Thursday / onelinedrawing / From Autumn To Ashes / Planes Mistaken For Stars

Thursday / onelinedrawing / From Autumn To Ashes / Planes Mistaken For Stars: live in Milwaukeelive in Milwaukee (2002)
Victory Records

Reviewer Rating: 3.5

Contributed by: Ryanryan
(others by this writer | submit your own)

I went to this show most anxious to see Planes Mistaken for Stars. I have all of their releases and think they deserve more credit than they've received so far. When we got to the show, my friend Simon and I immediately approached the merch booth and talked to Planes. They were great guys. I thi.

I went to this show most anxious to see Planes Mistaken for Stars. I have all of their releases and think they deserve more credit than they've received so far. When we got to the show, my friend Simon and I immediately approached the merch booth and talked to Planes. They were great guys. I think they were surprised anyone knew what they looked like and had seen em and shit. Word.

Planes took the stage and tore it apart. They rocked all the badass songs from their albums, including "Bastards," a song from the new ep. Totally killer. It was cool being able to see their drummer this time around.

From Autumn to Ashes came on, and we watched a song, and decided they sucked. We decided to go smoke weed with Planes, so we went backstage with em. Seriously, I thought they were satanic and all this, but they are great guys. We got so high, it was a blast. The rest of FATA's set sucked. Their drummer sang some songs, but he had a fucking horrible voice. I can't bellieve people are so into this band. I guess it's their emo bandname that fits in so well these days. Pussies. Fuck you all.

Next was onelinedrawing, aka a good Chris Carraba with an electric guitar and an R2D2 that played taped beats. This guy was badass and looks like Ben Stiller. Great voice, great set.

Thursday took stage and of course the place went nuts immediately. All the while, I was thinking, these people should have been doing this for Planes. Anyways. Thursday rocked it as usual. I've seen em six times now, and it was a little disappointig that in the past year and a half, they've added one song to their repetoire. Steve had a Cursive shirt on, though. That was cool.

That was my show experience. Pretty fun, and a LOT of hot girls.


People who liked this also liked:
Blue Sky Mile - Blue Sky MileSlomo Rabbit Kick - Bass Monster Lives In The Bass Forest

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
Anonymous (March 20, 2004)

You're a bunch of fucking idiots. Theres no such thing as a non one-sided review.

I bet if he wrote a review on how badass FATA is and how hot their tight black clothes, gauged ears, and studded belts looked, you would love him for it.

Some of these comments by you people make me want to go to a FATA show just to do some round house kicks and kick some of your fuckers faces in. Oooh yea... i think they play Milwaukee on Saturday, I might have to go. MALLCORE KIDS BEWARE.


Also, please do not call FATA hardcore you fucking teenybopper posers. How about emo-pussy scream-shit-rock? That sounds good to me.

I'm going to do a line of coke now. See you on Saturday fuckers.

Anonymous (February 21, 2004)

anyone whos defending FATA is a little bitch, they are the worst excuse for hardcore ive ever heard, its like hot topic created this band so they could sell shirts. fata=pussy ass emo shit
PMFS= kick ass

Anonymous (November 30, 2003)

actually i think more people like planes cuz they are "scary" and not like the rest of the momma's boys in punk and hardcore bands these days.

its refershing to see a band come out and kick ass who arent a bunch of 19 year olds "dressing up as punk kids".

planes are the real deal.

Anonymous (May 30, 2003)

It seems to me that no one likes Planes, just because they are a little scary. Bands like FATA ou can bring home to mom and not worry about them getting her stoned and fucking her on the coffee table.

Anonymous (May 4, 2003)

bitches and hoes man, bitches and hoes

Anonymous (May 4, 2003)

to the guy that asked if the reveiwer was in Phish i say this: BURN!

Anonymous (January 25, 2003)

PMFS was by far the best band on that show.

All you kids who just got into the scene about 3 weeks ago need to grab PMFS' first two records on Deep Elm to see where all these new school poser bands are ripping off their sound from.

And the reviewer had it right the first time. PMFS = Satan. You put all the bands on this tour in a room together for a month without food, PMFS will walk out with a big bag of bones.

Anonymous (December 3, 2002)

big tittied bitches on my erectile dong..fata has got it all wrong...they sing about getting dumped and pussy shit in their song(s)..their brutal performance ensures me they wont live long....

Anonymous (November 25, 2002)

yea this show sucked except for thursday. the review also sucks. that is all.

Anonymous (November 25, 2002)

good no nonsense personally subjective review.

word is bond.

