FeaturesContestsReviews
| John RalstonNeedle Bed2006 Vagrant
Review by: Anchors See others by this writer John Ralston (link) Only registered users can post comments Published on January 26th 2007
Elliott Smith will never be replaced. He was as enigmatic and accomplished a songwriter as we’ve had in the last 20 years, and his inner demons were presented in such a voyeuristic yet gorgeous manner that replication would be damn near impossible.
Please login or register to post comments. What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
It was a little too country tinged for me. I like his first full length and suicide the best. Score is for those albums. Rocky's a lot closer to Ryan Adams' sound than Smith's. You didn't like Makers? That album is phenomenal. My opinion is that Rocky Votolato is the new Elliot Smith. Done. Score's for Rocky ... but not the new album. Seriously? Ralston was in Legends Of Rodeo? Might have to check this out. You really got balls calling Elliott a one trick pony, nice of you to show your name while doing it ps. ralston used to be in a band called legends of rodeo. Smith was a one trick pony who was polished to a great extent by experienced producers. There's no denying his incredible voice and lyrics, but it took those producers (and a movie) to break him to the mainstream and turn his frail indie folk into something stellar. Ralston's record is self-produced and a much deeper first offering than Smith's first solo record. bad comparison to elliot smith, i think the best band to compare to elliott smith is someone still loves you boris yeltsin "Gone Gone Gone" sounds like a less awesome version of "Motorcycle Driveby" by Third Eye Blind. haven't heard the whole disc, but from his website it seems like this guy channels quite a bit more from the first two dashboard confessional albums than from any elliott smith record... Score is for Elliott Smith. Yeah, I said it. if you really want to hear someone channeling the ghost of elliott smith listen to arms and legs. |