Propagandhi / Comeback Kid

Propagandhi / Comeback Kid: live in Tokyolive in Tokyo (2008)
Fat Wreck Chords

Reviewer Rating: 4.5
User Rating:

Contributed by: JackischJackisch
(others by this writer | submit your own)

If I were to strip away all the bullshit of pleasantries and pretending that I'm a journalist type, and would just get down to it, I would post Propagandhi's set list, give it a 9 or 10, and then say "FUCK YEAH! WOO!" However, I don't think that's regarded very well these days, so I'll fancy it up i.

If I were to strip away all the bullshit of pleasantries and pretending that I'm a journalist type, and would just get down to it, I would post Propagandhi's set list, give it a 9 or 10, and then say "FUCK YEAH! WOO!" However, I don't think that's regarded very well these days, so I'll fancy it up in a review.

Shows in Japan I always find a little interesting. It's hard for me to not either be very negative on the experience or very positive. Always judging. Never just accepting. It's a fault of mine. I either think that it's amazing how much fun everyone is having and am amazed at the positive energy and the overall energy of the pit and the people in general, or I'm very skeptical of there being a circle pit for every band that is always seemingly perfectly formed. Is a circle pit just part of the equation to being punk? Is it all fake? Are they celebrating something from punk culture and being a part of it? It's all a very stupid slippery slope to go down, and the long of the short of it is that I don't like circle pits or crowd surfing, and there was shitloads of both. Good on them. Everyone was having fun. I just sometimes become a little testy when I'm trying to rock the fuck out to the music but instead am being repeatedly being pushed in a counter-clockwise fashion. Both Japanese fans and foreign fans were awesome though. There was no real dicks of the night.

Now, something I didn't really realize until the very end of the show was that this was essentially a Comeback Kid show with Propagandhi headlining. By this, I mean that it seemed like the majority of people there came for Comeback Kid or Comeback Kid-esque music, and the three opening bands sounded (at least to me) very similar to Comeback Kid, and not similar at all to Propagandhi. Through an off comment by Chris during Propagandhi's set, it seemed that Comeback Kid invited them on the tour to headline it. Fucked.

Without knowing this, and without knowing anything about Comeback Kid besides assumptions I made up all by myself, I had lots of thoughts like "fucking bullshit hardcore windmills" and "fucking Comeback Kid fans" and "what the fuck?" and all that crap.

The first band was Cleave...or Endzweck. One of the two. They were the first two bands. Whoever was first sounded like...incomprehensible hardcore with the odd emotional part put in there. If you're a fan of the genre, don't listen to a word I say, and just check them out. I think all the bands have MySpaces. I have no idea what I'm talking about with this kind of music. The second one sounded better than the first because they lost the odd emotional part and seemed to have a lot more energy. Also, more growling. For both bands there was a decent amount of people into it, or at least that's how it looked from the bar.

The third band was FC Five. For Comeback Kid-esque music, they were fucking amazing and the crowd was really, really into them. I waited outside for the majority of the set because it wasn't for me. I'm lame, though, so fuck me.

Before Comeback Kid came on, I had nothing but hate for them. I was having lame judgemental thoughts on the fans and the entire genre of music. At the end of their set, I didn't like the music, but I realized that I was a loser for hating them and that they seem like really cool guys who really enjoy what they're doing and sing about things that aren't fucking lame. Their crowd interaction was some of the best I've seen of a Western band in Japan (it seems lots of bands consider the language barrier an acceptable reason to say really lame things and follow them up with "haha, they don't understand"). The energy was intense, and I almost wished I was into it so I could've have that much fun with everyone in the pit, but it wasn't for me. Kudos, though, guys.

Now. Propagandhi...I had the expectations for them to be amazing and to have great commentary and basically just slay. I was worried that they'd play a lot off Potemkin City Limits. I really love the album, but I wanted to hear all their shit, not just the one album. They went above all expectations.