Anonymous (November 24, 2002)

Can you email me a picture of yourself? You see, I'm writing a dictionary and I need a picture for the words "meathead" and "dildo".

Anonymous (November 24, 2002)

Pussy fucking pothead im sure you only came to see that 80's hair band looking thing Planes Mistaken For Stars. After 2 songs at there Chicago show people were booing them and yelling shit like " you look like Andrew WK".
FATA came on next and the place blew up while your in the back smoking pot with the mountain men we were all in the pit enjoying what we paid for.

Anonymous (November 22, 2002)

Coke was big in the 80s and part of the late 70s. Now it's a suburban yuppie drug for people that can't let go of their highscool social order.

Anonymous (November 22, 2002)

What's wrong with smoking pot? If you don't like it, that's fine, but get a life if you look down on people for doing it. Let me guess. It makes you stupid? I'd say a good % of people that post here are fucking idiots and I'll bet a lot of them don't smoke pot. Seems some of you believe all the bullshit you were taught in school.

Anonymous (November 22, 2002)

fata... good band... still fucking clean-core

Anonymous (November 21, 2002)

coke was really in the 70s but its making a come back

all the ravers do x..its a nice drug though

burstandbloom (November 21, 2002)

No, all the cool kids sniff coke. How do you think the indie rock kids keep their figures?

SoftcoreDan (November 21, 2002)

when i saw fata open for snapcase, ended their set by bringing out melanie (i think that's her name) and did "short stories with tragic endings," and i got friggin chills...such an awesome band, even if they gave my friend the death stare in syracuse.....

oh yeah, smoking weed is so 1969. all the cool kids are on ecstasy now. bastard.

Anonymous (November 21, 2002)

The review was terrible. I was expecting to read about how the bands fared, not Ryan. I've never heard of Ryan and until he comes out with a decent record, I don't give a fuck what he does.

Anonymous (November 21, 2002)

what the fuck? why the fuck does it matter if he smokes weed? people make that such a big fucking deal, like oohhh weed is so stupid and bad. great, then don't smoke, but shut the fuck up and don't pass judgement on other people. and i thought his review was entertaining. way to go.

Anonymous (November 21, 2002)

I think that what we have here is a classic case of someone "liking" a boring and sucky band like Planes Mistaken for Stars simply for those reasons: that they are boring and suck. Kids say that said band is progressive and interesting and that they "rock", when in fact the only reason that they pretend to like them is because noone else will ever like them and the band will therefore stay "underground." Making anyone who likes the sucky band who doesn't get popular cool, and anyone who actually has good taste in music and likes equally good bands (who often get popular because they are good)is a poser and a loser because other kids actually found out how good a certain band is and the band isn't as underground now as they used to be. Some bands, like Planes Mistaken for Stars, never blow up for a reason: they fucking suck.

FeedMyNightmare (November 20, 2002)

HAHA right on with this review. Smoking pot is so bad for you...heh. Anyways, PMFS were the best band on this tour and only a handfull of people rocked out. This I cant understand. Then FATA comes on, looking like they jus came out of Hot Topic with their perfect hair and manicured nails..Kids start to jump around and look all stupid. I hate fashion core more than anything.

BurstAndBloom (November 20, 2002)

"I guess it's their emo bandname that fits in so well these days. Pussies. Fuck you all."

and PLANES MISTAKEN FOR STARS is so fucking macho?


Anonymous (November 20, 2002)


"yeah dude! we got hiiiigh as a kite with PMFS!"

You get a 1 star."

cool, brah(insert so. cal accent) no, i give the reviewer 5 stars for knowing, and liking PMFS, and another 5 for getting high with them. I would've given him another 5 stars if he got high on coke with them but anyway...
what is the deal with these fucking names..ooh so pretty and mysterious..From Autumn to Ashes, beautiful..the Early November..nice...Your Night Sky..creative...now i havent heard these bands but the names blow

Anonymous (November 20, 2002)

judging a band by it's looks proves you're all a bunch of lightweight posers.

