Cave In

Cave In: Creative EclipsesCreative Eclipses (1999)
Hydra Head Records

Reviewer Rating: 2.5

User Rating:

Contributed by: slippyslippy
(others by this writer | submit your own)
Published on November 12th 2004So here's Cave In's first non-metal release. I thought it would be important to review this record, considering the creative changes that the band has gone through; this is where it really took shape (although there were some telling moments on Until Your Heart Stops). And no, this doesn't sound a.

So here's Cave In's first non-metal release. I thought it would be important to review this record, considering the creative changes that the band has gone through; this is where it really took shape (although there were some telling moments on Until Your Heart Stops). And no, this doesn't sound a lot like the commercial hard rock of Antenna, though you can tell it's the same band.

On this 5 song EP, there are 2 original songs, and one of them is acoustic. "Luminance" is the heavy one, and it's one of the best songs Cave In has written. Everything clicks on it- the nervous drum rolls, crazy guitar effects, and the ability to make powerful and heavy music without screaming the whole time. The acoustic song is pretty decent, though it lacks the emotional weight of "Luminance" and sort of pales in comparison. Then there is the Failure cover, "Magnified". It's a good song and a great choice for a cover since it sounds so much like Cave In material. However, like the acoustic track, it can't measure up to "Luminance", and on a 5 track CD, it hurts.

So there are 2 tracks left to talk about, "Sonata Mcgrath" and "Sonata Brodsky". Both are electronic instrumental songs, in the vein of Aphex Twin's "Selected Ambient Works Volume II" or something by Boards of Canada without the beats. The problem is, neither song can measure up to something by the aformentioned groups, and while they can be good mood setters or background music, they just aren't much to get excited about.

So that's the whole record- one great song, two decent songs, and two electronic things that make me go "Eh." The CD just doesn't hold up to repeated listens. I'd recommend downloading "Luminance" instead of buying this whole CD, unless you are a real Cave In fan, and you want to listen to their interesting progression. If you want some great Cave In, try Until Your Heart Stops or Jupiter.

Login to rate this album

People who liked this also liked:

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?

Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.

Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.

InnuendoAndOutTheOther (November 16, 2004)

this score is for anything this band has ever done...AMAZING

all 3 of the actual tracks are awesome "Luminance" and "Magnified" being the stronger of the 2

Anonymous (November 15, 2004)

pretty great EP. i agree that luminance is a great song, but i think youre not giving the acoustic song enough credit. thats up there with my favorite cave in songs. i'd say "jupiter" is the best of theirs. if the new album is anything like the demos i heard, it will be embarrassingly bad

Anonymous (November 15, 2004)

shudder SEAFROST is a fucking brilliant piece of work.

Barkley

Anonymous (November 14, 2004)

When they played baltimore they played "sea frost" from Antenna

Anonymous (November 14, 2004)

ataxaria is GREAT. they also played world in my way when i saw them and i loved it. good times.

Anonymous (November 13, 2004)

Its funny tho in regards to them not playing anything from Antenna, this show was about three weeks after the official RCA roster posting-I almost knew they weren't going to play anything. However...they opened with Big Riff, which fucking killed-absolutely killed. They played two new ones-World is in the Way, and that one with the big delay part and the chorus that says "Mindset into Motion" Stream of Commerce, Juggernaut, and a some others that I can't remember (I was drinking Quebecois ale and I was gassed) They asked the crowd if anybody had "downloaded their new demos" to some applause. I kept screaming "Ataxia" that monstrous instrumental song that they demoed.

Barkley

Anonymous (November 13, 2004)

Cave In are absolutely terrible. This isn't flamebait, it's just the truth. If you like pretentious, yet lifeless wanking, this is for you.

Anonymous (November 13, 2004)

antenna is indeed a well written, well played, well produced (not over-produced) rock record. not amazing by any means, but a good, solid record.

that's odd that they didn't play any antenna songs when you saw them. they played 2 when i saw them a few weeks ago (2 from antenna, 2 from jupiter, 2 from until your heart stops and 2 new ones, great set).

Anonymous (November 13, 2004)

It's 10:00 PM. Do you know where your mom is?

www.milfhunter.com

slippy (November 13, 2004)

I liked Antenna despite its flaws but it can't compare to Jupiter.

Anonymous (November 13, 2004)

barkley, you're dead right. antenna is an amazing record that gets panned by hard-headed 'hardcore' kids (and unfortunately, the band themselves). musical progression from album to album is beautiful and necessary. embrace it, love it, go with the flow. just because they dont scream anymore, doesn't mean that it's not harcore.