They started with "A Speculative Fiction," which I heard was fairly standard, and then I assumed they would play the first three songs off Potemkin, but they went straight into "Fuck the Border" after. After this point I forget the order, but it was an equal mix of all the albums and all sounding fucking amazing. Every time they played an old song I thought to myself "holy fuck they're playing '_____'! Fucking '_____'! I wish I wasn't out of shape and could do more than sway and shake my head."

As said, the crowd seemed really cool. This is where the super positive "Go Japan" thing comes in. No violent assholes! Hooray! Not even one! Despite the drunk young business man (or suit-wearing man) in the crowd's constant taunts for "Ska Sucks," everyone was rad.

Propagandhi didn't talk so much, but they said their thank-yous in Japanese and Todd said a little more. Jord went on about how some drum move that I didn't care about wasn't started by NOFX but by another band that I'm not cool enough to know about. Todd introduced "Less Talk, More Rock" with saying he hopes we all think it's okay to be gay, and introduced "Purina Hall of Fame" saying that it was for the few vegetarians in the crowd, and that people should rethink eating seafood perhaps. As previously said, Chris thanked Comeback Kid for inviting them despite it being risky. Fuck, are Comeback Kid cool guys. I'm sorry that I was full of hate, CbK.

The last song before the encore was "Purina," and while it rocked heavily, I couldn't rock the fuck out to the max during the breakdown because of people's constant desire to crowd surf. There was a similar problem during the final song of the night: "Anti-Manifesto" (a song I didn't think they played anymore). Good on them crowd surfers for havin' a good time; I just wish it wasn't when I'm really trying to feel the intensity of "Anti-Manifesto."

Great night. Got rid of lame biases towards Comeback Kid. Saw an amazing Propagandhi set. Got to see some Japanese hardcore bands while chilling at the bar.

Set list (I'm probably missing one or two songs):

How to Clean Everything:

  • Anti-Manifesto
  • Stick the Fucking Flag Up Your Goddamn Ass, You Sonofabitch
  • Who Will Help Me Bake This Bread?
Where Quantity Is Job #1:
  • Hallie Does Hebron
Less Talk, More Rock:
  • Less Talk, More Rock
  • Nation States
  • Resisting Tyrannical
  • Rio de Manitoba
Today's Empires, Tomorrow's Ashes:
  • Today's Empires, Tomorrow's Ashes
  • Motor League
  • Purina Hall of Fame
  • Fuck the Border
Potemkin City Limits:
  • Speculative Fiction
  • Greater Things
  • Die Jugend Marschiert (America's Army)
  • Rock for Sustainable Capitalism


People who liked this also liked:
Jeff Rosenstock - We Cool?Alkaline Trio - This AddictionThe Please & Thank Yous - Mind Yr P's & Q's [cassette]House Boat - The Delaware OctopusViolent Femmes - The Blind Leading the NakedMotion City Soundtrack - My Dinosaur LifeMike Hale - Lives Like MineChuck Ragan - Gold CountryLucero - 1372 Overton ParkNothington - Roads, Bridges and Ruins

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
VictorIkpeba24 (April 30, 2008)

I know Jackish, but you're not alone, lots of people on this site and elsewhere hates this band and I don't understand why.

Alien (April 29, 2008)

haha man, leave comback kid alone.
but seriously. good review.

Jackisch (April 29, 2008)

I hope the review made it clear that I think I was a loser for hating Comeback Kid.

Also, there were/are definitely more Japanese people at western shows than Western people, but Western people are still disproportionately high. At Japanese punk shows I've seen (local and big), I"m usually the only western person.

VictorIkpeba24 (April 29, 2008)

I don't understand the hate about Comeback Kid. Well, yeah I kinda get it: Christian, Canadian, Victory. But their music is great, so much fun, they slightly change their sound on every album and it's still awesome. They may not be the best live band in the world, the singer often has no voice half-through the show, but it really doesn't matter cause everyone in the crowd go nuts and sing their heart out on every song. And there are usually a lot less poseurs or hard-moshing-tough-guys than on other "popular" hardcore bands' shows. You've got to respect their ability to make people happy.

