Punknews.org
The Get Up Kids - On A Wire (Cover Artwork)

The Get Up Kids

The Get Up Kids: On A WireOn A Wire (2002)
Vagrant Records

Reviewer Rating: 3.5
User Rating:


Contributed by: maverickScott
(others by this writer | submit your own)

Two types of people are going to read this review: people who hate the Get Up Kids and want to see me bash them, and - well, actually, that's probably the only type of person that's reading this. It's a shame, really. The Get Up Kids have inexplicably become the whipping boys of the emo-pop explos.
iTunes StoreAmazon


Two types of people are going to read this review: people who hate the Get Up Kids and want to see me bash them, and - well, actually, that's probably the only type of person that's reading this. It's a shame, really. The Get Up Kids have inexplicably become the whipping boys of the emo-pop explosion, taking the brunt of everyone's criticisms from Pitchfork to Buddyhead. The band has gone from meager Midwest beginnings to being the openers on national tours for Green Day and Weezer, not to mention consistently selling out their own shows across the country. These kids have worked their asses off in their brief existance and all they ever do is catch flak for it; if I were them, I'd be burnt out, too. And if I were burnt out, this would be the album I'd make.

Gone are the bouncy, playful tracks like "I'm A Loner Dottie, A Rebel" and "Don't Hate Me." Gone are the harder rockers like "10 Minutes" and "Action and Action." Gone are the sheer raw emotions of tracks like "Shorty" and "A Newfound Interest in Massachusetts." What remains? Remember that song "Company Dime," off their last album? You know, the one that just plodded along at a regular tempo, with no real energy or hook to it? That's about it.

That sounds harsh, though, and I don't mean it like that. But that is the style of the new Get Up Kids. It's obvious that Matt's time spent in the New Amsterdams between albums has affected this one greatly. Tracks like the opener "Overdue" and closer "Hannah Hold On" are both acoustic ballads that slide along. It should be noted, however, that both songs really are great, great tracks.

The band does inject some rock into their newfound formula on tracks like the energetic "Stay Gone." "Grunge Pig" also shines through on the disc, getting the same treatment that the Anniversary recently did to their sound - go classic rock on it! It works, as Grunge Pig is a thunderous 4 minute rocker with the yelled chorus of "I ask each year/ why am I here? / Begging you please / remembering / I'd rather die than be alone." It really is a high point of the album, both lyrically and musically. Unfortunately, the album takes a nosedive directly afterwards.

"High As The Moon" and "All That I Know" both come across as Beatles "influence" tunes, but both sound completely flat and uninspired, *especially* "All That I Know." This is one of 2 songs Jim takes the vocals on, and it's absolutely horrendus - the keyboards are annoying [as they are in most songs on the album where they play more than simple background chords] and Jim's lyrics are pseudo-hippy garbage. Jim's other track on the album, "Campfire Kansas," a guitar/piano duet with distorted vocals, is a complete reversal and gets a thumbs up. It's a cool little song which they'll probably never play live.

The good songs on this disc are really good, and the bad ones aren't even that bad, either, they just need some revisions. Take "The Worst Idea." The song is okay if you ditch that damn keyboard! It sounds like an old Monkees riff, with all honesty, and it's so fucking annoying. Then the modulation halfway through - ugh. Another potential winner, "Fall From Grace," is ruined by Matt Pryor's incredibly inconsistent vocals. Musically this song reminds me of REM, circa "New Adventures in Hi-Fi," but when Pryor comes in caterwauling "hannnnnng onnnnn..." about 2 steps flat, it completely ruins whatever the song had going for it.

It's cool that the Kids are tired - it's cool that they want to adapt their sound. But with this album, it's more of a complete overhaul with very little left behind. It's not so much of an evolution of the band's sound as more of "Hey guys, I like REM, let's work that in. Okay, I like the Beatles, let's work that in. Dude, what about my wife's band, the Anniversary? They're pretty good too" type thing. I'm really curious to see how the Kids' fanbase will react - the Promise Ring pulled a similar stunt this year on Wood/Water, and people seem to be sticking with them. I'm still torn on this album, though - the highs are very high, but the lows are really low - almost to the point of making me want to press the "skip" button on my CD player [which is a cardinal sin in my book]. No matter what anyone else says, though, this is the album that this band wanted to make, and whether we like it or not, it's as sincere as they can get. The question is, will we like it... or not?

MP3s

Overdue
Stay Gone
Wish You Were Here

REAL AUDIO

Stay Gone
Walking On A Wire
Wish You Were Here
The Worst Idea

 

 
People who liked this also liked:
Hot Water Music - No DivisionThe Get Up Kids - Something To Write Home AboutThe Get Up Kids - Guilt ShowThe Lawrence Arms - The Greatest Story Ever ToldThe Lawrence Arms - Oh! Calcutta!Jawbreaker - 24 Hour Revenge TherapyAlkaline Trio - GoddamnitAlkaline Trio - Maybe I'll Catch FireDescendents - Milo Goes To CollegeAlkaline Trio/Hot Water Music - Split

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
Anonymous (March 6, 2004)

Good fucking album, let me tell you what. They fucking completely revamped their style and I think they still sound great and our still original and still have their own sound, even if its not their old sound. I understand why people do hate this album, because the music they played on their previous albums might not even be considered in the same genre as the music that is being heard here. It just happened that they got lucky and made songs that still satisfy me. And isn't that what it's all about? So I commend you, Get Up Kids, for bending over and just completely putting yourself in a vulnerable position. You made music that you felt you had to make, even if your base fans fucking hate it. Long live. RATFE

Anonymous (August 12, 2003)

Dude, i LOVE TGUK. Ever since i heard Something to Write Home About, I decided that these guys are like, my heroes... but anyways, I got Eudora... and HOLY CRAP, that CD rocks! It's almost all i listen to, it beat out the battle for my CD player against Punk Rock Classics such as Lees Than Jake - Losing Streak, MXPX - Teenage Politics, NOFX - The Decline and Blink 182 - Dude Ranch. I seriously love that album. Then they came out with a new album. I got it. I was puzzled at first... but i started listening to it. I got those songs stuck in my head. It may not be high energy like Rx Bandits or Skankin' Pickle, but man, it rocks! I love this album. And Their drummer...! He's nuts! I play drums in a local ska band, and their drummer is one of the drummer i wish i could play like. Have you ever seen him play? He's like ambidexerous or something. It's so cool. But anyways... all i know is that this album may not be the "Hardest" or the "fastest" or "most emoish(if that's a word)" but it is definantly classic and i have to say that from this album to Four Minutes Mile, you got every type of music that i listen to, and that's why TGUK are, in my book, one of the best bands out there today. (they're up there next to 311)

Anonymous (July 11, 2003)

This album isn't so good compared to the other stuff. Something to Write Home About is definately the best of their works. But come on, we're die hard Get Up Kids fans... So we give them credit. Hannah hold on and Campfire Kansis were great songs! And it's EMO-punk... give them a break. TGUK for life!!!

Anonymous (May 19, 2003)

hii people,im portugal, dont be suprise but i listen to tguk for past 3 years, and i didnt realized that this band would be so talked, about the other critics i like to say that if you want to have a cool tguk,first respect their choices, and then make constructive critics to the their music...and what the hell, if you are pissed about the music and you have bought the cd, shame on you, even in the tguk internet page you can listen to the musics and choose to buy or not to buy it,i give 9/10 to this album because no one is perfect... Hey Get up Kids you are very cool,what about a concert in Portugal? could you consider that atleast?

XGOXTHEXGETUPKIDSXGOX

Ass: Manuel Seromenho
Portugal,Quarteira(Algarve)

Anonymous (May 15, 2003)

www.thelastyear.com

Anonymous (April 28, 2003)

Go to www. Punkcreations. Com now !!!!

Anonymous (April 23, 2003)

They are never boring.

Anonymous (April 17, 2003)

This album is alright but their old stuff is definetly better. i recently saw the get up kids when they came to pittsburgh and they were pretty boring but hot rod circuit kicked ass!

Anonymous (April 3, 2003)

JB.... = Julien Bureau..

David Lepage sa mère, c'est Huguette Michaud pis son pere Robert Lepage

Anonymous (March 23, 2003)

i enjoy this album quite greatly. the get up kids make me quiver with listening delight.

