Punknews.org

Get Up Kids / Superchunk / Hot Rod Circuit

Get Up Kids/Superchunk/Hot Rod Circuit: live in New York Citylive in New York City (2002)
Vagrant Records

Reviewer Rating: 3.5
User Rating:


Contributed by: kevtvkevtv
(others by this writer | submit your own)

Before going to this, I was oddly hesitant. The Get Up Kids first slew of releases are favorites of mine, but their new CD sometimes just doesn't rock where the rock is needed. I was rather skeptical going in, almost worried that I would leave the show much less a fan of their work. My only hope w.


Before going to this, I was oddly hesitant. The Get Up Kids first slew of releases are favorites of mine, but their new CD sometimes just doesn't rock where the rock is needed. I was rather skeptical going in, almost worried that I would leave the show much less a fan of their work. My only hope was that maybe the new songs that haven't taken a grasp of me will get a second chance after hearing them played live.

This show had some nerve being punctual. Guess that's what you get when it's held in a legit venue and not a VFW hall. As a result, I missed almost all of Hot Rod Circuit's set, which I wanted to catch. On the plus side, I walked in as they were playing the song I really wanted to hear, "The Pharmacist." After two more songs, Hot Rod Circuit was gone, gone, all gone.

With the layover before Superchunk, it's time to survey the crowd. Roseland fits a good amount of people and looks to almost be sold out. Lots of guys with girls, some who can't seem to can the public displays of affection. Buddy, I got news for you, I know she's your girlfriend without you having to kiss her every two seconds and wrap her in a bear hug.

Thankfully Roseland is more punctual than my grandmother and Sperchunk began their set after a very small amount of time. Now, I've only heard of Superchunk before this show. Somehow their music has eluded me over the years and I really have no excuse as to why. Last night, I found out I have some homework to do. Superchunk blasted through a rocking set that flew over the heads of half the audience who were unfortunately there just to see the headliners. After about 12 songs, Superchunk closed with their take on "Say My Name." Yes, the song by Destiny's Child. I never thought that could be pulled off, but their version was great and left their set on a high note.

The moment of truth soon arrived. Would the Get Up Kids still have that original spark that hot so many people hooked on them? The Get Up Kids opened with a song off of "On A Wire," "Let the Reigns Go Loose," and thankfully the song sounded a lot better and harder in a live setting. Compared to the CD version, the guitars were much louder and more prominent, giving the song the legs it needs.

Their set did have a heavy emphasis on new songs, which was expected, and most did indeed sound better live than my first impression of the new batch on their new CD. Suprise song of the set was theinclusion of "Up on A Roof," originally apprearing on their split 7" with Rocket From the Crypt. The furthest they went back into their catalog was their debut full-length "Four Minute Mile" for the songs "No Love" and the brilliant "Don't Hate Me."

The problem with their set was not how it sounded, but simply how it was arranged. Watching the crowd reaction was like watching waves in the ocean; it would peak when an older song was played and died down when a newer, slower song was played. The Get Up Kids opted to take the audience on an audio roller coaster as opposed to stringing similar-paced songs together. Also, the exclusion of songs like "Red Letter Day" and "Coming Clean" left some like myself hoping they would find their way into the encore.

Overall, I've seen them play a lot better (In fact, it was at Roseland where they gave the best performance I've seen them turn in when they successfully blew Weezer off of their own stage) but I didn't leave disappointed. The (Get Up) Kids have grown up, and in this bizarre scene which they are a part of, that takes a lot of courage to go against the grain and not do what is expected. For that, you can do nothing but respect them.

 

 
People who liked this also liked:
Killswitch Engage - Alive Or Just Breathing

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
Anonymous (July 20, 2002)

Buy Foolish, it might just be the greatest LP released in the last decade

Anonymous (July 17, 2002)

yo i was at that show also,and i couldnt agree with you more. superchunk kinda showed up the get upkids and i though it was pathetic that so many kids were so disrespectful to them and disregarded them, they werent so dissimilar to other bands they listen to. tguk weren tbad byut chose bad songs, i agree, they just for some reason didnt seem to excite me the way they did when i saw them in december but they still werent bad. hotrodcircuit sucked, ive seen them 5 times and this was by far the worst, theyre usually pretty good.

kevtv (July 16, 2002)

haha i know...any suggestions as to where i should start with their material? it's usually me giving out a ton of music suggestions, maybe someone couldhelp me with the rock power of superchunk

Anonymous (July 16, 2002)

damn right you've been missing out

kevtv (July 16, 2002)

to the guy who wrote "way to cover the other guys tracks", what u mean by that. my review sometimes is simlar to another write-up, which when i read it i just found oddly coincidental. i submitted my review before the other was posted, so i didn't rip anyone off.

also, i said i wasn't familar with who superchunk was because it was the the truth, i wasn't. i'm not some 14 year old kid who just got into music, superchunk is just one of those bands who never got attention form me and i wish that wasn't the case cause after seeing them live i feel like i've been missing out.

Anonymous (July 16, 2002)

I was at this show. I thought it rocked. i was a bit late and didn;t aniticpate such punctuality. I wound up missing all of hot rod as I was busy drinkin at Scuffy Duffys a few blocks away. at any rate, the show rocked. superchunk was awesome and "say my name" kicked ass. i thought the get-up kids set was awesome. and the reviewer was completely on the mark. they were jumpin all over the fuckin map with their songs.

Anonymous (July 16, 2002)

i wrote the first review to this tour, i rock!!!

Anonymous (July 15, 2002)

way to cover the other guys tracks.

evildeadalive (July 15, 2002)

How many goddamn reviews are we gonna have of this tour? Enough already.

tgarn (July 15, 2002)

You should have left that part out about you not knowing who superchunk is. Didnt you read the last review comments?

Anonymous (July 15, 2002)

Grrrr be on time to shows! if you were a band wouldn't you want people to be on time too? !

Contests

Exclusive Streams

Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Other Places to Go