Punknews.org | Thrice / Circa Survive / Pelican

Review Navigator

Features

Contests

Reviews

Thrice / Circa Survive / Pelican

live in Clifton Park
2008
live show

Thrice / Circa Survive / Pelican - live in Clifton Park (Cover Artwork)

Review by: Brian
See others by this writer

Thrice (link)

Only registered users
can post comments

Published on May 13th 2008

Clifton Park's Northern Lights venue was a surprisingly cozy venue for a tour I figured would be drawing bigger crowds in cities right near major universities (SUNY Albany is 20 minutes away). It was a really promising trio and each completely delivered the goods.

Pelican was already ten minutes into their set or so when we'd arrived, that song being "Sirius," the closer of 2005's The Fire in Our Throats Will Beckon the Thaw. Their drummer's really gotten flogged in reviews for the band's more recent album, last year's City of Echoes, but he seemed to hold steady here, keeping time and driving the rhythms and patterns well enough. They sounded powerful, and though the crowd didn't really seem to know what to do with them (aside from sporadic followers), they gave a warm reception after every song and especially upon conclusion of the set, which was the magnificent "Last Day of Winter." It was cool to see that the band was given around a 40-minute set, as well.

With a bit more grit to his voice, Anthony Green gave a new emphasis and urgency to Circa Survive that was unusual for them, considering more ambience and restraint has taken precedence in their sound. The set was about evenly split between their two full-lengths, with added dynamics, modified transitions and even a cool dub overlay for one song. They sounded great in the small club setting, which I'd never been afforded the opportunity to witness given their rapidly increasing fanbase. In fact, there was a noticeable departure of fans after the set; I'd wager it was the ones who were most rabid, climbing over each other for the chance to wail Green's soul-searching lyrics right back to him.

I'm not quite sure what the band opened with; there was some pretty post-rock twinkling and Green singing unfamiliar lines -- maybe it was that partial Björk cover he's known to sometimes throw in. There was a similar moment in between "Stop the Fucking Car" and "Kicking Your Crosses Down" with unfamiliar lyrics and guitar riffs; I just couldn't pick up on it. The only non-band material I did get was the Happy Birthday song played before the last two songs.

Set list (7:57-8:41):

?
Living Together
The Great Golden Baby
Travel Hymn
Mandala
Stop the Fucking Car
?
Kicking Your Crosses Down
The Greatest Lie
In Fear and Faith
The Difference Between Medicine and Poison Is the Dose

It was comforting to know that Thrice would be taking advantage of this headlining tour set and be playing a wide breadth of material from their expanding catalog. However, the crowd reaction was mixed; they were sometimes lukewarm to the softer, deeper cuts from The Alchemy Index ("Lost Continent," "Broken Lungs"). Dustin Kensrue would acknowledge this later on, thanking the crowd for their patience as they played the newer stuff (ultimately rewarding the crowd with "Deadbolt"). Sure, there were definitely a few people present for each of those songs who knew the lyrics and were visibly enjoying the vivid, colorful performances, but there was serious push-pit and flailing limb action for many of the songs from The Artist in the Ambulance (the title track? Mania.), the one heavier track off The Illusion of Safety and a couple from Vhiessu. Dudes in choo-choo hats and Glassjaw shirts would make prompt walks to the back of the venue whenever a song from Alchemy was announced and return for mild raging when songs off Ambulance were parlayed.

Again, though, those performances of the new songs were mostly nicely done. "Digital Sea" was a little more gritty, as the band heaped on the distortion a bit, unfortunately draining the song of much of its beauty. However, "Lost Continent" really tested Kensrue's vocal abilities and he was up to its requirements there, turning in an arresting vocal display that the song really relies upon. "Come All You Weary" matched all its tones and benefitted heartily from the live full band treatment. The Appleseed Cast-esque prettiness of "Broken Lungs" was executed with shine, but it really seemed lost on those who clearly preferred the band's heavier dynamics.

I didn't even really recognize the third song they played, which I later learned was "Flags of Dawn"; interestingly, I'd surmised at the time that it was a song off 'Air' I haven't yet fully immersed myself in. However, it's actually a B-side from Vheissu, available on the Red Sky EP.

"Trust" was the sole other pre-Ambulance song played, and it fit surprisingly well in the set. The band added a more atmospheric nature to it, almost making it seem more like a late entry in Vhiessu's sequencing.

The encore was an incredibly weird choice: two non-singles off Vhiessu, but the crowd roared in approval and "The Earth Will Shake" turned out to be a powerful closer.