Anonymous (March 16, 2003)

I found 'Don't hate me' 10000000 times better than 'Shorty' but its just me.

Anonymous (March 16, 2003)

Personally, I found the vocals really annoying, but it works. Somehow everything comes together and the lyrics aren't too bad. And as for classifying them as emo or not... Who cares? Thanks -Gloria

Anonymous (March 13, 2003)

ok this is how it goes, first of all education does not scare me at all. I'm not afraid to learn or experience something new. Although I do enjoy learning there is a time and place for everything. In this case it might not be so obvious. This is a place to talk about music, in this secton in particular, the get up kids latest effort. Not how in the begining there was sad, then came upset, then "emo" music. If people want to hear about that go to a hitory of emo site, or if you want to talk about it create a website or forum or chat room or whatever else you want. You don't go to the DMV and ask about property rights on you house,come on. Or you could just take what I say, disagree, and respect what I say by not trying to degrade it with childish comments. I say long winded as an opinion, some state it as a fact that I am affraid to learn. There is a difference. (Now thats a lot of bs)RATFE

Anonymous (March 6, 2003)

I think the get up kids rock and this album would only really appeal to those "true" fans because i def agree that this album is like nothing else they're done but it's still a winner!

ForeverNothing (March 1, 2003)

I think the majority of the people who have commented on "On a Wire" are too hung up in the term "emo". I admit, I do like the bands who fall under that category, but I also respect their desires to change their music. As James Dewees says, "You never write the same thing twice." I'm sure some of you have followed The Get Up Kids for many years, starting with Four Minute Mile. I have. My opinion is, if you really truely love a band for who they are, you will like anything they release. When I first heard "On a Wire", I skipped through the tracks quickly and thought, "This isn't TGUK at all." Then I started to realize, this is Matthew Pryor, Jim Suptic, Rob Pope, Ryan Pope, and James Dewees. These are the guys I have been listening to forever. I listened to the record with that in mind and I loved it. If you love a band, you're going to at least respect what they change in their music. The Get Up Kids have just proved to the world with this record that they are out to make music and nothing more, and that makes me love them even more. I see that some of you have said that they are weak lyrically and musically and I think that that is completely wrong. TGUK were strong in both fields with "Four Minute Mile", "Something to Write Home About", and "Eudora" but I think "On a Wire" reflects their most effort, both musically and lyrically. I think that people need to let go of the "emo" term and learn to listen to music that doesn't always fall under that category. This post will probably cause some people to get mad, but that's a risk I have to take to get my point across: "On a Wire" is amazing work by none other than the greatest band in my mind.

Anonymous (February 27, 2003)

RAFTE,
I don't think anyone needs to calm down when they aren't arguing. For your information I was answering others people questions regarding what is EMO. (See reviews 2002-05-15 and 2002-05-17). So, just because you don't need the "long winded comment" doesn't mean someone else thinks that way. Does education scare you that much? I guess that you know everything and think that when someone is talking they are upset. Oh well, I guess you need to grow up. dc

Anonymous (February 24, 2003)

What happened to the old get up kids???

Anonymous (February 20, 2003)

Im the dork who wrote the long winded comment. There is no need to get offended over the comment. You need to calm down. Its nice to write a comment about the album but not talk about the origins of the get up kids and emo music since the beginning of time. Take some pepto and kick it. RATFE

tattoo (February 19, 2003)

Hello EvilDeadalive,
You are right I was arguing for the sake of arguing because I like to see if I can get a rise out of someone. As always, I succeeded; however, I do give you credit for catching on so quickly. So take care and keep rocking. Plus, now I am not Mr. Anonymous anymore.

Kid_Dynamite (February 16, 2003)

i prefer their old records but this one isn´t bad either. i really apreciate that they chose the hard way with a record like this. another "something to wr...." record and they are the next big "emo" thing...

evildeadalive (February 14, 2003)

I think I get your point now. You're arguing for the sake of arguement? One guy cuts down another for a simple typo, and yet makes one himself, and I point it out. No need to make this a bigger deal than it is. Calm the fuck down. If you look you'll see that this arguement (the most pointless one in history I might add) started because I think the grammar police have a little too much time on their hands. I could care less about peoples typos as long as I can understand what they are saying.

You know it's good times making fun of peoples names, too bad you don't have one. Also, it's not like I'm pretending to be evil or anything, I just combined the titles of 2 of my favorite movies, Evil Dead and Dead Alive. Feel free to make fun of me for that now anonymous boy.

Anonymous (February 14, 2003)

Evildeadalive,
First of all, I did not write the other comment and second, who made you the grammar police? Plus, the person just forgot to add an "s" to listen. But according to you, "who has time to spell check, give me a fucking break". Another fine case of the Pot Calling the Kettle Black, Mr. Anal-retentive. Your cut down was so original. Please, if you are going to insult someone come up with something original besides "sucking your mom's dick". Like that was a cut down that NO ONE has every heard before, right. As for listening to Punk Rock, I have been listening since the '70's when the best part of you was running down your momma’s ass. However, I did appreciate your review of the album. Furthermore, you seem a little perturbed in your life, maybe you should stop eating all that cum to keep warm in Canada. Later, cool guy. Mr. Goodalivedead.

evildeadalive (February 13, 2003)

Calm down toughguy, whoever you were bitching at made a simple typo, it's not the end of the world. And you're questioning my maturity?

You know your grammar's not exactly that shit hot either to be criticizing someone elses. "the new direction does take a few listen to get warmed up to"

My opinion on the album is it's pretty decent, just not something I would listen to that often personally. Are they growing as a band? Sure. They're just not growing into anything that appeals to me. A little slow for my liking.

And a highschool punk I most certainly am not, I was listening to punk rock when you were still sucking your mom's dick. Have a good day Mr. anonymous.

Anonymous (February 12, 2003)

Evildeadalive,
Hey cool guy, right. Love the name; you must be one misguided high school punk. Get a clue and grow up. Hey, if you want to seem like an uneducated idiot, don't spell check. Plus, you probably haven't figured out how to use that function yet. Plus, the TGUK album is great and the direction shows true growth as a band. So, "evildeadalive" what did you think? It is a review board after all and not a bitch board. Oh, the maturity.

evildeadalive (February 12, 2003)

do you actually spell check every comment you make on here? give me a fucking break.

Anonymous (February 7, 2003)

"Cute and Paste", umm I think you meant cut and paste. Next time you might want to spell check. I think the person is just jealous because s/he can’t write as good and with intelligence. The Get Up Kids rock and the new direction does take a few listen to get warmed up to but overall it is great.

Anonymous (February 7, 2003)

Hello, Dork below me, just because someone is educated and has something to say that is correct, does not make them "long winded". As for free time, some of us get paid lots of money to surf the web. So stop being jealous and it does not take much time to cute and paste from articles or is that concept too mind blowing. So, give respect to the generation that is educating you all about the history of punk music. Your an idiot, so just shut the hell up. However, TGUK have produced another great album.

Anonymous (February 6, 2003)

Some of you people have too much free time and are long winded. Good album, Rthfe

Anonymous (January 24, 2003)

For those of you wanting a definition and history of emo here it is. If you want further information go to www.allmusic.com. That is were this information was taken from. Digablechild, you are pretty right on with your comments. As for skating, just pop some pain pains and keep on shreading.

