Punknews.org
of Montreal - Skeletal Lamping (Cover Artwork)

of Montreal

of Montreal: Skeletal LampingSkeletal Lamping (2008)
Polyvinyl Records

Reviewer Rating: 5


Contributed by: greg0rbgreg0rb
(others by this writer | submit your own)

Warning: This review contains language not suitable for children. For realz. During the first phase of the band and its pinnacle, 1999's The Gay Parade, of Montreal was a psychedelic-pop-rock band and included a full band and a cast of Elephant 6 characters on the records. By the time of 2004's f.
iTunes StoreAmazon


Warning: This review contains language not suitable for children. For realz.

During the first phase of the band and its pinnacle, 1999's The Gay Parade, of Montreal was a psychedelic-pop-rock band and included a full band and a cast of Elephant 6 characters on the records. By the time of 2004's fantastic Satanic Panic in the Attic, Kevin Barnes was working mostly on his own in the studio, and synths and drum machines were worming their way deeper into the mix. On last year's amazing Hissing Fauna, Are You the Destroyer?, electronics ruled and Barnes' insane self-harmonizing vocals were taken to the extremes. It was also his most consistent set and was simultaneously his catchiest and darkest, written when he was separated from his wife and new child. Barnes and his family have been back together awhile now, and Barnes is attempting to follow up his most critically acclaimed record to date. Barnes is pulling out all the stops, and even the packaging options are worth mentioning, but I'll let Pitchfork explain that with great pics of the collection.

On Skeletal Lamping, Barnes is untethered by these things we call 'tracks.' The sleeve lists 15 of these so-called tracks, but the record plays like one long piece with over 30 movements. You'll initially be confused as the music drastically shifts gears mid-track or changes track without notice, but soon you'll start to appreciate the crazy transitions and the constant barrage of new ideas. I believe there is only one instance of between-track silence. And there is certainly nothing on here like the previous album's 12-minute constant-tempo centerpiece, "The Past Is a Grotesque Animal."

Barnes puts his audience to the test immediately. "Nonpareil of Favor" begins the album pleasantly enough with a dancey beat, a catchy vocal full of Barnes' flourishes and sweet piano part. But just over a minute in the tempo downshifts and starts jack-hammering your eardrums with the most powerful guitar an of Montreal song has ever heard, pummeling you with dissonant chords and pointy lead lines for close to four minutes while slowly adding backbeat and melody bits back into the chaos. If you can make it past that you're in good shape, because rest of this bizarre-pop set is pretty melodic. My favorite stretch of the record is when it cools down briefly for the simple piano ballad "Touched Something's Hollow" before blasting into the brass-driven intro of "An Eluardian Instance" with its something like four different parts that all rule.

Kevin Barnes has fully accepted his role as the indie rock Prince, going back to the liner notes of The Sunlandic Twins. Think about it. He's a tiny man. He wears crazy clothes. He gravitates towards notes in the highest of male registers and often shrieks 'woo!' But most of all, he's a FREAK. Check out some of these doozies scattered about the album, taken out of context and listed together for greatest effect: "I wanna make you cum two hundred times a day" ("Gallery Piece"); "I'm just a black she-male" ("Wicked Wisdom"); and "We can do it softcore if you want, but you should know I take it both ways" ("For Our Elegant Caste")...and that's just scratching the surface. Then there's the most Prince-sounding of all, "Plastis Wafer." The first part of the song is a light funk which finds Barnes actually at a more restrained tone, returning often to a chorus of "I want you to be my pleasure puss / I wanna know what it's like to be inside you." He even uses sexual terms in non-sexual situations, from the safe "Don't you pimp out my heart" ("An Eluardian Instance") to the more out-there "I'm so sick of sucking the dick of this cruel, cruel city" ("St. Exquisite's Confessions"). These quote-ables might seem shocking coming from a family man, but not as shocking for a family man who has appeared on stage pants-less. I won't subject you to that image, but check out these pics from the outrageous stage show they put on recently in NYC (no nudity unless you count the horse): here.

Barnes says that none of this is meant to shock. Yeah, right. The guy must be a bit freaky if his noggin' is coming up with this stuff, but his safe-guard is he's taking on characters. The lead role of this sex-capade would be Georgie Fruit, who turned up briefly on Hissing's "Labyrinthian Pomp." Barnes has created a whole back story for this guy, and the most relevant part of it for you confused readers would be that Georgie is quite a confused guy himself who was born a male, changed to female, then changed back. Also, he's African-American for some reason (the 'black she-male' thing makes sense now, huh?).

In other tunes, his characters are warning friends of getting involved with sex fiends. "Beware Our Nubile Miscreants" is a highlight of the record's later portion with the oft-returning chorus hook over different lyrics, echoing breakdown and real-drum outro. First single "Id Engager" is the closer of the record and seems to be written as such with none of the bizarre tempo changes but plenty of spunk and a danceable disco groove. It is difficult to point out other standout tracks because you get lost in the record as a whole and noting some part 2:45 into a track or something seems silly.

