Useless ID - Symptoms (Cover Artwork)

Useless ID

Useless ID: SymptomsSymptoms (2012)
Fat Wreck Chords

Reviewer Rating: 2.5
User Rating:

Contributed by: JimmyNorvilleJimmyNorville
(others by this writer | submit your own)

Let's get the short version of the review out of the way first: Have you heard The Lost Broken Bones? Yes? Did you like it? No? Then you won't like this. Yes? There is a decent chance you will enjoy this, although it won't exactly be breaking new ground. I haven't followed Useless ID's career too.
iTunes StoreAmazon

Let's get the short version of the review out of the way first: Have you heard The Lost Broken Bones? Yes? Did you like it? No? Then you won't like this. Yes? There is a decent chance you will enjoy this, although it won't exactly be breaking new ground.

I haven't followed Useless ID's career too much, so I'm not sure when they changed from the pop-punk band on Kung Fu Records to this sound--which I guess would still be called pop-punk, but has a darker tone with more aggression. For anyone unfamiliar with this sound, it is kind of like if No Use for a Name's Keep Them Confused wasn't so mellow. Of course if my attempt (and probable failure) to describe Useless ID's current noise isn't sufficient, you can watch the music video for "Before It Kills."

The album opens with "Live or Die," and the song starts fairly heavily (in pop-punk terms) and Yotam Ben Horin starts singing with a nice melody before beginning to shout. This is somewhat of a "theme" on the album--lots of clean singing and lots of shouting. The track is fairly bass heavy, with lots of drums, and easy to dance to. That too is something that recurs throughout the album.

Following that is "Before It Kills" (see the video above) followed by "Normal With You," which starts off very quiet and mellow before heavy drums come in. This is full on pop-punk. It is a similar sound to the previous tracks, but Horin's vocals sound a bit whinier (when they aren't being half-whispered to minimal music) and contains unmistakable relationship lyrics with lines like "Did he touch you the same way I did? / It doesn't really make much sense / The demon is out and he took my life / So please bring me an exorcist." The following track, "Erratic," also begins quietly before building up, but still stays midtempo, also containing undeniably pop-punk territory lyrics like "I was a misfit in my youth." "Manic Depression" starts off with a strong beat timed with "I've got the mad! Mad! Mad! Mad! Manic depression!" and, for a song about having manic depression, it is surprisingly light.

With "Sleeping with Knives," we get back to the lyricism found on Lost Broken Bones--personal, but metaphorical. I think this is where Horin's lyricism really shines with lines like "Outside your window, I've always been / I'm a vampire waiting to be led in." However, musically, it is one of the less catchy songs. And, in this case, the lyrics are a bit immature and fall into the "revenge" category that you'd hope a 33-year-old man would be above.

The titular track is a sort of love song with a chorus of "I want your love / I want your pain / I want your symptoms" that is sung calmly and slowly in a way that sounds like music you would hear in a dream sequence in a movie or something. The rest of the lyrics are sung normally and without any shouting. The song starts off fairly mellow and while some drums drop in before any singing begins, it stays quiet. Continuing the theme of mental health is "Obsessive Compulsive Disorder," which starts off heavy and then becomes mellow before getting back to the chorus (and opening lines) of "Your obsessive compulsive disorder creeps me out / I don't want it." However, digging deeper, the song sounds like a bitter song about an ex-girlfriend with lines like "Waiting for the perfect thrill / When you should stay the fuck away / Nothing seems to work / When the patient never takes her pills."

While a pop-punk staple is songs about being dumped, "New Misery" shows an example of how to (mostly) do it right. With a very, very catchy chorus of "I'm sick of feeling like a battery / The way you charge me up The way you empty me." Yes, a metaphor about being a battery is kind of corny, but it fully works in the song. The song is a bit more relatable than some of the others. "Waiting for an Accident" has the sound of an album closer and some more metaphorical lines like "Open the gates of Capricon / I'm walking into a field of thorns," but all too specific, bitter lines like "So, how does it feel to be in his arms / While you're falling asleep" still rear their ugly head. "Fear in the Mirror" is fairly repetitive, but perfectly adequate as one of the 12 tracks on the album. Album closer "Somewhere" has a slightly grandiose sound as Horen sings "I'm aware and it scares me inside" and the band bursts in to the previously very minimal song. But then it goes back to minimal. The song has a great tone and lyrics that almost make up for the petty, specific jabs throughout the rest of the album.