Originally an arty outgrowth of hardcore punk, emo became an important force in underground rock by the late '90s, appealing to modern-day punks and indie-rockers alike. Some emo leans toward the progressive side, full of complex guitar work, unorthodox song structures, arty noise, and extreme dynamic shifts; some emo is much closer to punk-pop, though it's a bit more intricate. Emo lyrics are deeply personal, usually either free-associative poetry or intimate confessionals. Though it's far less macho, emo is a direct descendant of hardcore's preoccupations with authenticity and anti-commercialism; it grew out of the conviction that commercially oriented music was too artificial and calculated to express any genuine emotion. Because the emo ideal is authentic, deeply felt emotion that defies rational analysis, the style can be prone to excess in its quest for ever-bigger peaks and releases. But at its best, emo has a sweeping power that manages to be visceral, challenging, and intimate all at once. The groundwork for emo was laid by Hüsker Dü's 1984 landmark Zen Arcade, which made it possible for hardcore bands to tackle more personal subject matter and write more tuneful and technically demanding songs. Emo emerged in Washington, D.C. not long after, amidst the remnants of the hardcore scene that had produced Minor Threat and Bad Brains. The term "emo" (sometimes lengthened to "emocore") was initially used to describe hardcore bands who favored expressive vocals over the typical barking rants; the first true emo band was Rites of Spring, followed by ex-Minor Threat singer Ian MacKaye's short-lived Embrace. MacKaye's Dischord label became the center for D.C.'s growing emo scene, releasing work by Rites of Spring, Dag Nasty, Nation of Ulysses, and MacKaye's collaboration with members of Rites of Spring, Fugazi. Fugazi became the definitive early emo band, crossing over to alternative rock listeners and getting press for their uncompromisingly anti-commercial attitudes. Aside from the Dischord stable, most early emo was deeply underground, recorded by extremely short-lived bands and released on vinyl in small quantities by small labels; some vocalists literally wept onstage during song climaxes, earning derision from hardcore purists. Fugazi notwithstanding, emo didn't really break out of obscurity until the mid-'90s emergence of Sunny Day Real Estate, whose early work defined the style in the minds of many. Tempering Fugazi's gnarled guitar webs with Seattle grunge, straight-up prog-rock, and crooned vocals, SDRE launched a thousand imitators who connected with their dramatic melodies and introspective mysticism. Some of this new generation connected equally with the wry, geeky introspection and catchy punk-pop of Weezer's Pinkerton album. While several artists continued to build on Fugazi's innovations (including Quicksand and Drive Like Jehu), most '90s emo bands borrowed from some combination of Fugazi, Sunny Day Real Estate, and Weezer. Groups like the Promise Ring, the Get Up Kids, Braid, Texas Is the Reason, Jimmy Eat World, Joan of Arc, and Jets to Brazil earned substantial followings in the indie-rock world, making emo one of the more popular underground rock styles at the turn of the millennium.

digablechild (January 23, 2003)

Some people are just so touchy these days. For your information I am a thirty year old who has done his fair share of staying true to the alternative community. I have watched and participated in the many trends while growing up. I had my first skateboard in the 70's. Yeah it was one of those colorful banana boards. I have been a skater until a few years back when my lower back and knees just couldn't take it anymore. The lingering effects of a bad car injury in highschool finally caught up with me. A day doesn't go by that I wish I was out skating. However, since I have lived most of my life in the DC area, absent five years in Knoxville for college, I have watched the DC punk scene grow and explode. It pains me to hear people not know about the roots of emo music.

Music 101. Emo music, which we call today, really started with the band Rites of Spring. It was called emotional hardcore/punk due to the fact that the vocalist (Guy) sang and acted out how the music was affecting him. The band was able to let down the tough guy image that all of the older punk bands had previously been displaying. It was a new thing for concert goers to witness, this new act of someone showing their emotions on stage and through their lyrics was unheard of at the time. Like everything else, we - as a culture- had to put a new label on this type of sound. So, some DC bands began to get the label as emotional core punk. Later it was shortened to emo-core. For your information, Fugazi was one of the first emotional core bands and since they are from dc and have two members from Rites of Spring, they could be labeled emo. To hear their emotion on their songs, one needs to see them live and especially you need to hear Suggestions and Reclamation. These songs are filled with emotion. These songs dealt with issues not relating to lost love or will this girl like me.

Today’s so called emo music is a label that marketing executives have put on countless numbers of bands to sell records. If someone likes one so-called emo band then the marketers believe that they will buy other bands in the same genre. As far as most of the so called emo bands today, I just consider them to be alternative rock. Emo can be used to categorize any band that shows any emotion on stage our in their lyrics. Isn't anger an emotion? So why aren't hardcore bands called emo? I just think that we, as a culture have once again tried to put labels on everything. Our society just has to put things in categories so we can easily label something so hopefully everyone can understand it. I guess we are all suckers for thinking that we are punk and are against the main stream when we actually have just been like everyone.

As for emo being wimpy or for sad people, you need to get real and experience more. Oh, the stereotypes will never end. So, are you a better person for not being emo? Or do you believe that you are like stone and show no emotion what so ever? Emo is for any emotion and it is sorry that today people only recognize emo with the nerdy kid that wears glasses and is sad all of the time. Let’s think as the true pioneers of punk thought and let’s break down these stereotypes and change the way society thinks. Otherwise, you are not punk, you are just like everyone else.

I am not trying to upset anyone, I just want to hopefully give some insight and make you all think. Someday when you become the old school you will realize that you are now longer the new school. To quote Mike Ness, "There would be no New School without the Old School." He is so right and when you reach my age you can reflect and see how the world actually works. It is hard to imagine that I am a Land Use Planner with the County that wears a suit and tie to work. However, I will always be punk at heart with my full sleeve tattoos and my music. When I was a crazy teenager, I thought it was me against the world. Now I realize that if you want to change something the best way is to infiltrate the organization and do it that way.

As for the Get Up Kids new album, it is really good. I admit when I bought it when it first came out, I was caught totally off guard. I was waiting for the fast up beat songs like on the previous albums. I hated it, I thought what has Scott Litt done to these guys. It was like R.E.M.'s Automatic for the People. Then after my second listen I was like, I get it, this is just a great alternative rock album and just shows the growth that the band has made. When you get older sometimes you don't need everything to be loud and fast. Sometimes it is nice to have a variety in your music bin and this album fits in mine very nicely. This is an album that you grow into and will truly appreciate as you get older. Let me know what you think when you turn thirty, have a career and are married. Peace.

Anonymous (January 16, 2003)

This is the best get up kids CD of all time, cause they made sure that none of the "I swear I friggin' hate pop, even though i obviously love it" people will never listen to this. Great music, great CD

Anonymous (December 29, 2002)

This bad

Anonymous (December 26, 2002)

Not that bad

soulbleed (December 25, 2002)

I'm beginning to wonder if this site is nothing but a bunch of wannabe-bigshots insulting each other's opinions without even validating theirs beforehand. If you have something to say, make sure it's about the album, and make sure you've actually given it a chance without prejudice.

This album probably has gotten the worst response out of any of the new records that came out this year, and somehow that makes sense. Expectations were high, the band was sick of making the same old crap over and over - and you know what happens when bands try and expand their creativity past the small borders of emo's potential: they fail. I can think of few exceptions outside of the pioneers of the genre who have successfully pulled this off.

"On A Wire" if produced by anyone else would be an amazing record, but knowing that this was made by the same people who recorded albums like "Something to Write Home About" and "Four Minute Mile" just makes me disillusioned. It contains some very intelligent moments, and it's obvious that the singer has let his other projects influence the direction of his main priority, which usually isn't a good sign (the Tool/APC relationship springs to mind about now) - Reggie and the Full Effect and New Amsterdams couldn't hold a candle to this band if they tried, so mixing their styles doesn't even seem like a good idea to begin with.

After all is said and done, this is a satisfactory album. The only thing I have left to add is that I hope they get their heads on straight and stop trying to revolutionize a genre and realize they already have.

Anonymous (December 22, 2002)

Emo is another name for sissies. This has NOTHING to do with punk (and I actually listened to the cd before saying that)

Anonymous (December 19, 2002)

Everyone in here needs to go out and get or DL the Ramones S/T or Rocket to Russia. Its a sure cure for the blues, cos thats wat I had to listen to after I listened to this record.

Anonymous (December 19, 2002)

I'm looking forward to that... :/

maverick (December 16, 2002)

Holy shitfuck.

Get Up Kids in Iowa City tonight rocked the fucking house.

These songs sound 10 times better live.

Look for a review of the show soon.

-Scott

maverick (December 12, 2002)

New Found Glory is trying to be Less Than Jake?