I know someone who was at that show (for Propagandhi). She liked it.

Spalmer (April 29, 2008)

Okay motherfuckers I know about english colonialism in South Africa, but the point remains that there are a great many black people there, too. Did they go to the show? The expats comment was about the Japanese show in particular. Everyone get skullfucked.

LORDSHREDDER (April 28, 2008)

I have had the pleasure of seeing Propagandhi a few times over the years, and always a fucking rocking treat. My favorite was in Chris dressed up as a Milkshake in SF.

BarleyPat (April 28, 2008)

Um, wow. I don't even know what to say to that.

Anyway, good review.

Score is for my lame ass never seeing Propaghandi despite the fact that they are one of my favorites. I fail.

sceneupdates (April 28, 2008)

I just noticed a small mistake I made. There are millions of WHITE people living in South Africa.

sceneupdates (April 28, 2008)

Spalmer, you are fucking retarded. And as the people below me have pointed out, there are millions of people living in South Africa. Generations of my family were born here. You're obviously watching too much Discovery where they show you bushmen and wild animals (I have a pet Lion, just to let you know - I ride it to school).

The majority of the NOFX show was white (as like every single punk show I've been to), but when you got an Akon show or some other crap, the majority is black. Different strokes for different folks I guess...

inagreendase (April 27, 2008)

from what I could tell there were a ton of white people at the NOFX show in South Africa.

Yeah, uhh, aren't there a lot of whites in South Africa in general?

tinner (April 27, 2008)

Great review! The show was pretty awesome! I really like the new song they played and am pretty excited for the new record!

hubitcherkokov (April 27, 2008)

"Potemkin City Limits" is my favorite Propagandhi record. I still need to see the live. Great review!

contrarian (April 27, 2008)

Uhh dude, the whites in South Africa aren't expats, they've been there for quite a few generations now . . . heard of something called apartheid? Nope?

Jesus_H_Christ (April 27, 2008)

Nice review. The show sounds like it may have been a tad surreal with considering the line-up.

Spalmer (April 27, 2008)

What kind of crowd shows up for these sorts of shows? Mostly Japanese, or are there a lot of expats? I'm wondering because from what I could tell there were a ton of white people at the NOFX show in South Africa. Does punk have any appeal to those without "western" ties?

usversusthem (April 27, 2008)

Man the idea of new Propagandhi songs excites me to no end. However: No Iteration is booooo.

And also: God who the fuck yells for Ska Sucks. That is offensively dumb.

briennis (April 27, 2008)

frankly, i would be kinda disappointed with that few songs off Potemkin.

likeaparasite (April 27, 2008)

The new song they played was called "The Supporting Cast". The best part of the show was some guy who was obviously Japanese (you could tell from his accent) yelling "Ska Sucks!" repeatedly every time there was a break between songs and being totally ignored by the band. It was a cool crowd. My baseball cap got knocked off while I was getting shoved around in the front row and some guy was nice enough to snatch it and wave it around until I grabbed it back.

Jackisch (April 27, 2008)

Fuck, I can't believe I forgot that they played a new song. They gave the name of it, but I forgot what it was. It sounded similar to Potemkin shit though.

goodna (April 27, 2008)

Ok review, seems he just doesn't want to offend anyone though

contrarian (April 27, 2008)

Good review. I'm glad CK invited Propagandhi and not vice-versa. I'd assumed they had better taste than that and I guess I'm probably right.

I've been itching to hear Propagandhi post-Potemkin; I'd be pretty bummed to finally see them but not hear "Iteration."

Exclusive Streams

Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Managing Editor

Adam White

Contributing Editors

Kira Wisniewski Brittany Strummer Armando Olivas John Flynn Chris Moran John Gentile Mark Little

Copy Editor

Adam Eisenberg Britt Reiser

Podcast Producer

Greg Simpson


Aubin Paul

ISSN 1710-5366

© Copyright 1999-2013 Punknews.org

Terms of Use Privacy Policy Contact Us About Punknews.org

Other Places to Go