Explosions in the Sky / Eluvium / Caroline

Explosions in the Sky/Eluvium/Caroline: live in New Yorklive in New York (2006)
Temporary Residence

Reviewer Rating: 4.5

Contributed by: danperroneDan Perrone
(others by this writer | submit your own)

It's been a decade since well-respected label Temporary Residence launched; with the plethora of excellent albums released by the group, the number of their bands that have seen a recent jump in popularity, and the high-profile signings they've made, who wouldn't want to celebrate their tenth birthd.

It's been a decade since well-respected label Temporary Residence launched; with the plethora of excellent albums released by the group, the number of their bands that have seen a recent jump in popularity, and the high-profile signings they've made, who wouldn't want to celebrate their tenth birthday? A three-night stand at the Bowery Ballroom in New York City, with four different Temporary Residence acts each night, was the party they threw, and not even Hurricane Ernesto was going to stop me from dropping by one of the nights. I attended the second show of the three, featuring one of my personal favorite and one of the most important bands in music today, Explosions in the Sky.

Soaked, freezing, and out twelve bucks for a cab, we waited forty-five minutes after doors opened for the opening act to come on, an indie rock group named Lazarus. The focal point of the group is the enormous vocalist and acoustic guitarist, a man who probably stood six foot seven, looming over the crowd as the band began to play material from their three albums. They played acoustic indie rock with keyboards and percussion, and although they used some electric guitar and xylophone rather well, their performance was unremarkable and wasn't enough to hold my interest for too long. I give them a 5/10, simply for talent.

Caroline's mixture of cutesy pop music and atmospheric, almost ambient music is a flawless combination, and she's got an interesting voice as well. It was only her and her friend on stage, in front of Mac computers with God-knows-what on the screen, which was a little awkward at first. During the second song, "All I Need," her computer actually crashed, leaving her high and dry and leaving the crowd rather embarrassed; the recovery was quick though, and she continued on, albeit with little eye contact. It was a shy performance with little stage presence, but the music was solid and Caroline's voice was on point as well. The crowd was into it as well, which was nice, because you could tell she looked pretty nervous, especially after the computer malfunction. I'd say she deserves a 7/10.

Eluvium, the ambient project of Matthew Cooper, was something I was really eager to see, as I had no idea how it would be pulled off in a live setting. This man has made some of the dreamiest, beautiful music around -- it's almost as if time stops as his albums progress. If Caroline was nervous, Cooper was a wreck, hands shaking and eyes wide like a deer in headlights as he set up his gear. He opened with a piano piece that also opens his brand new EP, When I Live by the Garden and the Sea, and although it's essentially one part repeated over and over, he had great control over the tempo and loudness of what he was playing; as the song would progress, it gradually got louder and more intense, feeling more and more like an actual composition, rather than just a looped piece. The more ambient songs were the real treat, however, even though it's difficult to figure out how he achieves such a sound. For something so minimalist sounding, the music is actually very deep with many things going on at once, and with a lot of emotion. Matthews Cooper took all the focus off of himself with the music, as it swept the crowd away, most of them with eyes closed, taking it all in. He only played five or six songs, but it was wonderful. 8/10.

In a fun segway between Eluvium and Explosions, Cooper thanked the head of Temporary Residence for making it all possible for everyone there, and proceeded to try to play him "Happy Birthday" on piano. After fumbling around with it for a few minutes and realizing he had no idea why it wasn't working he just went up to the microphone and sang it himself, getting the crowd to sing as well. It was a silly way to pass the time between groups, and it garnered a good laugh.

There isn't a hotter band on the scene right now than post-rock behemoth Explosions in the Sky. Call it pretentious, but if there's a band that's going to save music, it's these four men. Touted as one of the best live acts in the world, the group performs epic, beautiful, emotional pieces with no vocals. To keep the discussion of post-rock as a genre to a minimum, let's just say they are a fantastic band (and you probably have heard them without even knowing it -- they composed the score to the film "Friday Night Lights"). Excited couldn't begin to describe how I felt as they walked on stage, especially as they opened with a brand new song on their completed but not yet titled release to come out in February 2007. It contained everything that the group excels at: a lot of melody in the opening into a blistering finale, a wall of sound from the guitars accompanied by pulsating drumming. Explosions also closed with a new song, and as the song ended, guitarist Munaf and two other members of Temporary Residence bands brought out snare drums and started beating them like mad at the climax of the set. "Memorial," the slowest song on the group's The Earth Is Not a Cold Dead Place, was showcased with a furious ending as the guitarists ended up almost smashing their guitars on the ground, spinning them through the air in utmost intensity, and "Greet Death" was played louder than most metal bands play, with the bassist strumming at a pace that was not perceived to be humanly possible. For such a pleasant sounding band on tape, their live sound is monstrous, and fits well with the epic nature of the music. Explosions in the Sky also fed off the crowd's energy, getting more and more into their music as the crowd clapped, head-banged, and screamed in anticipation of the group's more extreme parts ("The Only Moment We Were Alone" was the culmination of all of this). It was a cathartic set, certainly one to be remembered for many years to come. 10/10.