-Scott

Anonymous (December 11, 2002)

yeah yeah yeah, this is from that same anonymous guy who commented on the onther album. Everybody had got to shut the hell up. This is just simply amazing music here people. What this is is just raw emotion and musical talent. I dont understand how the hell you couldn't like this cd. I bought it the day it came out and still have not stopped listening to it. So for all you people who dont like tguk, please go get a life. And yes they maybe weak but who the hell cares, i guess your not the type who should be listening to this. The used is my favorite band but TGUK are a close second, SO SHUT THE HELL UP. Tguk are something desperately needed in the punk culture, there are to many damn poppy bands like new found glory, who is just trying to be less than jake, so do yourselves a favor, if you dont like tguk, dont bother posting a comment. Thank you

Anonymous (December 7, 2002)

No we arent. The Hidden Public controls this web site. I command you to LOVE all NoFx- even if they are old, fat, boring, men with no good music to write or anything to sing about. BECAUSE I SAID SO.

Anonymous (December 6, 2002)

Hey cunthead we re here to give our opinions so shut your hole.

Anonymous (December 6, 2002)

"Since when did punk mean "what i think is absolute and perfect and if you dont agree you are a poser and you suck" ?"

Since I said so. The Get Up Kids are WEAK AS HEEEELLLLLLLL!

Anonymous (December 4, 2002)

Since when did punk mean "what i think is absolute and perfect and if you dont agree you are a poser and you suck" ? Quick! Conform and try to agree with everyone before they hate you! Hurry or you wont have friends and life will be just TERRIBLE! Are we over our middle-school-become-the-default-personality-thing now? I sure as hell hope so.

M4CH1N3 (December 3, 2002)

This album is a piece of shit. Why is it reviewed on PUNK news???

Anonymous (December 3, 2002)

This is by far the best album the Get Up Kids have made. The lyrics are awesome and creative. The way they use the acoustic is bad ass. Oh yeah and im a 19 year old who listens not only 14 year olds listen.

Anonymous (November 28, 2002)

We don't have enough do-nothing whiny bitches in the music industry, do we? I can see how girls could like this music, and maybe a few gay johns, but men? Grown men? No! The music is bland and shitty, the vocalist is a annoying to no end. I turned it off at track 3 screaming "MY GOD! THIS IS WHAT THEY CALL ALTERNATIVE?" Its just a bunch of shitty love dittys and other stuff that makes stupid little brats cry. Good. Just don't act like this band perfected a respectable genre!

devilsdeathwish (November 27, 2002)

this cd is nothing to write home about, but "Campfire Kansas" is probably one of the best songs i've ever heard to chill to. I give all my respect to the The Get Up Kids for trying to evolve and grow as a band. It's real refreshing to see a band take a chance and change their style. Put themselves out there for everyone to critique and i really respect that. They get 8 points for Campfire Kansas and Overdue.

Anonymous (November 26, 2002)

well after reading all of these comments and replies i've come to the conclusion that MOST of you aren't over the age of 14 and you wouldn't know good music if it hit you in the face.

2002 was full of dissapointing cd's. the problem being that playing in a band isn't supposed to be a career. "on a wire" is nothing more than a forced album. they tried too hard to make a good record instead of an honest record. if you had been around when Woodson and Four Minute Mile dropped then you would understand. i won't call this a bad cd, but it definitely isn't worth 5 stars. ALL THESE BANDS NEED TO QUIT TRYING SO HARD. IT ISN'T COOL TO BE EMO. I WISH YOU KIDS WOULD GET THAT. IT'S ABOUT HONESTY AND BEING TRUE TO YOURSELF.

Anonymous (November 14, 2002)

Well, I've listened to it... many many many times over and I can't shake it. I don't like this album. At least not nearly as much as i wanted to. They just seem so bored. And man, I'm really starting to be annoyed by the keyboard modulating crap that James is adding to every song. I did go to see them live when they came with Superchunk. It hurt soooo bad. They played a grand total of two songs off of Four Minute Mile ("Don't Hate Me" and "No Love" which was introduced as a song of this CD they made in 2 days). They played the entire new CD, which despite what they were trying to promote on their website, did NOT get any more rocking live. They even managed to ruin songs I liked with added organ (thanks James). I'm happy that they're doing what they want and not just hammering out the same thing again. It just could have been so much better...

Painaxl

maverick (November 12, 2002)

10,000 hits?

Holy shit.

-Scott

punkboy_1 (November 6, 2002)

i dont know if i like this cd or not. its not the get up kids that i know but everyone has to change every now and then. there a few really good songs and a few terrible ones.

Anonymous (November 5, 2002)

Strange that the review should mention 'The Company Dime': - I really like the Get Up Kids and, despite my initial disappointment, have grown to love On A Wire.
However, I can’t stand ‘The Company Dime’, it is a painfully un-catchy tune… it is the one Get Up track that I simply can't bear. So I really disagree that the latest album resembles it in any way.

Anonymous (November 1, 2002)

This album is so different but so great i am a big fan of the get up kids and all other vagrant bands and any one who hates this album is not a true get up kid fan and as the band say you only dissapoint the ones who don't believe.

Anonymous (October 27, 2002)

i agree that the Get Up Kids new cd is awesome. i bought it the next day it was out and i really look up to the way they put so emotion into their music. it sux that their others were so pop-music like. but that wont change the way i feel about them now.

Amber

Anonymous (October 24, 2002)

dude, the better tracks are great (campfire kansas is an awesome "chill song"), the lesser tracks are really weak, but i give props to tguk for trying to evolve as rockers. Too many bands do the same thing over and over and its real refreshing to see a band defy the emo-status that everyone placed on them. though more of a "chill" cd then the others, its still better then the junk most bands put out.

Anonymous (October 23, 2002)

its a shame that the get up kids put out such poppy emo stuff before "on a wire" cuz so many people that would love this cd will never give it a chance. this is by far my fav get up kids cd, the song writing and lyrics vastly improved from "something to write home about" to this cd. at 13 this cd probably would have pissed me off too but you will like it in a couple of years.

Anonymous (October 22, 2002)

the getupkids newest cd kicks ass... c... ur are the coolest chick in the world! i heart c!

Anonymous (October 22, 2002)

The music is well thought out. The lyrics are strong. People named Eric Killian need to learn how to spell before they cricize a perfectly good cd

Anonymous (October 21, 2002)

I was pretty dissapointed when i first bought this cd, because i know the fast, raw energy of four minute mile and the perfect pop of something to write home about. however i gave it a few more listens and a few songs grew on me. Campfire Kansas is a great little sing along, "Wish you were" here remembers the best of their emo days and "worst idea" is fun too. The kids are exploring new territory here and most of the time come up strong. I wish i never heard "all i know" because itsw just awful. The new songs didnt go over very well when i saw them live. The crowd was just kind of staring, until they busted out the old stuff.

Anonymous (October 20, 2002)

New album is wicked. who gives a fuck about emo. good music is good music whatever genre.
If you like TGUK, then ull love mother knows best. their album comes out Jan 10th

bemused (October 15, 2002)

Its just plain BAD

mike_mafia (September 5, 2002)

i disagree, ON A WIRE is a beautiful follow-up, ignoring all 'emo' propaganda and evolving their music into not neccessarily what they think will sell (because they could write an album for simply big money purposes), instead its a display of their progress as musicians.. at worst the album is a little dull, but "Overdue", "Stay Gone", "Let the Reigns Go Loose", and "Grunge Pig" are GUK memorables..

Anonymous (September 3, 2002)

Honestly i think that this album shows that te gt up kids are falling apart. If they dont change fast then there gunna be a band that sit y a fire and sings folk songs. There god musicians, and the Midwet Rock type o music wa a success. It as the ablum was even too emo, it wa to boring. AI think there work on this album was indeed horrible, and the album showed. I will no settle for this. I'l just hav to cntinue listening to Red Letter Day Somthin to Write Home About, & For Minuete Mile, until they get there act together. Its a shame, there my favorite band, i hope for geat chnge i do, n so does a lot o people.
By Eric Killian

Belve (August 30, 2002)

one of my favorite cds, different from there past releases, but change is good. this shows them maturing and progressing musically.

Anonymous (August 24, 2002)

This album rules!!!!

Anonymous (August 10, 2002)

this album was great. i havent been a tguk fan for very long, in fact this was the first album i had lestiend to. after buying this i bought something to write home about and loved it the same. even thou the two are totally diff. i like the type of music they changed or excpreinced with. emo is a gener that is diffinantly a trend. and emotion is in good music any music with emotion is cool. im a hardcore kid and i took a chance and now i lesten to dashboard conffesional and i love it. its no glass jaw or refused but its still bad ass!thubs u tguks fucking rock and if your redkneck you wont like this or if your a meatle head who lestiens to metalica cause then your deff a redkneck so fuck off!