The main difference between 2008's Bones and Symptoms is that, in, Symptoms, the lyrics are more direct. I can't help but assume people will complain that it is too similar in sound, but I think they have managed to successfully do what many people seem to want from their favorite bands--the same album again. This is to say they didn't record the same album again, but they recorded an album that isn't doing anything new that might scare off fans of the previous album. As I've mentioned multiple times, there are too many bitter lines seemingly directed at a girl that left Horen that take me out of the songs. However, overall, the songs are enjoyable. The lines that make the listener sympathetic work drastically better than the ones that attempt to make the listener see this mystery woman as a bad person. Of course, the lyrics that are open to interpretation by the listener work best of all. This album probably isn't going to be album of the year for most people, but it is perfectly sufficient to listen to if you just want to enjoy some music. And hopefully, now that Symptoms has been released, Horen can quit being consumed by this bad relationship. Until another Useless ID album gets released, I'd personally recommend The Lost Broken Bones.


People who liked this also liked:
The Menzingers - Chamberlain WaitsFake Problems - It's Great to Be AliveAmerican Steel - Dear Friends and Gentle HeartsHeartsounds - Until We SurrenderBanner Pilot - Heart Beats PacificNOFX - CoasterMixtapes - Thought About Growing UpNOFX - Cokie the ClownFake Problems - Real Ghosts Caught on TapeOff with Their Heads - In Desolation

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
Mikeums14 (March 5, 2012)

I got hooked on these guys shortly after "The Lost Broken Bones" came out. Nasty good musicianship, lyrical spit, and some of the catchiest melodies I've ever heard. Seriously, their previous work can put shame to your "Million $$ American pop star & their producer" and these guys are punks from Israel working w/ Bill Stevenson. After that, I took the time to really get into some of their older albums like "Redemption," but not limited to it. That record also batted a thousand for the same reasons. So, once I heard about this release, I was seriously salivating. After numerous spins, this album was far lower than anything I was expecting from these guys, especially since they haven't released material in 3 yrs and would be getting the big opp to have their record put out on FAT (and the ability to seriously penetrate the American market, something I haven't seen them do exponentially well). "Symptoms" felt like a forced work w/ filler; really. Far from the passionate and witty melodic geniuses I know Useless ID can be. There are a few good songs to pick out... Yeah, but don't under estimate my enthusiasm: Their past albums are really that good. Don't let "Symptoms" spin you off.

punker001 (February 29, 2012)

Lost Broken Bones was much better! that album was great. This is ok but overall I was disappointed.

kylewagoner (February 28, 2012)

It's pretty...okay. Their brand of pop punk never really has knocked me off my feet, but I like them as people well enough that I bought it.

hayman (February 28, 2012)

Always been a big fan of these guys. They always kill it live too.
2 1/2 stars for this is a bit low. It's a solid album, better than most reviewed here.

Jeevz (February 28, 2012)

2 and a half, man

puddboy (February 28, 2012)

I like this album, especially in the beginning, but started liking it less and less the more I heard it. I think that's because this is a pretty garden-variety pop punk album. It's ok, not great, but pretty good...

'they played the songs I knew they would, some old, some new....'

mclz (February 28, 2012)

I know a lot of people didn't like the record, but I thought it was really good. Then again I've also like the last couple of NUFAN records as well.

Exclusive Streams


Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Managing Editor

Adam White

Contributing Editors

Kira Wisniewski Brittany Strummer Armando Olivas John Flynn Chris Moran John Gentile Mark Little

Copy Editor

Adam Eisenberg Britt Reiser

Podcast Producer

Greg Simpson


Aubin Paul

ISSN 1710-5366

© Copyright 1999-2013 Punknews.org

Terms of Use Privacy Policy Contact Us About Punknews.org

Other Places to Go