|
Review Navigator   FeaturesReviews
 | Phantom PlanetPhantom Planet2004 Epic 
 Review by: Scott See others by this writer ![[staff]](/images/icons/staffsticker.gif){kind=icon}
Phantom Planet (link) Only registered users can post comments 
 
Published on January 30th 2004
Say goodbye to Phantom Planet, the one hit wonder. Say goodbye to Phantom Planet, posterboys for "The OC." Say goodbye to Phantom Planet, "that band with the guy from Rushmore in it." People who liked this also liked:           Please login or register to post comments. What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
Wastes of flesh? Cmon man put a little effort into it these two bickering losers need to just get it out of their systems and hate fuck each other...alright, we get it. you two are both ignorant and juvenile, its not that funny. now start making out, you wastes of flesh. Sara is my favorite manatee. She's my bestest friend ever. pixies reference for sarah(no h). i can't think of that one off the top of my head. are you comparing it to jeffery with one f? the amount of time huh. I'm not even on that often. I know you secretly wish I was. I know you get so excited when you see my name on this site. I associate my girlfiend not flushing her used tampons with "the rag" With the amount of time and effort you spend on this website its obvious that you aint gettin no dick right now. You can't tell me you're not shopping at lane bryant. OH, you wish I was fat. Guys always associate being on "the rag" as a factor for being "pissy". You guys really need to take a sexuality class. Why don't you guys try getting a girlfriend. "Sara(no h)" "you're pointless. Face it, everything you do doesn't matter. Why are you even here? You're not going to save the world one day. You're not going to cure a disease. Why did your parents make you? Because it was fun and it felt good. It just sucks that you were the outcome. I don't enjoy the fact that you're here, but I bet your parents enjoyed making you. Now go fuck yourself. twat" "this didn't sound like a scott review." i haven't gotten any pussy since the day i was born, so anything is good enough for me Hey twat I apologize for being such a cunt. I've been on the rag and there really isnt any excuse for my behavior. The truth is that I want you inside me. But I'm horribly overweight and would crush you. Sara, i'm sorry i'm just really bored and retarded. i honestly apologize for my moronic insults. So are you... Naked haahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha... Ha. You people are funny. C'mon now, ripping off the Strokes on THIS record? I don't hear it. I fucking love those poodle haired hipsters tho. I'll be damned if Phantom Planet is gonna tarnish their image in my mind. This record is getting glossier by the second This is fun. Keep sweet talkin me. I'm sorry your peen is so small that you couldn't satisfy your girl, and as a result she became a hairy lesbian. Not all girls hate men, and are lesbian. Girls just don't like your small smelly dick. You're the one with the hatred of men. Maybe this homophobia of yours is because you're actually in denial. If you're a lesbian, I'm cool with it. Not if you're fat or ugly like I'm pretty sure you are. Ugly lesbians suck. It's cause alot of you guys are stupid. Whenever someone states an opinion and someone else doesn't agree they start name calling. And then it becomes this attack/defense position. Maybe some of you need to stop reading reviews if you're so emotional about it. man, twat might just be more hated than me. congrats, it's a tough act to keep up. http://www.punknews.org/article.php?sid=7634 I only asked if you were at first. Now I'm pretty sure you are. Now shut up you dumb ass. Stop trying so hard. How can you say I'm a "white trash woman basher" when you're calling me a fag? You be a hypocrite. Silly little girl needs to make up her mind. Isn't it about time you call daddy up for some more money. you're as gay as they come. Stop overcomponsating with you're white trash woman bashing it doesn't fool me. hey sara with a c-u-n-t, where in my little rant did i say i actually like this band? Um thats right i didn't. I just like to argue. Whats with the gay bashing you homophobe? This isn't elementary school. If you like someone you don't pull their hair or call them a fag. If you want my cock just tell me. wah wah wah. You must be on the Phantom Planet Street team or something. Are you gay like Alex Greenwald? Don't be sad cause you're