Anonymous (August 9, 2002)

I happen to think this album is great. Granted, it's not what I expected, but what the hell. After a couple of listens, it really grows on you.

And by the way... Four Minute Mile and Woodson are way better than Something to Write Home About.

Anonymous (July 30, 2002)

This album is fucking good! So what if its different to the classic 'something to write home about', its a great album.

Anonymous (July 26, 2002)

shit man! what tha fuck is it?? This album sucks! I want the old Tguk back, indie really sucks, i won´t go to GUKs show again! I want the EMO BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!! i wonder if they did this shit (album) so as to sell more! A dissapointed old FAN..

Anonymous (July 25, 2002)

I agree with TheGetupChick and all the people who have said this before...this album was an immense disappointment for me.

It wasn't entirely unexpected though; when I heard they were going to do something different than Something to Write Home About, and go with more of a classic rock feel I was extremely worried. My fears came true. Even when I heard the whole album had a slower feel I still had some hope. The slower songs they made were still great. But it feels like all their energy has been completely drained out of their songs.

Something to Write Home About has to be one of my all time favorites albums, if not my favorite overall. That album is immortal IMO. So maybe no album could've lived up to it. Somehow though, I doubt it, and, again, it's been said before, it's not so much the sound switch as the song's being boring and lifeless that make this album a real bummer. Just wanted to throw in my opinion.

-Brendan

Anonymous (July 23, 2002)

This CD sucks and that's all there is to it. If you don't believe it, then come to a show, and watch the disappointment on the faces of the entire crowd when all they play are the shitty new songs. I was just at the KC show, and it was awful. This is their hometown, where some of their most dedicated fans who have known them for years are. (I should know, I am one.) No one wants to say it to their faces, but the album BLOWS guys, seriously. I listened to it a million times and I just can't even take it one more time. I think I'll sell it back to the Love Garden Sounds....sorry.

TheGetupChick (July 22, 2002)

The first GUKs Cd I bought was something to write home about. At first I didnt listen to it that much...but then when I was tired of my other CDs I put in the GUK and I absolutly LOVED IT! I just kept listening to it in the shower, on the way to school everywhere! Then I bought the Four MInute Mile and I just kept buying their Cd's and I NEVER got tired of them! They are just like my favorite band, and I LOVe their drummer he has so much rythm. So I considered myself one of the BIGGEST GUKs fans! I finally saw them in concert in Las VEgas....I was so excited about it. And TGUK just played their new shitty ol' songs...and live they just really sucked (well the audience was lame 2) when the GUK played their old stuff every1 was happy, then the new stuff it was like NO! For some reason I just dont really care for their New Cd....but I will alwayz love their old music, and I still cant go a day w/ out hearing one of their songs!

Anonymous (July 19, 2002)

I got this album when it first came out, rushed home, threw it on and was immediately dissappointed. I left in my desk for a month or so and found it one day and said what the fuck, i'll play it, after all I never listened to the whole thing. Well HOLY SHIT..this album is really great. It's just damn good indie rock...leavin' the gay emo shit behind was a good move.

Anonymous (July 19, 2002)

If I don't fall asleep to this album, then you guys will, bitching about categorizing music like sorting fucking mixed play-doh, it's just plain ignorant.
like what the fuck is the rock-pop section????

Anonymous (July 13, 2002)

ever since i heard my first get up kids song, i haven't gone a day without listening to one of their songs. they seemed almost too good to be true. the songs seemed so inspired and freeflowing. each instrument tickled more than just my sense of hearing. and the drumlines... the most creative i have ever come to know. when i heard overdue for the first time, i thought the song was cool and figured it would be the exception on the album with regard to its not being much like the kids' previously released music. i couldn't have been more mistaken. Almost the entire album has a depressing theme to it. They seem almost like a different band altogether. i suppose if this were the first album i had ever heard from the get up kids, i might have rated it a 6 or 7. but considering their older shit, i can't help but be extremely disappointed. but hey, there's gotta be a reason for this album turning out the way it did; that's what i'm bent on finding out.

Anonymous (July 8, 2002)

this alblum is great because it is different from the rest. If anyone was a true music fan rather than a "hardcore punk rocker" they would really see the alblum for what its worth. There are some songs that lack at some points but as a whole i think the alblum is fantastic. Plus "Campfire Kansas" is a fucking awesome song. But what do i know im not punk.

Anonymous (July 4, 2002)

personally i think this scott dude is a total fucktard. so what if this cd doesn't sound like the rest. i have loved tguk for a long time and i don't intend to stop. i love the new cd, and the songs were great live as well. maybe you should listen to the cd more than once before you critique it.

Anonymous (July 3, 2002)

hey scott, just to tell u, i went to tguk show in dc and they played campfire kansas live...it rocked. tguk are the best band alive and their new album is just tguk trying out new stuff-they arent copying off anyone...their music is original and just plain COOL! But I do agree, their old stuff is the best ever.

Anonymous (July 3, 2002)

anyways this album is good...i mean it sounds like a definite group effort. this album has some of my favorite songs by them [hannah hold on, campfire kansas, fall from grace]...i'd tell anyone i know to buy this - yuou cant base a review of an album on comparisons to past albums theyve made. the question is...if this was a NEW band coming out, with this being their debut CD, would you still give it such bad reviews?

Anonymous (July 3, 2002)

huh-huh...WIMPCORE - did you make that up yourself you fucking idiot? some people shiould be banned from places like this. heres to you man fuck off and maybe LISTEN t6o music inste4ad of hearing it once and saying - oooh this is DIFFERENT i hate it. fuckin wanker.

Anonymous (June 23, 2002)

blaaah

Anonymous (June 23, 2002)

I think it was 1996 when The Get Up Kids became my cd players new obsession. I would drive from coast to coast with The Four Minute Mile, Woodson and Red Letter Day non stop for 40 plus hours and I never got sick of the same songs. I got to see The Get up Kids in North Carolina in a small record store in Chapel Hill to then watch them play at the Cat's Cradle the same night, it was nothing but Amazing I must say! I bought "On A wire" about a month ago and I have forced myself to like it but it just aint happening. I can't think of 1 get up kids song that i don't like but this record has more than a few. I actually thought it was the wrong cd in the cd case that I just purched when i first heard it since i always skip the first track to play the cd from the middle. It's just some weird bullshit thing I do when i hear a cd for the first time. I hear some New Amsterdam coming through in this plus some other style that i have no idea or care where it came from. I love the new amsterdams but lets keep the get up kids a seperate deal....."just like my opinion man.....the Get up Kids will remain my favorite but this cd was not a good one, cool to experiment but I want to hear what sounds good and this does not sound good to me at all. i can swallow about three tracks, Track 1 is great, track 8 is amazing but that is all I can deal with. the get up kids are so amazing for what they have released thus far so don't count them out. The Get up kids are the best even to a old 30 year old washed up skateboarder. Take care!!

Anonymous (June 15, 2002)

This album is a complete disappointment to any rock fan. I don't know if it should be considered ironic or simply a trade off for selling records to audiences who never supported bands when they were "local." Local doesn't carry with it the hope of being big; it displays a love for music and those who take the time and energy to venture past programmed radio stations. I can't help but ask, "who is their audience?" I skipped through every track and will skip the next album release. The get up kids should be changed to the GET OUT KIDS. Seriously, a song titled "Campfire Kansas" belongs on the soundtrack of "Wizard of Oz."

Anonymous (June 12, 2002)

Read this too, more fft
For a band that's seemed to always be ahead of the curve in genre development, THE GET UP KIDS' third full-length album is truly a "gut check" kind of disc. In order to truly appreciate the level in which "On A Wire" works, one must drop all expectations and preconceived notions of what a GET UP KIDS release should sound like, simply because this band no longer can be pigeon-holed into a particular formula.

