FeaturesContestsReviews
| The Promise RingWood/Water2002 Anti/Foreign Leisure
Review by: Scott See others by this writer The Promise Ring (link) Only registered users can post comments Published on April 24th 2002
Punknews.org, circa April 2012 Please login or register to post comments. What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
A 10? PSS-- This album is graduating music. I can't explain it, but it is. Your window is open, the air is stale, the fan is wobbly and ineffective and this record plays. It is almost somber, indulging pop without being repetitive, but very fun to listen to. Like a few people have said, this LP takes multiple listens, but then you will be rewarded. Early choice for record of the year I've never been a huge Promise Ring fan, but I love this album. The songs are slow and pretty. I normally think the Promise Ring are pretty cool, and that's coming from a guy who generally likes things with a bit more punch. But this album was just waaaaaay too slow and boring. I feel like going to sleep, and while their other CD's can have the soothing effect due to their laid-back sounds, this one just bored me to death. Worst CD I ever bought. I got this album 5 days ago and I'm glad I didn't write a comment before now. At first I thought this album kinda sucked, but with every time I hear it, it gets better and better. It took me like 10 spins to get into it and it's been growing since. Usually albums that some time to get into are the ones that are still remembered 10 years from now. So I totally agree with the review. haha, pick his brains, thats a good one. oh yeah, this is exhaustra and i meant to give the album 1 star. this album sucks. i wish it didn't, but it does. complete and total departure from the rest of their catalogue. while this fact alone doesn't make it suck, it sure doesn't help. this is what happens when bands stick around too long and need to feel relevant again. someone put the promise ring out of their misery. Three Words: Nothing Feels Good 10 for the review, 7 for the record. "Pinkerton" was released on September 24th, 1996 [so says CDNOW.com]. "Pinkerton" was certified gold on July 3rd, 2001 [so says RIAA.org]. So sue me, I was off by 3 months. It's still damn close to 5 years. Pinkerton took at least 5 years to go gold... "dumbass". anyway back to the promise ring... i havent heard it yet but i will (tomorrow hopefully). I LOVED very emergency and I hope that this one can compare... I heard that song stop playing guitar or whatever... its damn good... i hope that they are all equal to or better than that "pinkerton" is not an important album adn it went gold much quicker than 5 years. dumbass. I always thought these guys were alright, but after hearing a few songs off of Wood Water, such as Stop Playing Guitar, what can I say? I'm hooked. Three words. Nothing Feels Good. Yeah this album is quite incredible. I've loved all Promise Ring stuff (yes, even "Electric Pink" and "Very Emergency"). This is very different, but VERY VERY good. This band can't make a bad song... cept for "American Girl". you have entirely too much time on your hands... haven't heard the album yet but the 3 is for the effort on your part Dude you fucking rule cool review...i'm gonna check out this cd. Yeah, I gotta admit that the only reason I bought this album is because I consider myself a loyal fan to the group and it's predecessors(ie-Cap'n Jazz....) and at first listen it didn't sit well. But the more I listen to it, the more it grabs me and I really appreciate it. Not since 30 degrees to everywhere have they put out such a solid album, in my opinion. Also, well done review, man. now that was a cool review...maybe i'll check out the album... |