In a self-penned press release Barnes says, "I wanted to make a record that could truly surprise a listener. To create something that was, in turns, enraging, joyous, discomforting, playful, lovely, unpleasant, freaky [and] mesmeric…" and he succeeds on all levels. With the first listen, the lyrics and odd transitions will have you wondering what they'll do next. But as you become more acquainted with the record the transitions will make perfect sense and you'll love sassin' along with lines like "I'm the motherfuckin' headliner, bitch you don't even know it!" I didn't think the Barnes could top Hissing but I think we have a new high-water mark here and the risks he takes totally pay off. I agree with Barnes that we live in a pop music world where we can "finish an artist's sentences, musically and lyrically" and he should be commended for avoiding that.

While of Montreal is an extremely polarizing band and many of you will disagree with me (ex-fans included), I am to the point of loving this record where I can almost say this is some sort of historically significant release, if only in the indie world. I won't name-drop certain overused critics' reference points from, say `66 or `67, but I must say that in a similar way, of Montreal is pushing pop music boundaries to new extremes while somehow retaining the key elements of listenability and replay value.

 

 
People who liked this also liked:
Islands - Arm's WayThe Clash - London CallingCursive - Happy HollowModest Mouse - We Were Dead Before the Ship Even SankMurder by Death - Good Morning, MagpieDum Dum Girls - I Will BeJapandroids - Art Czars [7 inch]The Mountain Goats - The Life of the World to Come DVDAloha - Home AcresModest Mouse - Building Nothing Out of Something

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
greg0rb (October 27, 2008)

Yes, that is them. It's a redone version of "Wrath Pinned to the Mist and Other Games" off of Sunlandic Twins. So I just got the full art version CD of this and good lord is it a sight to behold. Needs to be seen to be believed.

sickboi (October 27, 2008)

Did this band really do the "Outback Steakhouse" song?

-chris

blanktapesemptybottles (October 26, 2008)

I think I assumed wrongly that they were some shitty pretentious scene band

blanktapesemptybottles (October 26, 2008)

how the fuck did I miss this band this long?!

shark-e (October 26, 2008)

I have yet to hear the record, but your review actually made me want to go out and buy it. More on that later...
Good job!

Michael_Jackson_Jordan (October 25, 2008)

"While of Montreal is an extremely polarizing band and many of you will disagree with me (ex-fans included), I am to the point of loving this record where I can almost say this is some sort of historically significant release, if only in the indie world. I won’t name-drop certain overused critics’ reference points from, say `66 or `67, but I must say that in a similar way, of Montreal is pushing pop music boundaries to new extremes while somehow retaining the key elements of listenability and replay value."

THANK YOU FOR GETTING THIS RIGHT. So far, all the other reviews I have read about this album have not been on the same page as my feelings, but you nailed this one on the head. I think this is definitely one of the most important releases in the past decade, for sure, due in part to its innovativeness and unique take on deconstructing pop. I could not believe even Pitchfork gave this album a low-balling 5.9 -- I was expecting them to ejaculate with glee and serve a high 9 that hasn't been seen since Arcade Fire's "Funeral." This is not one of the most immediately accessible albums by far, but when you endulge in it, you soon find yourself being able to appreciate every schizophrenic song as well as their incongruities. It's perfect due to it's imperfections.

youwinalemon (October 25, 2008)

Album of the year for me. Excellent review.

colin (October 25, 2008)

we ride, we ride, skeletal lamping.

can't really get into this band, but blood brothers were good.


this.

also even pitchfork doesn't like this album, which is surprising.

seriously though this band is overrated as all get out.

xote (October 25, 2008)

I dig it.

Bipedcasserole (October 25, 2008)

score's for the review. excellent job.

i love pretty much everything of montreal's done, but i still dig Cherry Peel the most. sucks for me since that album was all acoustic folk-pop and they seem to be running as fast as they can away from anything organic sounding.

still though. most people either love or hate this band. i can't deny barne's melodies and vision. love it.

theDrivingSnow (October 25, 2008)

Overrated. Not as shocking as it purports/wants to be. A failed experiment. "For Our Elegant Caste" is one of the most annoying songs of the year.

timorous_me (October 25, 2008)

"Hissing Fauna, Are You the Destroyer?" was one of my favorite records last year, but I thought this one was horrible. And really, I thought the majority of their output prior to "Hissing" was horrible too (save two or three tracks from each release).

GlassPipeMurder (October 25, 2008)

we ride, we ride, skeletal lamping.

can't really get into this band, but blood brothers were good.

Contests

Exclusive Streams

Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Other Places to Go