Punknews.org
Skin Like Iron - Descent Into Light [12-inch] (Cover Artwork)

Skin Like Iron

Skin Like Iron: Descent Into Light [12-inch]Descent Into Light [12-inch] (2010)
Six Feet Under

Reviewer Rating: 1.5


Contributed by: OverDefinedOverDefined
(others by this writer | submit your own)

This is a strange record to figure out. This band has a great name, a cool album cover, and the recording quality is thick and full with an awesome guitar tone, but the actual content of the record leave me shaking my head in confusion. The problem with this band is the music. Since this is, I as.
iTunes Store


This is a strange record to figure out. This band has a great name, a cool album cover, and the recording quality is thick and full with an awesome guitar tone, but the actual content of the record leave me shaking my head in confusion.

The problem with this band is the music. Since this is, I assume, a hardcore band, the only actual melody is in the guitar parts, which take center stage for the entire record and are elevated high above everything else in the mix–an approach that can work well when the guitars are done well. However, Skin Like Iron's riffs just don't make sense melodically. They slip in and out of tonality, often in a major key (which is odd, since 99.999% of heavy music is in a minor key), and sometimes without any tonal center at all. There are times where it sounds like the writer just moved his hands around without worrying about what it really sounds like, almost randomly.

For instance, the opening riff of the record ("Animals") is just a major scale going down and up. It sounds like a high school marching band warm-up. Then there is the main riff to the track "Survival", which sounds like nothing, just random notes. The guitars also have the annoying tendency, almost always, of throwing on the extra fifth on the bottom of power chords. For guitar players, it's that thing when you play a power chord on the A-string and then bar your first finger to the E-string as well so that you are playing the E and A strings on the same fret. I've always felt that this trick should be used as more of a spice; it's very annoying when used as a crutch, which is what SLI does over and over on this record.

The only thing I can come up with why Skin Like Iron would want to sound atonal or try to play in a major key so often is that occasionally this sounds like Fucked Up, who often play in a major key, but actually pull it off. With all of that, there are two instances on the record that I thought worked and sounded good. The first is in the track "Violent Trauma", which sounds like old Bad Religion with screaming, and the intro riff to "A Metropolis Collapsed", which makes the atonality work before the song shifts into another weird riff that just doesn't work.

As for the rest of the record, the vocals are screamed, sounding a bit like a higher-pitched Integrity. The lyrics are typical apocalypse-predicting fare that is common in many modern hardcore bands. In "A Metropolis Collapsed": "Nothing remains, nothing stands. In the shadows of a metropolis collapsed. Nothing remains of the days when life once thrived. The sunshine–so bright–bright enough to blind your eyes. No memories remain to remind you of the time you were alive." And so on. As for the drums, they are buried in the mix, but there is a drum break in the song "Survival" where the drummer is just playing the D-beat by himself and it's done pretty poorly.

Ultimately, this is a weird record. It looks nice from the outside, but the content suffers from the atonal guitar riffs and lack of real substance in the lyrics. I don't see anyone on this site being into this.

 

 
People who liked this also liked:
Hot Water Music - Til the Wheels Fall OffPelican - What We All Come to NeedCeremony - Rohnert ParkBlack Breath - Heavy BreathingCrime in Stereo - I Was Trying to Describe You to SomeoneNew Lows - New LowsThe Effort - IconoclasmVerse - From Anger and RageFrontier(s) - The Plains [7-inch]The Body - All the Waters of the Earth Shall Turn to Blood

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
conduit (February 7, 2011)

I'm not offended, I just highly disagree.

danpib08 (February 7, 2011)

You're name is misenthropic.

Misanthropee (February 7, 2011)

Huh? Both reviews I have listed are positive, one effusively so. I don't enjoy "talking shit" either. What I do enjoy is journalistic objectivity. If something stirs a desire in me to write about it, positive or negative, I will. It's just as narcissistic to gush about stuff you like all the time as it is to constantly cut down what you dislike.

Yeesh, I was actually trying to complement your providing some much-needed balance to a reviews section that's overall been a love-fest since the ban on anonymous posting ages ago. No need to go negative, you shit-talker, you!

overdefined (February 6, 2011)

Why? What's the point in writing a bunch of scathing reviews at the expense of a record I actually like not getting a review at all? Most of the records I review on this site wouldn't even get a review if I didn't do it. And get this, I prefer to NOT spend all my time talking shit. I will write a certain amount of reviews this year and I would rather fill those with things that I think are great than waste my time shitting on someone else's efforts. It's pretty awesome that you're going to submit a review bashing something. Great use of your time.

And btw - Brian asked me specifically to review this record.

Misanthropee (February 6, 2011)

Booo, more reviewers need to bring the hate around here. Luckily I'll be saving the day with a 1-star soon.

overdefined (February 6, 2011)

Can't please anyone around here...

Misanthropee: my next review is 4 stars, don't worry.

Misanthropee (February 5, 2011)

Holy fucking jesus, a review that isn't 4 stars!!!

overdefined (February 5, 2011)

@conduit - I'm glad you're personally offended that the riffs on this record are atonal.

conduit (February 5, 2011)

Yeah this record is great, this review is extremely uninformed, it sounds like you know absolutely nothing about hardcore for the most part if you can't tell what this band's influences are or what they are going for, let alone think that "There are times where it sounds like the writer just moved his hands around without worrying about what it really sounds like, almost randomly."

Next time try actually listening to the record more then once, and try making comparisons to bands this band is actually similar to and sounds like instead of pulling random points of reference seemingly out of your ass.

rjr (February 4, 2011)

very good record.

raveneffect (February 4, 2011)

Saw these guys open for Ceremony during the summer. They were really fun and tight live. I dig this record because of how weird it is.

Exclusive Streams

Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Other Places to Go