Punknews.org

Clann Z

Clann Z: Black Coats & BandagesBlack Coats & Bandages (2004)
G7 Welcoming Committee Records

Reviewer Rating: 4


Contributed by: adamAdam
(others by this writer | submit your own)

Clann Zú's change of direction on their sophomore record is astonishingly risky. Much of the charm of their first record Rua came from the original amalgamation of traditional Celtic elements with modern (at times electronic) percussion and very genuine lyrical vitriol. This was the backdrop for a s.


Clann Zú's change of direction on their sophomore record is astonishingly risky. Much of the charm of their first record Rua came from the original amalgamation of traditional Celtic elements with modern (at times electronic) percussion and very genuine lyrical vitriol. This was the backdrop for a set of sorrowful, dark (to the point of gothic) songs of Irish cultural reclamation. The mix was at times quite lively, with busy violins clashing over impassioned vocals; a few songs were even compared to DJ Shadow's work and bordered on being outright danceable. Compared to that record Black Coats & Bandages is completely raw, shockingly so. It's a record of mid to slow paced ballads, sparely arranged and sparsely produced. The prevailing theme in the title track (and the band's press) is `funeral oration.'

The enjoyably different Irish instrumentation has been for the most part completely dropped. Frontman Declan de Barra never screams an angry tirade like Rua's defining "Words For Snow," his vocal delivery is far more subtle and measured. The vocalist' s understated falsetto calls to mind Radiohead's Thom Yorke (albeit with less of a whine). With that in mind I was quite ready to write this record off. It seemed clear to me that Clann Zú had sacrificed the fun, aggressive and hooky parts of their sound for something more artistic. While that will likely thrill the indie crowd that feeds on such ostentatious tripe, blissfully moronic Ramones songs can still far too easily satisfy my own tastes.

...

Yet I didn't even believe that was my opinion of a band I was in love with last year and rather stubbornly put off this review. While their sound has certainly evolved there was certainly nothing that felt shallow about this album or the band's delivery. I wasn't "getting it," plain and simple. That was the problem and I knew it.

It was not until I forced a change in atmosphere that Black Coats & Bandages truly clicked for me. It's a step I wouldn't take for most groups, but most groups haven't proved themselves to be worth the effort like this one. I write this sitting here late at night, in complete darkness and free of any distraction. It's here, when the record can entirely control the mood, that the brilliant, genre bending Clann Zú of ol' emerges.

Songs like "So Complicated Was The Fall" benefited most from this atmosphere. The band's trademark violins move hauntingly across the track, one of the record's heavier songs instrumentally. There's a moment of screeching guitar work near the song's conclusion that sounds dangerously abrasive. The bass driven, Irish language "t-éan bn" channels Disintegration era Cure at times, a record that shares Black Coats' pacing. There's a sudden blast of distortion that emerges in the piano driven "One Bedroom Apartment" that feels hugely cathartic. It's a curious effect that emerges more than a few times across the album's ten songs: de Barra's fragile vocal delivery will unexpectedly be countered with an outburst of violent instrumental dissonance that drives home his anger with a spectacular lack of subtlety.

Black Coats & Bandages is a dark, quiet record. It's not a casual listen and in that lies my difficulty in initially grasping it. It's certainly doesn't suit the season it was released in by any stretch of the imagination. This is a moody, deeply personal document that demands the proper attention for it to work its charms. Give it that and you'll be rewarded.

Clann Zú - There Will Be No Morning Copy
Clann Zú - From Bethlehem To Jenin

 

 
People who liked this also liked:
Bomb the Music Industry! - ScramblesThe Decay / Wayfarer - DecayfarerFugazi - The ArgumentDear Landlord - Dream HomesClann Z - RuaThe Futureheads - News and TributesThe Stickup - Please, DiseaseThe Good, The Bad and The Queen - The Good, The Bad and The QueenThe Riptides - Hang OutNothington - All In

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
DenBez (July 30, 2006)

Best album of the last forever.

Anonymous (March 31, 2005)

Best of the new millenium

Anonymous (August 3, 2004)

I love this album. From Bethleham to Jenin is a hauntingly beatiful song

noreply (June 10, 2004)

i like this alot

Anonymous (June 7, 2004)

I can tell by reading your review that your full of shit

Anonymous (June 5, 2004)

I like this better than rua.

Anonymous (June 5, 2004)

hey hey salior. uummmmm. check out their website.

Anonymous (June 5, 2004)

I agree 100% with your review. It is by no means RUA, but it has those subtle moments of genius that shine through. Hopefully their next will be a summation of the two rather than another spastic change in pace.

-duped

Anonymous (June 4, 2004)

the songs that i've heard have been unbelievably good...

this is hands down one of the best bands on earth at the moment.

Anonymous (June 4, 2004)

this is the best cd of the year. and next year. and the year after that , and the year before last.

hey_sailor (June 4, 2004)

Alright...this doesn't have anything to do with Clann Zu, but does anyone know what the fuck Propagandhi are doing right now? Wasn't it like 2 years ago that they were working on a cover album and the follow-up to "Today's Empires"?

Exclusive Streams

Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Other Places to Go