Along those lines, I'm nothing but awed with the direction this band has taken. Athough there exists an occasional glimpse of that emo-rock sound that this band almost single-handedly launched into mass hysteria, those moments are few and far between. "On A Wire" is a magnificently well thought-out album, opening and closing with mellow, almost acoustic tunes that stroke and wind down the flames of curiousity. If there's one word to characterize this revised sound, it's smooth. Matt Pryor's vocals come off as relaxed and comfortable as ever - whereas on previous releases, Pryor had to reach to achieve some kind of urgency. The title track,"On A Wire," features Pryor in a much more focused manner, and that compliments the less intrusive (but far superior) use of keyboards and electronic touches. The sixth track, "High As The Moon" is a relative low-point as it reminds me of the lazy, lounge pop of KOUFAX, but it comes after the rockin' "Grunge Pig" which oozes of bitterness. "Wish You Were Here," and "The Worst Idea" are both vintage GET UP KIDS pop songs, that I'm sure will be infectious live. It's nearly impossible to not sing-along to the former's title, and the keyboard work is super bouncy. "Hannah Hold On," finishes off the opus, and while it's somewhat of a downer, it's in true, GET UP KIDS' fighting spirit.

With their first release of original material in nearly four years, the GET UP KIDS have reinvented themselves into an act that's far mature beyond their previous musical experiences. Although "On A Wire" is far from being a heavy release in terms of loudness, it's as powerful in terms of context as anything else in my collection. The artwork and overall presentation is simply astounding, with a tri-fold paper sleeve, and die-cut insert section. Unfortunately, the lyrics aren't included, but if anything, that only makes you want to listen harder. I'm stunned, excited, and inspired by "On A Wire," as this release screams, "totally worth the wait."

Anonymous (June 12, 2002)

This CD is really a great CD, I first heard TGUK when i heard Something To Write Home About, as soon as i heard it i bought it, then I started buying all there other CD's like 4 minute mile, Eudora, REd Letter Woodson. Personally, i love every last one of those cd's, at first i didnt like the keyboard stuff they did, at all, but after a while it kinda rgows on ya. I was expecting something a little bit more upbeat from them with this album and at first, i was sorely dissappointed, but if you actually take the time to listen to most of the songs you will actually start to appreciate it more, here's a few qoutes i would like you all to read,just a little food for thought.
"We wanted to make a record that was more song-oriented and not like guitar-rock-oriented, and I think we did it," Rob Pope says. "We're not a punk-rock band and we never said we were; we never carried that flag. We've always just tried to do our own thing and do it different than any other band is doing it. I think if people are fans of music and they've been fans of us, it's a departure, but it's not that huge a thing. While we were making the record, we were asking ourselves, "Is the average 15-year-old kid who comes to our shows going to like this?? Then we realized that we just can't worry about that."

Or, as Pryor sings in "Hannah, Hold On," "You only disappoint the ones who don't believe." -TGUK

The bottom line is that if you dont like this album, then too bad, ita agreat album regardless of what anyone says and im a true fan of their older stuff and look, i still like this one, i probably listen to this one more now than any of the others. And why should theyt keep doin the same thing and sound like everyone else. Its a great album, every song,and if you dont like it, tough. If you are a TRUE fan of The Get Up Kids, buy this CD, actually listen to it and enjoy it for what its worth, i highly reccomend this CD, it will not dissappoint you.

Anonymous (June 12, 2002)

Scott sucks big dick.
I think this album is really kickass, it's what got me into The Get Up Kids. I seriously hope that how other people review albums is not a determining factor in whether or not they buy them.
I happen to like the keyboard, especially live. I'm tired of bass, guitar, and drums. *rolls eyes*
So everyone, buy the damn album and think for yourselves.
Fuck you buddy.
I never liked critics anyway.

Anonymous (June 4, 2002)

While it isn't quite as catchy and great as something to write home about i think the album is pretty good. it's a way different sound than their previous albums but what can you excpect people to grow up and mature and keep playing the exact same music that got them to the top of the indie scene. that's ridiculous. i just saw them live and all the new songs came off great and more rockin then the cd so maybe you guys should go see them live and then make your harsh judgements.

Anonymous (May 23, 2002)

face to face sucks just as bad as the get up kids.

myfaceisonfire (May 22, 2002)

"Who's idea was it to let morons hear music?"

Maybe a better question might be "Who's idea was it to let morons use a computer?"

Anonymous (May 22, 2002)

"fugazi rules- and fugazi isn't emo, by what the description of emo is- then Ben E King and those old time '50's love singers were Emo as well dumbshits- emo seems to be whinning about girls and relationships- or crying about something. I don't hear Fugazi whinning about girls or relationships, their music doesn't have a genre, it's just great music. "

You are seriously the dumbest person I've ever encountered. So emo is noly about whining about girls? Ok, I guess if you think so, it must be right. Um, once again, Fugazi is emo. If you want a decent explanation of what emo is, visit fourfa.com.

Anonymous (May 22, 2002)

Oh no, it looks like GUK abandoned the formula they perfected, and you're all sad. Who's idea was it to let morons hear music?

Anonymous (May 21, 2002)

I also just noticed that Scott gave this album a better rating than he did the new Face to Face...now that is a crime. It's no good having lots of reviews in your portfolio if none of them are accurate. - bigjerk

Anonymous (May 21, 2002)

This album blows. A few good songs but that's it...what a disappointment. Here's to all the emo kids regretting the TGUK tattoos they got a few years ago. - bigjerk

Anonymous (May 21, 2002)

Pretty amazing that such a bad record can cause such comment mayhem. Hahahaha. I on the other hand am just commenting to comment on that fact. And oh I almost forgot, since the split with rocket from the crypt came out I knew that their next album would be mid-tempo Cheap Trick (after they lost their edge) kinda boring FM poprock. But hay if that's what they gotta do.. Now they pulled a Cars (anno 1987), maybe next time they will pull a (godforbid) Incubus...

myfaceisonfire (May 20, 2002)

To whoever was bitching about the naysayers being 13 year old kids:

So you're saying that since I don't like this new album, I'm 13 years old? Pure genious. I'm not ragging on the band for changing their sound, that's fine, I'm ragging on them because they put out a shitty album, plian and simple. I don't like it. If you tell me I'm 13 for that, then so be it. I'd be willing to bet that I've spent more years on this planet than you have though, either that or you're just incredibly stupid. Anybody that starts making such broad generalizations obviously hasn't yet grown out of their "I'm cooler than you" stage.

This album just doesn't interest me. I'd go buy pick up the new New Amsterdams album if I wanted to listen to alt.country, but I don't. Campfire Kansas is a good song, but I think that's the only bright spot on the whole thing.

Anonymous (May 20, 2002)

by the way- I never said Fugazi was pussy compared to Minor Threat dipshit- I said these pop emo bands are- not fugazi, fugazi rules- and fugazi isn't emo, by what the description of emo is- then Ben E King and those old time '50's love singers were Emo as well dumbshits- emo seems to be whinning about girls and relationships- or crying about something. I don't hear Fugazi whinning about girls or relationships, their music doesn't have a genre, it's just great music. Planes Mistaken For Stars is about as hardcore as they come- that isn't emo- what exactly makes a band "emo" and what makes a band "punk"? Huh? Dipshits? I mean, these "punk" bands nowadays resemble nothing of what punk was to begin with- so what makes them "punk"? Is it because htey started out independent? Most bands do idiots. The whole point and the whole purpose was lost long ago and now all we have are people like yourselves trying to place things into a genre the "corporations" basically created for you. You disgrace me and music in general. Die.....Please Die!

Anonymous (May 20, 2002)

Fucking idiots!- that sums up anyone who listens to this shit and everyone defending this band. CASE CLOSED

Anonymous (May 19, 2002)

"[insert band name] is emo" "[insert band name] is not emo you fucking idiot"All I ever hear on this site is how emo sucks and how too many bands these days are trying to be emo and are "selling out" or whatever. If emo is all that bad why does it matter who is emo and who isnt. Fuck it all, right?

Anonymous (May 19, 2002)

How can Fugazi not be emo whenever people heard them, tried to label them, and called them emocore? Isn't it hard not to be something when you invented it? Its like saying the Ramones aren't punk. Fugazi may not be mall emo...but dont say theyre not emo... and please figure out what youre talking about. dont just go buy the genre markers at hot topic. by the way, they have a new saves the day patch that you need to buy and iron on your emo shirt.

Anonymous (May 19, 2002)

The whole album is just a cheap immitation on Elliott Smith but with more of a Clingy, Geek vibe to it. They should stick to the Hard Rawwwk.