All pretension aside, Explosions in the Sky is a band that you need to see live before you die. Their six-song set was easily the best performance I've ever seen, and with three fine supporting acts, the Temporary Residence birthday party was a rousing success.


People who liked this also liked:
Envy - Insomniac DozeThe Format - Dog ProblemsSufjan Stevens - The Avalanche: Outtakes & Extras from the Illinois AlbumAlexisonfire - CrisisMisery Signals - MirrorsCircle Takes The Square - As The Roots UndoNorma Jean - RedeemerAtreyu - A Death-Grip on YesterdayProtest the Hero - KeziaThe Fullblast - Contagious Movement Theory

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
Anonymous (September 27, 2006)

I have seen and loved: Explosions, Mogwai, Mono, and Pelican. Explosions was my favorite out of all of them, then Mono. But I cant help but wish I would of seen Godspeed! when they were around.

Anonymous (September 27, 2006)

i had tickets to this show and sold them. i really, really, really regret it after reading this.

Anonymous (September 27, 2006)

for my mood music, william basinski.

explosions is the empire strikes back of the instrumental bands. the dark horse.

I like them, but they have yet to sustain their songs past a certain minute mark. I'm looking forward to there future records.

Why does music constantly need 'saving', motherfucker in a bubble?

The whole idea of saving music is dumb. Everytime you hear someone talk about the "horrible" state of music, they won't mention more than 2-3 bad bands because jokes on us, 80% of all mediocre music is comprised of bands "saving" music and bitching about the "depressing state of rock".


wyefa (September 26, 2006)

Explosions in the sky rules! Almost as much as Isis.

danperrone (September 26, 2006)

65daysofstatic are more electronic oriented, kinda glitchy at times, but still pretty emotional and atmospheric like most post rock

it's really good, the fall of math and one time for all time are both fantastic albums

leecorsoisapenis (September 26, 2006)

Who are these 65daysofstatic? Are they in the same vein of eits or Mogwai? Also, I have never seen Mogwai or eits and that saddens me. One of my best friends has seen them both, and he hangs that over my head every day.


danperrone (September 26, 2006)

65daysofstatic are AMAZING...i wish i could see them live!!!

ghostmonkey (September 26, 2006)

65 Days of Static live blow both Mogwai and EITS out of the water - one of the top 3 bands I have ever seen. They manage to convey the same emotions as both bands, but manage to do it in 4 minute songs. Absolutely amazing.

vitustinnitus (September 26, 2006)

clarification: "wasn't all that great" means when compared to a regular eits show. mogwai only played for about 40 minutes and stuart was having tech problems throughout. still good tho, and they opened with "mogwai fear satan"

vitustinnitus (September 26, 2006)

i will always commit to explosions in the sky for having the best live show. i lived in austin a few years back and had plenty of chances to take people to eits shows, and the result was always the same. they would always come out in a quasi-daze and tell me that it was the closest thing they've had to a religious experience. i've seen mogwai once, and since it was at a SXSW showcase, it wasn't all that great.

i was interviewing the guys from by the end of tonight on my radio show, and they say eits is gearing up for a massive fuck-off tour soon, so for the love of god COME THROUGH NASHVILLE DAMNIT. i miss seeing you guys.

greyicewater (September 26, 2006)

i hate all of you. i have seen neither mogwai or explosions. i was going to see mogwai once but my friend caused us to be late and i didn't get to see them. i hate her too.

Archangel (September 26, 2006)

Mogwai was ridiculous. They'd build and build and then just explode and their light show went crazy. It was awesome in the word's truest meaning.

iconoclast (September 26, 2006)

ive seen mogwai and explosions live, and while explosions is totally amazing, nothing comes close to a mogwai show. definitely the most amazing live experience ive ever had.

nocigar (September 26, 2006)

damn, Mogwai and Explosions are both fucking great bands.

danperrone (September 26, 2006)

yo archie, how was mogwai? loud as balls?

like herod on the govt commisions boot....WHOAAAAAAA

greyicewater (September 26, 2006)

i'm always looking for when this band will be in atlanta but i'm always disappointed. hopefully one day soon they will play. they are a definate must see for me. hopefully i don't die any time soon.

Archangel (September 26, 2006)

I would kill a nun for the chance to see Explosions in the Sky.

I caught Mogwai earlier this year, and it sounds like something of a similar approach to playing the songs live.

Thanks for reviewing this; get ready for the assbags.

Exclusive Streams


Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Managing Editor

Adam White

Contributing Editors

Kira Wisniewski Brittany Strummer Armando Olivas John Flynn Chris Moran John Gentile Mark Little

Copy Editor

Adam Eisenberg Britt Reiser

Podcast Producer

Greg Simpson


Aubin Paul

ISSN 1710-5366

© Copyright 1999-2013 Punknews.org

Terms of Use Privacy Policy Contact Us About Punknews.org

Other Places to Go