shitty band sucks. this didn't sound like a scott review. This score is the reward that "twat" will get if he can tell me what that word means...without looking it up. twat....yeah man, you told them. YOU ARE ONE ROUGH TUMBLER. GRRRRRR Twat puts way too much time and effort into trying to piss people off... This score is for the soundtrack to Rushmore. The Creation are great, I didn't mind the revitalized interest. Slackers was a highly underated movie. Is it sara with a c-u-n-t? Is that how you spell it? Cuz ya should. My name is john but with a h-u-g-e-c-o-c-k. Your parents are retarded. It's funny that everyone says that phantom planet is totally ripping off the strokes. But the strokes didn't exactly write the handbook for this shit now did they? Can anyone say velvet underground? gang of four ring any bells. now all of you kindly suck my balls. you're pointless. Face it, everything you do doesn't matter. Why are you even here? You're not going to save the world one day. You're not going to cure a disease. Why did your parents make you? Because it was fun and it felt good. It just sucks that you were the outcome. I don't enjoy the fact that you're here, but I bet your parents enjoyed making you. Now go fuck yourself. phantom planet went from sounding like one or two other bands to sounding like 700 other bands. this isn't a really bad album, it's just pointless. This is a pretty catchy album, but after listening to this for a week, it just gets left on the cd shelf. Maybe it lost it's lasting power. HAHAHAHAHA...ripping on The Strokes is sooooo funny. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA, you are now punk, baby! Woooo! I still propose a movie section to this site. I just read through all of the comments, and I think someone said the Strokes were a good band. I'm not sure how to respond. i just watched the music video. It started out ok with what looked like a frat version of "Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba" then turned into a super awesome genuis zombie video! Then fucked it up with the emo ending. Now i'm all pissed. hmmm? I never noticed the Hot Hot Heat influence but I certainly do now. In other news of this record, I heard one of my rmates playing "Big Brat" a few months ago upon ripping this disc from soulseek (WE FUCKING PAY FOR MUSIC SO SHUT THE FUCK UP ALREADY) I thought hmmm this is the best Blur song I've heard in years, then I found out it was Phantom Planet. I kinda figured that they were going to go for a Hellacopters sound this time around. "rushmore, rushmore, rushmore, (slackers), donnie darko, rushmore, rushmore, models, actors, rushmore, the strokes". you fruits are giving me a headache. le sigh. the kid from rushmore was the drummer in the band, but he left recently. wait, so is this that band with the guy from Rushmore in it or not? Big Brat is a catchy little single, but really, this album is a lop of shit. This line really sums up the album: "If this band were still underground, New York hipsters would be wetting themselves over this album" doesnt it have the bully from donnie darko in the band too? hes totally core man. yeah i miss the old phantom planet... wow, maybe i should give it a chance... I don't know how I feel about this. To say that this album has a "hard" edge is a tad mis-leading in my opinion. Underneath it all there seems to still be a glossy-our singer is a model/actor feel to it. I like it, but I don't love it. shittiest review scott....if you put the effort into your reviews that you put into letting people know how you're a fucking straight edge/anti drug/anti sex moron maybe they'd be good. i love you LOVE TO FUCKING THROW THAT CRAP AROUND. i need to hear this. "on respones to your whole new band comment, what do you expect when u lose what 3 out of 5 memebers?" Yeah, it seems like they did hit the garage rock fad, but they do it REALLY WELL. They took a hint from what's hippin' and hoppin' these days, and they made great songs. Just because a band's style is somewhat cliché to the time period doesn't mean the songs are going to be any less good. Badd Business is a rocker, fo' sho'. How can you say this is better? All they really did was jump on the band wagon of all the popular bands these days, for example THE STROKES (good band),The Vines and all that polished to be "unpolished" crap. I have no idea what this cd wants to be. It's badd. on respones to your whole new band comment, what do you expect when u lose what 3 out of 5 memebers? Agreed. |