Anonymous (November 20, 2002)

answer me this, (i saw this show in pitt) why is it that pmfs can come out looking more like a metal band than anything else (i.e. the lead singers long hair, the drummers braided beard, and no shirts) tell the tech guy to use all the lights and smoke and shit, and completely rock and everyone stands around with their fingers in their asses..... BUT... when fata comes out (i like them too i honestly do) looking all prettied up like they always do (seen 'em 3 times and they always have nice sideburns and the one guy has the vintage denim jean jackets that match the jeans) and play some hardcore stuff that people are like flipping out for, then have these slow ass breakdowns... people continue to dance through,HOW CAN YOU DANCE THROUGH A FATA BREAKDOWN i don't understand it

I GOT THE BEST DESCRIPTION OF FATA - CLEANCORE... honestly, anyone whos seen them live can't say otherwise

Anonymous (November 20, 2002)

Planes Mistaken for Stars... yeah they sucked. What a joke. I was prepared to leave when their fat-ass drummer peeled off his shirt, and then they began to sing a song about fucking. They continued playing while bunching together in a big group as I was convinced they were fucking eachother. But luckily my mind wasn't totally scarred for at that point From Autumn to Ashes came on and changed my perspective of what was beginning to be a shitty show. It continued on to be a great show, as Thursday, naturally, rocked.

Anonymous (November 20, 2002)


"yeah dude! we got hiiiigh as a kite with PMFS!"

You get a 1 star.

Anonymous (November 20, 2002)

this review was right on.

Anonymous (November 20, 2002)

I would personally like to cyber-shake this guy's hand. PMFS is completely underrated. Through multiple aggresively innovative releases, they still opened up for a local band in STL. Lame.

While the guys from Thursday are occupying the stalls to throw up their pizza in effort to save their girlish figures, PMFS are hunting down Carson Daly, screwing chicks, killing cats and playing circles around FATA.

onelinedrawing... eh, we all have our guilty pleasures. R2D2, don't front.


Anonymous (November 20, 2002)

yeah your review sucks and FATA is awesome. every other band just sounds all plain emo and gay.

Anonymous (November 20, 2002)

You're all entitled to your opinions, but what's the point in saying "they rulled, they sucked, he was cool, they were okay"? You're saying nothing about the fucking show at all, it's almost like you just wanted to jump in and write something before anyone else just to say you did.

I personally like all of these bands though, and I really don't understand all this animosity towards FATA. I saw them open for Shai Hulud a while back and will be seeing them again in December most anxiously. They put on a great show with a lot of energy and do a great job melding together varuious forms of metal. Just because you don't like metal (which you obviously don't) doesn't mean a band sucks. And don't go yelling at me that FATA aren't metal - I know they're not a metal band, but they do blend (and very well, by the way) bits of black and death metal with hardcore (and nice melodic breakdowns) very nicely.

I'm really pissed we didn't get a lineup like this in Hollywood - Although Thrusday with Cursive and Poison the Well was really badass.

tgarn (November 19, 2002)

it would actually be chris caraba is a jonah with an acoustic guitar, seeing onelinedrawing came first

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

ya but it about sums up my feelings of the chicago show too.

planes, old, and thursday all kicked ass. fata sucked.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

Horrible horrible horrible review, you suck.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

oh, my mistake. frats are about drinking, not smoking.

so you must be in phish?

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

planes did fucking tear it apart (new ep is great)and though i think fata are okay, they were not nearly as good as i thought they would be. jonah was amazing and so was thursday. good show and pretty good review, though i was gonna review this show, too late--emptycauses

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

I wanted to go to this show, but couldn't find a ride....I'm pissed.

evildeadalive (November 19, 2002)

"Jonah Mantagra (One Line Drawing) sounds absolutley nothing like Chris Carabba, Jonah writes about everything in life, not jsut about girls, and his feelings ar soooo much more raw then chris's. Jonah also varies at his styles unlike every song sounding almost the same. I think Chris is a good artist, but I think that Jonah is 100000X's better."

Uhhh, did you notice that he said good things about onelinedrawing, and actually called him "a good Chris Carraba", which certainly implies he's a lot better? I guess not, the review must have been too long to read. That's cool.

Well, I actually kinda liked this review to tell you the truth, even though I absolutely hate marajuana. I thought it was kinda fresh and honest. One guys interpretation of a show without breaking out his thesaurus.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

The only PMFS cd I have is Fuck With Fire, my question is - Why are the vocals so goddamn low? I can hardly hear the singer.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

haha, what a great fucking review... Fuck Thursday, FATA and whatever other flavor of the month played the show. Planes is one of the best, most intense and unique bands to ever hit the scene. If you don't own any of their albums do yourself a huge favor, trade in some of your bullshit emo cds and by "Fuck With Fire" or any of the albums for that matter. If you dont like planes I'd go as far as to say you don't know good music...

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

FATA are great.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

If by "hot" you mean "fat, ugly, dirty, nasty ass hardcore ugly girls", then yea, I agree.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

Wow, you need to listen a little closer to the music before you group it with someone else.

