I didn't like it at all at first. The only song that I really liked was the last song for a long time. But, I would put my iPod on shuffle and songs from Happy Hollow would come up from time to time and I really started to appreciate the songs one at a time. I would still say it is my least favorite Cursive album, but that still means it is better than a lot of that crap out there. I heard a couple of the new songs when they played in Omaha a few months back and they were really good. I can't wait to see them again in May.