Thursday / Far / Midnight Masses

Thursday / Far / Midnight Masses: live in New Yorklive in New York (2009)
Epitaph Records

Reviewer Rating: 4.5

Contributed by: InaGreendaseBrian
(others by this writer | submit your own)

Midnight Masses were practically the footnote of this rather monumental Sunday night show at lower Manhattan's Bowery Ballroom. '90s emocore-cum-shoegaze vets Far reuniting for their first show in nearly a decade here and Thursday playing fan favorite, 2001's Full Collapse, front to back? How do you.

Midnight Masses were practically the footnote of this rather monumental Sunday night show at lower Manhattan's Bowery Ballroom. '90s emocore-cum-shoegaze vets Far reuniting for their first show in nearly a decade here and Thursday playing fan favorite, 2001's Full Collapse, front to back? How do you compete with that?

Well, you try to ignore it and make your own stamp on things, I guess. Buds with ...Trail of Dead, MM had a psychedelic-indie sound that bonded elements of both classic rock and the stars of Pitchfork's more recent, positive reviews. I had read a lot of Doors comparisons doing pre-show research; it kinda made sense. Some of the more repetitive refrains were accessible for immediate singing along ("Heaven," another song whose key lyric was "are you whisperin' to me?"); other moments bore decently interesting textures and layers. The dual-gendered harmonies were spot-on, too. But honestly, these were the brighter spots of a somewhat boring set that was a little too sedating otherwise. And they had a generous 40 minutes, too.

I knew a fair amount about Far before their set here, but musically, only that they seemed to pay a big influence on some of my favorite bands (Cave In, Thursday). I listened to some of the stuff from the heralded Water & Solutions beforehand and since it reminded me of a more Deftones-indebted Sunny Day Real Estate, I was looking forward to seeing if they could pull it off just as well 11 years after the fact. Their set here ended up being a greater, more expansive look at their catalog and the resulting mix was pretty cool regardless. Frontman Jonah Matranga (who would play as/in New End Original, onelinedrawing and Gratitude post-Far) was unhinged by his guitar for half the set, and would take advantage through theatrical spasms, characteristic of the band's elder scene. He would kneel towards the stage's front side pretty often and it helped connect him with what few Far fans speckled the front floor. The other guys in the band were energetic too, though, especially guitarist Shaun Lopez, whose fuming strums and lowered-head intensity provided Far's most compelling element.

Raucous old-guy mosh erupted for some of the band's older, more vaguely metallic hardcore-informed stuff, but their fans mostly reacted with politely passionate singing along. The latter was most evident when Thursday frontman Geoff Rickly came out to join the band for "Mother Mary"; apparently, it was a kind of reversal of history, as Thursday would cover the song nightly on a tour with onelinedrawing years back, having Matranga come out with them. It was definitely the most melodic and memorable moment of the set, but given the song's accessibility it was given, I suppose.

There seemed to be some technical difficulties and an occasional sour note or missed (or delayed) cue here and there, but the band weathered those bumps finely and seemed otherwise tight. From a pretty unbiased perspective, I was solidly impressed.

Set list (8:47-9:35):

  1. You Wear It So Well
  2. I Like It
  3. Water & Solutions
  4. Man Overboard
  5. Bury White
  6. ?
  7. Waiting for Sunday
  8. Love, American Style
  9. Really Here
  10. Heather's Homework (?)
  11. Mother Mary [f/ Geoff Rickly]
  12. The System
Both of the major bands had setup times that stretched for way too long (Far -- 34 minutes; Thursday -- 31), but Thursday made up for it with one of the best sets I've seen them play. I was begrudgingly psyched for this show because, as much as I love the raw, ragged atmospheres of Full Collapse, I still prefer the followup, the more majestically emotional War All the Time. Still, as Thursday wove their way through the album, it was cool to get background on the songs: I always thought "Autobiography of a Nation" referenced America's slaughtering and takeover of the Natives -- turns out it's about punk rock and hardcore; they mentioned Far's blatant influence on "Standing on the Edge of Summer"; and emphasized how awful "Wind-Up" is (disagreed). It was an awesomely smoldering and throttling, bass-heavy rendition of Full Collapse (keyboardist Andrew Everding joined the band for just the encore) with all the sappy trimmings.

They never really seemed to miss a beat, save the quick breaks in among songs, and I think that could probably be attributed to the fact that a lot of these songs have been set staples for years, anyway. They were just stringing them all together here (Rickly's wide-radius mic swinging for the "rain rain down" part in "Paris in Flames" came right on time).