Jonah Mantagra (One Line Drawing) sounds absolutley nothing like Chris Carabba, Jonah writes about everything in life, not jsut about girls, and his feelings ar soooo much more raw then chris's. Jonah also varies at his styles unlike every song sounding almost the same. I think Chris is a good artist, but I think that Jonah is 100000X's better.

If you watched his stage show it is also incredible. He is a very moving person, and he knows how to work a crowd, from past experiences in his bands, New End Original, and Far.

So pay attention if you plan on doing a review on someone, people actually read these things and you dont want to give them the wrong impression.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

Why bother even post this review, this guy is an idiot..

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

Hey everyone, this is Ryan, the guy who wrote that awesome review

I got a good laugh out of all your comments, thanks to the supporters, i couldn't have done it without you

Planes was the best band on the tour, anyone who disagrees can suck my sphincter

Weed is good for the mind, good for the soul

I am NOT in a frat...last time i checked, frats were about drinking, not smoking...you fuckin douche


Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

this tour sux..

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

yea, that review sucked but pmfs is amazing, even more so live than on record...fata is too generic for my tastes and one line drawing was one of the best shows ive ever been to, playing at thunderdome (rip) in tallahassee with further seems forever..amazing stuff

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

Personally, i think all those bands are really good. I havent much of PMFS, but i'll check it out. FATA are really good, damn good players. Thursday playing a FAR song, that must of been just the best. Only downside, weed sucks. makes people fucking stupid.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

Awesome review. Smoking tha dizzank.


Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

this is the worst review of a show i have ever seen. pussy. PMFS sucked, FATA was 10000 times better, go smoke yourself stupid.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

10 bucks the girls weren't really hot at all, that was the weed taking over his senses..

fallingtopieces (November 19, 2002)

WOW!!!!! that has to be the best way to conclude a review EVER. Instead of a wrap up/ final thought, its hot chicks, nice. I'm actually going to change my conclusion on the essay im writing tonight to "Hippie chicks who protest are SIZZLIN'"

ok that wasnt funny, but i dont care its like 3 am and im delirious

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

i think this guy should go join the buddyhead staff.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

one of the shittiest reviews on this site. and that is really saying something considering how many terrible reviews there are. but hey, you're a cool dude anyways, i mean, you smoked weed, right? only the cool people smoke weed.

WussEmoRock (November 19, 2002)

hahahaha. As much as that review was horrible and didn't say anything about the show, just which bands sucked and who he smoked with, it was still funny as hell and entertaining to read.


Hamish (November 19, 2002)

Actually, I really enjoyed that review (though probably for the wrong reasons). And he was right about the bands too, PMFS, onelinedrawing and Thursday are great. FATA is a fucking joke. Onelinedrawing shows are just about the funnest shows around (though preferably in an extremely intimate setting), I'm seeing him on thursday and it's gonna be a blast.

TheBouncingSoul (November 19, 2002)

I went to this show, and Planes fucking sucked.....

not as bad as your review though

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

In Chicago, Thursday covered the Far song "Mother Mary," and they even had Jonah sing it. It was a great experience. Jonah is so good live, it really is something to see him.

pwfanatic (November 19, 2002)

i'm not even gonna waste my time saying why this is the shittiest, most one-sided, juvenile review i have ever read in the longest time.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

this is the most ridiculous review i've ever read. made me laugh.


Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

"...and had seen em and shit. Word."

what the fuck? we're you high when you wrote this too?

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

jonah rocks. onelinedrawing, new end original, and FAR! it's a shame Far is no more. and this would have been a great show. i love every band.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

...um.. why was this review even posted?

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

i found this review more entertaining than 95% of the others

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

no more reviews for you.

"i went and smoked weed with planes." man you're lame.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

haha, that comment about the reviewer being in a frat gave me a good laugh.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

Boo, only three sentences for OneLineDrawing what are you on?

- Scott
(I should have reviewed Pittsburgh's)

Anonymous (November 18, 2002)

this is quite possibly the most ridiculous review ever.

are you in a frat?

Anonymous (November 18, 2002)

pmfs is the best band around. this guy had it right.

Exclusive Streams


Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Managing Editor

Adam White

Contributing Editors

Kira Wisniewski Brittany Strummer Armando Olivas John Flynn Chris Moran John Gentile Mark Little

Copy Editor

Adam Eisenberg Britt Reiser

Podcast Producer

Greg Simpson


Aubin Paul

ISSN 1710-5366

© Copyright 1999-2013 Punknews.org

Terms of Use Privacy Policy Contact Us About Punknews.org

Other Places to Go