Set list (9:20-10:50):

Hold Fast Hope
All That's Left
Flags of Dawn
Digital Sea
Firebreather
The Messenger
Trust
The Earth Isn't Humming
The Artist in the Ambulance
Under a Killing Moon
Lost Continent
Stare at the Sun
Broken Lungs
Come All You Weary
Of Dust and Nations
Daedalus
Don't Tell and We Won't Ask
Deadbolt

Encore

For Miles
The Earth Will Shake

My one complaint? Thrice's $20 price tag for T-shirts printed on Bay Island Sportswear; hopefully it's because Invisible Children, the charity riding along with the tour, is getting a good cut of it.

Besides everything else, a surprisingly tolerable crowd and very modestly sized venue made for an excellent show. There's still a few weeks left, so hit it up.

Photos by: Me -- check out more Thrice pictures or Pelican pictures at my Flickr page

Login to rate this album

People who liked this also liked:

Please login or register to post comments.

What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?

Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.

Posted by dordon on 2008-05-16 11:16:42
My Score:

hey i live in clifton park. score is for the org having something from northern lights.

Posted by strickland on 2008-05-16 11:11:51

" i personally love alchemy but dont really enjoy any of the older material."

me too. The Earth will Shake would be an excellent closer. Or opener. Actually I just wanna see it played live.

Posted by bwisott on 2008-05-14 18:50:53

Circa is a kick ass band. Not so into thrice. I thought it was a good show overall though.

"like spinning lines, dont be scared."

Posted by colin on 2008-05-14 18:23:35

fucking 9? really?

i saw this in austin and i'd give it about a 5, mainly cause pelican fucking rules.

also more photos from this tour:

http://www.distortedperspective.com/public/thrice/
http ://www.distortedperspective.com/public/pelican/
http://www.disto rtedperspective.com/public/circa/

circa survive sucks. so do their fans.

Posted by inagreendase on 2008-05-14 14:45:12

The t-shirts are often higher because some venues get a cut of merch sales. Most venues take 20% and take each band's inventory upon arrival. It sucks.

Pelican and Circa's shirts were $15.

Posted by primeevil7 on 2008-05-14 13:00:11
My Score:

They OPENED with Hold Fast Hope?

*jaw. floor*

Wait. They played Deadbolt, the Earth Isn't Humming, Under a Killing Moon, the Earth Will Shake, the Artist in the Ambulence, and Of Dust and Nations and you all are complaining?

Makes no sense.

Posted by thatsyouth on 2008-05-14 12:24:05
My Score:

trust would have been amazing to see

Posted by telegraphrocks on 2008-05-14 12:07:04

Oh, and best Thrice songs:
"Hideous Strength", "Beltsville Crucible", and "Image Of The Invisible".
I don't think I would've liked that show at all.

Posted by telegraphrocks on 2008-05-14 12:04:20

"The t-shirts are often higher because some venues get a cut of merch sales. Most venues take 20% and take each band's inventory upon arrival. It sucks."
-----------------------

I really don't get why this happens. I mean, don't venues PAY THE BANDS THAT PLAY!?!?!? If so, wouldn't it just be "here's some money from us, now give us some of yours"?
Shit makes no sense.

I remember a show here (Chicago) a few years back at The Vic and one band refused to sell shit because the venue was gonna take a %, and then they spent several minutes onstage ripping on the venue.

Meow, meow, garbage lady!

Posted by CANNON on 2008-05-14 12:00:39

The t-shirts are often higher because some venues get a cut of merch sales. Most venues take 20% and take each band's inventory upon arrival. It sucks.

Posted by HeresLookinAtYou on 2008-05-14 11:19:49

Oh and I can't believe they played "Trust."

I've never seen that played live before.

Posted by HeresLookinAtYou on 2008-05-14 11:17:21
My Score:

I was at this show too. I actually saw your name right below mine on the guest list haha.

I missed Pelican, but Circa was amazing as usual.

For Miles is one of my favorite Thrice songs, so it was cool to see them play that as an encore.

Overall, really solid show.

Posted by chrisafi on 2008-05-14 07:54:54

I've never been to a UK show where tshirts cost under £10, or $20. We get ripped off hard over here lol

Posted by Fallen_leaves on 2008-05-14 00:32:18

ya i saw thrice on this tour in MA and the crowd was very similar in the way it was mixed up. i personally love alchemy but dont really enjoy any of the older material.

Posted by holy_balls on 2008-05-13 22:49:24

I thought I was the only one who though "Broken Lungs" sounded like Appleseed Cast. Anyways, Good review. I enjoyed my date of this tour. Eventhough I was surrounded by people smoking weed.

Posted by steveman on 2008-05-13 21:52:34

Did the focus ring fall off your camera?

Good review, I'm hoping to see this in Chicago.

Posted by ryne on 2008-05-13 21:44:37

Nice, you summed it up pretty damn well.