Kurt_F (May 19, 2002)

Oh and to the idiot who said Fugazi aren't emo: That made me laugh for no less than 87 minutes. Then you go on to say that they are pussy compared to bands like Minor Threat? Well, considering some certain Fugazi members were in Minor Threat........

Kurt_F (May 19, 2002)

Calling London: I don't care what your friends think is emo. They are wrong. Who cares if TGUK have influenced new bands. Doesn't matter. They are'nt emo.

Scotty, I like you. Where's Jimi to come and school these kids? I need some help dude....oh and uh, Emo IS a genre, sorry. Oh and uh, Planes Mistaken for Stars ARE emo, sorry.

CallingLondon (May 18, 2002)

wow, i did use the word "emo" a lot in my last post, didn't i? I know i don't know everything about the style of music, however, i do know enough about it to know that TGUK is the band most people (or atleast my friends) think of when they think of emo. i also know that they've influenced a bunch of newer bands.

Anonymous (May 18, 2002)

Ummm... emo is not a trend... well it is, but it has been around a long time as well (not as a trend of course), and yes it is considered a genre of music.

-Scotty

Anonymous (May 17, 2002)

I just read the response to my last comment about how much I was looking forward to this cd and all I have to say is if listening to this album and weezer makes me a pussy then fuck that I am a pussy. Call me what you like but I am going to listen to what I want and what I like. You know what I always say?... pick what you like and like what you pick. Carry that over into musical tastes and you will be fine... fuck everyone else that might give you shit!

Anonymous (May 17, 2002)

I just got this album today and I love it... but I am thinking it will end up in the same pile as Dashboard Confessional, The Anniversary, and a few other of my "emo" albums. They are in the "I will listen to this while I do my homework because it is so good but it wont make me want to sing along with it and I can concentrate" pile. But I am really into this album as of right now... I'm on track 5.

ambiotical_sophisticrat (May 17, 2002)

EMO ISN"T A GENRE, IT'S JUST A TREND

all music is emotional, "emo" is just a trend that will die out hopefully.

Anonymous (May 17, 2002)

It's a stupid fucking name for a genre anyway. Isn't all music supposed to be emotional?

-Scotty

Anonymous (May 17, 2002)

No one can give a clear definition of emo, no one. - bigjerk

Anonymous (May 17, 2002)

i'm really sick of every band's new album being a disappointment...this sounds like country meets really bad pink floyd...i was just waiting for them to rock but they never did...but i still love 'em no matter what...hannah hold on and the first track were pretty good...

Anonymous (May 17, 2002)

drug addict music rules, pennywise sucks. Lou Reed > pennywise jocks. as for this album, i'm sure it gets old after listening to it twice.

Anonymous (May 17, 2002)

"..but the mohawk punk you speak of is even more pathetic- fuckin' drug addict music....Emo bands are pussy compared to bands like Black Flag...."

If it wasn't for the mohawk punk he spoke of, Gregg Ginn would be ripping off some more Black Sabbath riffs. And most of the non-pussy "cause some violence" bands you listed aren't even fucking straight-edge. Do some fucking drugs or read a book instead of shooting roids and wasting time standing in front of your mirror checking to see if you match Rollin's physique yet. I hate fucking 'roid heads like you. There's nothing wrong with being a pussy, 'cause you are what you eat. And I'll bet half of the fucking Emo-heads have enough aggression packed up to knock your "macho" ass on the floor. Grow a neck. I guarentee that you go to shows and make sure you're right up front crossing your little PUDGE fingers hoping the pit behind you won't astray to you. Have a beer and maybe you'll calm down. Fucking asshole.

--ned

Anonymous (May 17, 2002)

I don't know what you guys are all yapping on about...personally i don't give a fuck whether a band is emo or not and the same goes for punk bands, metal bands, rock bands,... I like a lot of different stuff and it's all good in my book as long as the music is good. So stop being so shortsighted and just let the music do the talking

you can read my reviews on:
www.munchkinmusic.be

HungOverHero (May 16, 2002)

Hey,
There's absolutely nothing wrong with watching porn.
Everyone does it.

sargonii2k1 (May 16, 2002)

okay i agree, shut up with the genre bullshit. cos something's quiet doesn't make it "wimpcore" or whatever. Emo came from emotional rock, but whatever, people all interpret it differently. whatever it is, I like it. As for Disturbed... I LIkE MAINSTREAM. I just like more than that too. Sure, there are some fun mainstream bands, but there's so much more, you have to open your ears dude. I stick with my "review" of this cd.

Anonymous (May 16, 2002)

"Planes Mistaken For Stars" isn't Emo you dipshit! Neither is "Fugazi". And Emo is pussy music- but the mohawk punk you speak of is even more pathetic- fuckin' drug addict music. Pennywise rules- and just because you like Pennywise doesn't mean you're a drunk you dumb fuck, I've loved PW for years and I don't drink or party or watch porno you stupid shit- Emo is just for people who would rather cry and complain at shows than jump around and create violent havoc. Emo bands are pussys in comparison to bands like Black Flag, Minor Threat, Pennywise, Danzig, Misfits, and Striking Distance.

Kurt_F (May 16, 2002)

Emo started when hardcore bands in the late 80's basically sang/yelled higher and had more personal lyrics. Fugazi and Rites of Spring are some early emo bands. Some good emo bands from the past few years are: Sunny Day Real Estate (everything before the Rising Tide), Appleseed Cast, Mineral, The Casket Lottery, Cap'n Jazz, Planes Mistaken for Stars, Texas is The Reason, and SOME EARLY Get Up Kids songs. And just for future reference: Dashboard Confessioal is NOT emo. Saves the Day are NOT emo. Jimmy Eat World are NOT emo. (well, except a really old song or 2) The Juliana Theory are NOT emo. Just because a band plays music that isn't always happy or fast and the singer has a high voice doesnt make it emo. By those terms, Rush would be emo. You freaking idiots.

Emo is not pussy music. The purpose of emo isn't to be squeaky clean/over produced/pop-friendly music, it's raw. So if you're some Pennywise loving, beer drinking, skateboarding, Bro who would rather watch porn and Half Baked rather than read a book, or maybe some "screw the system" gutter punk that's to worried about your Casualties patches and mohawk and looking punk enough to actually think, stay away from emo, it's a little to deep for you.

If you think emo is "pussy": Download "Trust Nolan" from The Casket Lottery, "Life Gets in the Way of Living" from Grade, "The Past Two" from Planes Mistaken For Stars, or maybe "Oh Messy Life" from Cap'n Jazz. Don't be afraid.

-Kurt
p.s.- there is nothing wrong with Pennywise, I was just using an example of the typical so-cal bro-punk

Anonymous (May 16, 2002)

I found this cd in the used bin the day after it came out. It really didn't surprise me that someone sold it already. I'm not gonna say it's bad or anything, but I love every album they released before this one. I personally think they've taken a turn for the worst, but that's just my opinion. I'm not into the mellow stuff like this, I'd rather listen to Sunny Day Real Estate or Braid if I'm looking for something more relaxing. The new Guk cd just seems to lack energy. I really wish I could buy it but I really can't stand it. It's too bad too cause I was really looking forward to it.

-Scotty

Anonymous (May 16, 2002)

It just sounds kinda jaded to me. I'm not sure what to think of this. Maybe they have lost their drive? What's up with all the stoopid synthwankin'? This guy used to fuck it up with Coalesce... And; for all you "they are this and that style": grow the fuck up. One day, maybe, you'll figure out that music is just music. Ah, by the way, I'm way into the whole post-emo/new-crust/avant-punk thing! Shiat..

Anonymous (May 15, 2002)

If you Like or Dislike THE GET UP KIDS
U'll love Big Treats one word "incredible" to get your hands on this bad boy
send:$10 $1 shipping to:
Crafty Records
75 Earley St.
Bronx, NY 10464

Anonymous (May 15, 2002)

to calling london: what makes you think that you know exactly what modern emo is? and i find it halarious that you used the word emo 5 times in one four line comment...

Anonymous (May 15, 2002)

What the hell is Emo? Is Emo the same thing as wimpcore?

