Punknews.org
Chuck Klosterman - Eating the Dinosaur [book] (Cover Artwork)

Chuck Klosterman

Chuck Klosterman: Eating the Dinosaur [book]Eating the Dinosaur [book] (2009)
Scribner

Reviewer Rating: 3.5


Contributed by: JeloneJelone
(others by this writer | submit your own)

With Eating the Dinosaur, author Chuck Klosterman has finally penned a true sequel to his knockout 2003 collection Sex, Drugs and Cocoa Puffs: A Low Culture Manifesto. They're both collections of original essays examining the philosophical hidden meanings of popular culture. Where they differ, thoug.


With Eating the Dinosaur, author Chuck Klosterman has finally penned a true sequel to his knockout 2003 collection Sex, Drugs and Cocoa Puffs: A Low Culture Manifesto. They're both collections of original essays examining the philosophical hidden meanings of popular culture. Where they differ, though, is in maturity. Cocoa Puffs took on The Real World, John Cusack, and Saved By the Bell. Dinosaur, meanwhile, attempts to explain the Waco massacre, the Unibomber and the mathematical theories of the film Primer. Obviously, this is headier, more mature stuff.

Klosterman announces as such on the collection's first essay, "Something Instead of Nothing," in which he contemplates how realistically (or unrealistically) interviews depict people. It reveals everything the book is about, from the formatting -- although the essays jump around from one subpoint to the next, they are helpfully annotated -- to the book's general topic, which is, "What is real?" Supplemented by interviews with documentarian Errol Morris and radio host Ira Glass (as well some delicious footnotes. Seriously, Klosterman provides some of my favorite footnotes of all time), Klosterman debates with himself and his subjects over why anyone would bother telling the truth in a public interview. The potential gains are numerous -- exposure, publicity for a product being sold, and for the ridiculously famous, a chance to interact with a sane, smart human being -- but Klosterman provides just as many reasons why giving interviews is a bad idea, and why telling the truth can be an even worse one. This is why Klosterman occasionally lies when being interviewed.

Later in the book, Klosterman considers whether it's better to be a perfectly built athlete with average stats or an averagely built player with those same scores -- do we appreciate people more when they have to earn their achievements more? He compares Nirvana frontman Kurt Cobain with Branch Davidian leader David Koresh. He attempts to explain -- occasionally even justify -- Ted Kaczynski's worldview. As is Klosterman's way, the writing is incisive and humorous, though with diminished returns.

Klosterman seems at a Joe Sacco-like crossroads. Does he continue to write about rock â??n' roll and low culture? Should he pursue more "adult" topics like war, disease and bitter, bitter failure? Dinosaur feels like an argument for the latter. While his musical observations are compelling when coupled with more "real world" goals -- like on the Cobain/Koresh essay -- some of Klosterman's thoughts seem too tired and uneventful in comparison to his more socio-political material. On "T Is for True," he discusses irony, literalism and honesty as they apply to Weezer frontman Rivers Cuomo, political figure Ralph Nader and filmmaker Werner Herzog. The Nader portion is insightful; the Cuomo section less so. The essay examines a guy who may or may not have contributed to the rise of the Bush administration (which is stirring), as well as the guy who wrote Make Believe (which I would rather forget). While Klosterman takes an original stance on explaining Weezer and its fans post-Pinkerton (Cuomo has always written explicitly about himself. Pinkerton is just the point where he and his fans' interests overlapped), the topic still feels rehashed, in that every Weezer release stirs up yet another conversation about how the band was better with Matt Sharp involved. And while I appreciate Klosterman's unique approach to the topic, there's still a part of me that resents people who argue that Weezer has released an album this decade on par with its '90s material. In a world where Jason Todd and Bucky can come back to life, a man has to believe in something, dammit, even if it means believing that Weezer will never be good again (but...but the "Red Album" was funny in spots...!). Keep "We Are All on Drugs" to yourself, pal, and pass the "You Gave Your Love to Me Softly," please.

But I could never call anything Klosterman writes in this or any of his other books disappointing. He's still the premier scribe of the aughts, as far I'm concerned, and I will continue to follow him, taking in his every witticism. Still, there is this slight feeling of fatigue in reading Dinosaur, the thought that maybe Klosterman is getting sick of all this nonsense. In truth, every book he's done since Cocoa Puffs has attempted to distance itself from that work in some way. Killing Yourself to Live was too concerned with mortality and fidelity to be taken lightly, IV was a clearinghouse collection and not a true continuation, and Downtown Owl, Klosterman's first novel, was another rumination on death (and his home state North Dakota). While Dinosaur is the closest Klosterman has come to mimicking Cocoa Puffs, it also works best when it takes on fresh, more adult topics. Also, sports, oddly enough. "What We Talk About When We Talk About Ralph Sampson" allowed me to have quite a meaningful five-second conversation with my father about basketball.

 

 
People who liked this also liked:
Crime in Stereo - Is DeadShahman - Who Am I? [7-inch]Mastodon / Feist - Feistodon [7-inch]Mean Jeans - On MarsDNF - Hurt [7-inch]Agatha - Agatha [12-inch]Screaming Females - UglyColin Newman - A-ZBright Eyes - The People's Key16 - Deep Cuts From Dark Clouds

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
flowerfeeder (November 9, 2009)

Just started reading this on Friday. Surprised to see it reviewed here.

mikeflynn (November 7, 2009)

Looking forward to reading this...though Killing Yourself to Live is my favorite book by him.

Can't wait for the Fargo Rock CIty movie that Craig Finn from The Hold Steady is involved with.

misterspike (November 7, 2009)

Fuck this buying books shit. I'm waiting until I can download the .pdf or audiobook on gimmefreeshit.net or whatever the kids do these days.

Uncle_Leo (November 6, 2009)

I did a double take when I saw this up.

I loved Coacoa Puffs and I got excited when I saw this in the book store the other day, but maybe I'll wait until it shows up in paper back now.

kidgotham (November 6, 2009)

I also liked that you referenced Joe Sacco. I love his books.

kidgotham (November 6, 2009)

This was a great review. My score is for it. I was well thought out and was actually critical.

the_other_scott (November 6, 2009)

i've tried with three of his books to get all the way through, and never could. half the time its interesting, but the other half is self-deluded fluff from a guy who still listens to Poison.

irish_joo (November 6, 2009)

This was good...but not great. I feel like he is trying to hard to pull together the pop culture references sometimes. He is also hard to read when you have no idea what he is talking about.

Cos (November 6, 2009)

"[E]very Weezer release stirs up yet another conversation about how the band was better with Matt Sharp involved. And while I appreciate Klostermanâ??s unique approach to the topic, thereâ??s still a part of me that resents people who argue that Weezer has released an album this decade on par with its â??90s material."

The thing about Klosterman that has always bugged me is the lengths he goes to defend mediocre music just because it sells. I suppose if you're interviewing Britney Spears (as he once did) this would make you a thoughtful interviewer, but it makes you a damn lousy critic. Whenever Klosterman does this, he smacks of insincerity no matter how much he tries to mask it.

I loved SD&CP as much as the next pop culture nerd and I've been disappointed with everything ever since. IV culled some brilliance out of his essays but they were still fleeting and "Killing Yourself..." was so obnoxious in its self involvement. I'm sure there's some great stuff in here somewhere... I'm just not sure its worth wading through the crap.

theproblemwithfire (November 6, 2009)

never read anything by him, but IV by him is on my book list to check out some time...

Exclusive Streams

Sponsored


Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Other Places to Go