Despite no barrier, Bowery was awesomely lax about crossing the stage threshold; some crowd-surfed, others stage-dove. In the pit, you could witness everything from goofy push-mosh and hardcore two-stepping to that silly watered-down version thereof I remember being amused by at "post-hardcore" shows like these around 2001-2003. Both cases made for a pretty good indicator of the crowd's diverse makeup.

But all loved it, and when the band came back out on stage for a bonus six-song encore it was even better. The audience was notably less responsive for the trio of tracks off Common Existence songs, but the band probably expected this; almost a dozen gigantic black balloon-type spheres were launched onto the crowd as Thursday kicked into the mournful, new wave-y, morose textures of "Circuits of Fever." But when it ended, everyone ceased slapping the buoyant balls into the air and bugged out when the band kicked into their best complex anthem in "Jet Black New Year." And speaking of anthems, "War All the Time" could not have demonstrated that stripped-down quality of Thursday's songwriting better as a closer.

Set list (10:06-10:53):
  1. A0001 [over the PA] / Understanding in a Car Crash
  2. Concealer
  3. Autobiography of a Nation
  4. A Hole in the World
  5. Cross Out the Eyes
  6. Paris in Flames
  7. I Am the Killer
  8. Standing on the Edge of Summer
  9. Wind-Up
  10. How Long Is the Night? / I1100 [over the PA]
    Encore (10:54-11:26):
  11. The Other Side of the Crash / Over and Out (Of Control)
  12. Beyond the Visible Spectrum
  13. Friends in the Armed Forces
  14. Circuits of Fever
  15. Jet Black New Year
  16. War All the Time


People who liked this also liked:
The Ataris - So Long, AstoriaBigwig - Unmerry MelodiesNo Motiv - LolaFairweather - LusitaniaBandits of the Acoustic Revolution - A Call to Arms5¢ Deposit - We Have Your Daughter!Boys Night Out - Make Yourself SickStrike Anywhere - Exit EnglishScary Kids Scaring Kids - After DarkPinhead Gunpowder - Compulsive Disclosure

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
RedElephant (October 31, 2009)

the fact that Midnight Masses basically started praying and huggin one another at the end of their set when i saw them last year with Trail Of Dead immediately turned me off of them.

deadxlast (October 29, 2009)

This sounds AWESOME. Good review. I love Far.

deadpan (October 28, 2009)

Jonah Matranga has an incredibly imposing vocal presence live. He really does.

preston (October 27, 2009)

I wish I would've went to this.

How many Thursday shows has Brian reviewed?

Make_Way (October 27, 2009)

This probably would have been an awesome show to go to, Thursday-wise. Full Collapse remains one of my favorite albums of all time. I like how even the "instrumental" tracks were played over the PA to complete the Full Collapse album experience.

Two questions:
1) Did they include the "...tide is high" portion to the end of "Understanding in a Car Crash", even though it sort of stems from one of the instrumental tracks?
2) Why didn't they play something like "Streaks in the Sky" in the encore? Do they ever play songs from Waiting live anymore? The last time I saw them, (back in 2002), they played "Streaks..." and "This Side of Brightness"

damnitsderek (October 27, 2009)

Seems like somewhat of a small set list.

little_brother (October 27, 2009)

I meant to score this a nine...

little_brother (October 27, 2009)

Awesome show, I hadn't seem Thursday since like 2002. Full Collapse is what got me into them, so seeing this show with Far opening up was not something I couldn't pass up. I, like most of the crowd, was less impressed with the new material. Score is also for getting into the Far show at the Mercury Lounge tonight for the last three songs for free.

Jelone (October 27, 2009)

-Still haven't seen Thursday live. I agree about War All the Time. -Buddy of mine went to Far's Philly show. From what I've heard from you and him, I think I got some researchin' to do.

Exclusive Streams

Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Managing Editor

Adam White

Contributing Editors

Kira Wisniewski Brittany Strummer Armando Olivas John Flynn Chris Moran John Gentile Mark Little

Copy Editor

Adam Eisenberg Britt Reiser

Podcast Producer

Greg Simpson


Aubin Paul

ISSN 1710-5366

© Copyright 1999-2013 Punknews.org

Terms of Use Privacy Policy Contact Us About Punknews.org

Other Places to Go