Anonymous (May 15, 2002)

I konw i am, thank you

CallingLondon (May 15, 2002)

the get up kids aren't emo? what are you talking about? of course they're emo. they're like, or were on they're last two albums, the definition of modern emo. i'm not saying this is a bad thing. i don't have a problem with the style, but i love how for every single emo band out today, there are people who say that band isn't emo.

Anonymous (May 15, 2002)

"Annoying vocals, generic musically- just pop- period, terrible music with no intensity. This is music for guy's who had their balls chopped off and feel no testosterone"

-- You're such a man.

Anonymous (May 15, 2002)

for the last three years the get up kids have continued to amaze me. This new album marks another change for the kids and its one for the better. they've matured at musicians and lyricists in the last few years. the new songs have a laid back, tired feel but they really seem to show that this is where the kids are at right now and i for one really enjoy it. you can tell that they're giving it their all and i commend them.

evildeadalive (May 15, 2002)

You are talking to people about mainstream while you actually like Disturbed?

sargonii2k1 (May 15, 2002)

Word. I bought this CD the first day it came out. Mind, my musical taste runs from Dashboard and the Lyndsay Diaries to Anti-Flag to Throwdown to Disturbed to Pink Floyd :) to the Beatles, I like a whole lot of music. This CD, in my opinion, is absolutely amazing. It isn't pop. It doesn't immediately get stuck in your head. It's laid back. But it has so many classic rock influences, while maintaining what TGUK already had, that it's just amazing. This CD is probably in my top five CD's of all time. They are a unique band, so some don't like it. That's fine, go listen to your mainstream. But they have a great sound, and it's proven that people like it. So don't listen to this review that says it's uninspired crap. I'm amazed, as well, that while Matthew Pryor is married, he still manages to maintain the type of music characteristic of a somewhat younger generation, adapting the content to his own life. REALLY. Check this CD out. It's really good. That is all.

And no they are not emo, and DEFINITELY not run-of-the-mill. Grow up and broaden your horizons. Or go listen to your Blink.

Anonymous (May 15, 2002)

To the person below me: You are a complete idiot. TGUK aren't emo. And we've all known for awhile that punknews.org doesn't just show "punk" news. You have very low intelligence.

Anonymous (May 15, 2002)

Don't compare these little girls to the Beach Boys. It's not like The Beach Boys were hard or anything- but they played great music- unlike these people. This band is just run of the mill emo crap- I don't get it- this sin't punk at all. What's sad is that if someone wrote a review for a metal band like Danzig, which is far closer to punk than this wimpy stuff, people would complain about it being metal- but this isn't punk in the slightest bit- punk seems to be dead and the only aggression remaining is from some new Hardcore bands and old guys like Rollins and Danzig who can still get it done- this stuff is weak,if this is what "punk" is than I don't want anything to do with "punk".

Anonymous (May 15, 2002)

It's one thing for a band to grow and change from one album to the next, constantly evolving their style, but this abandons their style completely.

This reminds me of when the Beach Boys grew their hair out, had huge beards, and started playing hippie music to prove they weren't just a surf band and Brian Wilson wasn't the only one who could write songs. The Get Up Kids are trying to prove they aren't just a punk/emo band and that Matthew Pryor isn't the only one who writes the songs...

There are plenty of bands who have released sub-par records, and this is one of them. Let's hope Reggie won't sound this serious and stale.

Anonymous (May 15, 2002)

all of you who are complaining about the album "not sounding the same as the last one" are a bunch of 13 year old cunts. bands change, at least the good ones do. it would be incredibly boring if every album sounded the same. i'm glad the get up kids ditched the punk influence for a more rock 'n' roll sound and i'm glad they made this album. if you just plain dislike it that's one thing but if you dislike it because it doesn't sound like their old stuff your just being immature. some say this will alienate some fans, well if those fans are the people who want GUK to ake 'four minute mile' over and over then i say to hell with you. i'mglad your alienated because your obviously closed minded and not deserving of such an incredible band. listen to the ataris, they never do anything creative.

Anonymous (May 15, 2002)

We won't give you shit- we'll just call you what you rightfully are- A PUSSY!!!

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

I like TGUK. Thats all there is to it. I will probably buy this album and the new weezer very soon. So you can all suck my balls if you dont like them and give me or any other fan shit.

Adam (May 14, 2002)

Very nice review. To me this is no more than a common tale. I've anticipated this album and i've looked forward to it for so long. It's happened many times in where i put on a cd for the first time and find that it's something totally different than what i expected. Now i'm not dissin the latest material from the get up kids, it's just that when i anticiapted this album, i anticipated to hear rocking tunes with crazy guitar riffs and catchy keyboard melodies. You know, what tguk are known for. The review made a good point on pryor's side project, the new amsterdams. You can definetly see an abundence of similarities in the lyrics and the music. All in all, i see myself listening to this album seldomly. I appreciate it for what it is. Don't get me wrong, it's great music, it's just not what i expected.

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

horrible sounding, i found the cd on audiogalaxy 2 weeks ago, i know at first i said the same thing about saves the day's new album and it grew on me, but theres no way i can get used to this. pray that they dont play this shit at shows this summer. its a shame

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

how many friggin bands have a cd with the song name "wish you were here" on it?

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

I really like all of The Get Up Kids older albums. But I'm pretty sure I will never buy this album. If a friend of mine does happen to buy it, I might burn it, but thats it. Seriously though, their other albums are pure genious (not the complation one).

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

I'm really looking forward to hearing this, I don't care what anyone else thinks. I enjoy their music, and I almost guarantee I will love this album.

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

I think the only thing working on this album, and keeping it from sounding like a totally generic alt-rock/emo band, are Mathew Pryor's vocals. Their last album had slow tracks, but they were pleasant to listen to. These tracks aren't even that slow, just boring.

I can't imagine how these songs would sound live, the Get Up Kids used to always play with so much energy and passion. The last time I saw them with Weezer, half of them walked out dressed in 1970's thrift store clothes like they were the band in Almost Famous. I should of known we'd be in trouble then...

They're trying too hard to sound different, if only some of that energy transferred to the songs.

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

This is pathetic

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

I agree, this album is bad, but I like some emo.

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

Annoying vocals, generic musically- just pop- period, terrible music with no intensity. This is music for guy's who had their balls chopped off and feel no testosterone

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

wimpy album. period. These guys sound like every other wimpcore band.

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

This goes out to the comment 3 down from me. What should they do when they are burnt by flak? You say get pissed?!? That is the worst reaction. THat is what is wanted and, moreover, expected by the persons throwing the flak. You say they are bending over, I say they are responding with a non-suttle anger/aggression. Violence is not a response, it's an impulse. It's an ignorant and arrogant result of acting on that impulse. The Get Up Kids responded with an ablum they deemed worthy, isntead of going reactionary and I commend them for it. Songs 5,6,12 are incredible. SOrry I don't know the names off top of my head.

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

I'll go on record saying that I like TGUK..make fun of me, please. But I have yet to hear this album. - bigjerk

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

Weak musicaly? If theres one thing that the get up kids arent is weak musicaly. The structures a way more complex than any punk or emo band i've heard. The riffs have plenty of variety and the drummer is freakin excellent. I would know, I am a drummer. Their just more suttle. I love the new album, it`s not like the older stuff but it is still great. Overdue is so good, I listen to it like 10 times a day.

-ejaculine

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

Very well written review I must say, kudos. But this band is just very weak musically and lyrically. I tried a few songs off this album and it wasn't bad, just wasn't anything- it made me feel nothing. Just, whatever- get some fuckin' energy. And the answer to your question- what should a band do when it is burnt out by flak and criticism? Go completely insane and be as brutal and violent as possible and do exactly what YOU want- these guys seem to just be bending over to takei t, rather than getting pissed- but then again, this is a pop band, so don't expect much

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

They might lose some of their fan base, but remember, they made a huge sound change in between Four Minute Mile and Something to Write Home About as well, so this is not uprecedented. Anyways, I haven't heard it yet, so I'll hold off my opinions until I do.

Anonymous (May 14, 2002)

I agree with your review. The slow songs like Hannah and campfire kansas are all really good, its just theres no real good rocking songs to balance it. I like it, its just no something to write home about.

So in comparison to other of there albums its a 6, overall a 7, maybe 8 for campfire kansas which I really like.

wyzo

Exclusive Streams

Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Other Places to Go