Remember last month when my fine feathered friend Mr. Todd Kowalski informed you that we had recorded a song for the upcoming "Rock Against Bush" comp coming out on Fat Wreck Chords? Yes, that's the one. You have an excellent memory.
Well, guess which band got booted from it because they refused to remove a pot-shot aimed at international billionaire, global financier, war-profiteer and all-around asswipe George Soros from their liner notes? No, it wasn't Good Charlotte. Good guess though. Try again.
That's right, it was us!
Next time someone comes knocking on our door hawking the virtues of joining a unified front against something, we'll be sure to ask them this: unity on whose terms? At what cost?
This message not brought to you by George Soros.
Contributed by justindlaird. Posted by aubin on Tuesday, March 16, 2004 at 11:03 AM (EST)
"Propagandhi recorded a song for the Fat Comp. titled "Free John Hinkly" but it was removed because in their liner notes they criticized "international billionaire, global financier, war-profiteer and all-around asswipe George Soros."
Punk Voter (273 comments)
Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way. Seriously.
Aubin (March 16, 2004)
I like Soros, myself... I've read some of his stuff, and put him in the non-evil category of billionaries... along with Warren Buffet who have proved to be more progressive and generous than most people with a lot of money.
"Over the past ten years, Soros has channeled more than two billion dollars into creating a network of non-governmental organizations and activist groups in more than 30 countries. His contributions in Russia, the other countries of the former Soviet Union and Eastern Europe were responsible for creating, almost overnight, a civil society; recently, his philanthropic activities have expanded into southern Africa, Haiti, Guatemala and the United States"
Soros made a lot of his money - $1B in one day - by shorting the British pound, and was criticized heavily by the British government.
I wish Propagandhi - a band I do respect - would outline their show rest of comment 4+ Replies
KirbyPuckett (March 16, 2004)
In other news... I got my wish. I woke up this morning and Absolutepunk.net was ad-free. - Kirby 5+ Replies
squirrelbait (March 16, 2004)
So does this mean that Fat Mike himself wouldn't allow them to have that in the liner notes? If so, than that's pretty hypocrital of him.
Someone (March 16, 2004)
Who made this decision? Fat mike? Angry record retailers? I want more information. I e-mailed fat to get their side and I hope they will tell us more. And who the fuck is George Soros? 5+ Replies
Skanknsmile (March 16, 2004)
i wouldn't expect this from fat mike, since they are like the first band he signed to his label and has more history with them rather than some of the shitty ass bands on the comp like good charlotte. i wanna hear the song now. damn it all
Someone (March 16, 2004)
Is anyone else sick of Propagandhi criticizing the US? They're CANADIAN!!! As US citizens, we have the right and the responsibility to question our government and people of power. As Canadian citizens, it seems like they are sitting on the other side of the fence taking shots at our country. And while it is true a foreign band can "Rock Against Bush" because he has affected the entire world with his idiocy, they have been criticizing the US since How To Clean Everything (see Stick the Fucking Flag Up Your Goddamn Ass, You Sonofabitch). It's like you can complain about you mom being a bitch all you want because she's your mom, but when the kid next door calls her a bitch, you're gonna knock his teeth out. 33+ Replies
Jimmy_the_Saint (March 16, 2004)
Does this mean that NOFX can't put their song on the Rock Against Paul Edgar Phillipe Martin comp? 2+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
this would have to seem to be fat wreck/propagandhi split, and not in the split seven inch way
Someone (March 16, 2004)
If this was fat mike's doing I do believe that he's gonna lose a lot of other bands on his label as well. This could be the worst move Fat Mike has ever made. 2+ Replies
LushJ (March 16, 2004)
If it's a unity comp against George Bush, internecine sniping should be kept to a minimum. The Left has enough problems with all of us talking shit on each other, and tearing each other down for slight policy/ideological differences. Punkvoter and the Fat comp is meant to be broad-based and inclusive, not divisive. To me, it's a logical step to choose to concentrate our attacks and critiques- ON THIS RECORD- to the right and the Bush Administration. It's not "Rock Against Shady Lefty Billionaires"- it's "Rock Against Bush". 4+ Replies
GREG6711 (March 16, 2004)
Prediction: i would not expect to see Propagandhi's next record on Fat. 1+ Reply
Someone (March 16, 2004)
Propagandhi's got balls the rest of you so called punx only wish you had. Even if they're wrong in this case, they are standing up for what they believe in, and are once again prepared to suffer for it. Ever wonder what it must be like to be Chris, and go through US customs?
Someone (March 16, 2004)
Who gives a shit? Finally Propagandhi can get rid of Fat and release exclusively on G7.
Someone (March 16, 2004)
Propagandhi's website has this on it about americans.
Why do you hate Americans?
We don't hate Americans. I hate the fact that we are even ever asked this question. Some of our best friends are Americans. Seriously, criticisms of America have less, if anything at all, to do with individual citizens, and everything to do with a level of power concentrated in the hands of "American" policy-makers (by and large, rich corporations and their lackey politicians). You have to keep in mind, there are millions of American citizens who live lives in opposition to the role that their country (and most Western countries, Canada included) plays in the suppression and destruction of the values of freedom and democracy. The United States is this planet's only economic and military superpower. We think it's important to ask how it became and how it remains the most influential player on the world's
show rest of comment
Someone (March 16, 2004)
These guys are dumb. First off, they take shots at Bush. First off, he is our president, not yours, you wacky canucks. Second, What's up with your "Artwork" on the intro to your site, Propaghandi? YOu Make GWB's look like HItler? compare? i can see why you would say the iraq issue. But what else did Hitler do that GWB also did? I don't remember Bush sending 11 million minorities to die. I don't remember anything like that at all. YOu are the lamest shits on the planet. "OI OI OI!!! fight the demonic president." I bet if Kerry wins, you'd hate him too. Here is an Idea: worry about your country, not ours. 6+ Replies
GREG6711 (March 16, 2004)
I heard Fat Mike was in a white power band... oh wait, i'm confusing NOFX and Mest again, I guess their that similar. 4+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
This is crap, Propagandhi have every right to put that in the liner notes. Also other countries and Propagandhi talking shit about Bush, big deal. It’s not like the US doesnt bash every other country in the world, even if there suppose to be allies, don’t you remember freedumb fries. Who knows maybe I live in the wrong country it just seems every political show to most people on the street make fun of other countries in some form. I guess if someone bashes the US its are turn to whine and cry like the pussies we are……………
GREG6711 (March 16, 2004)
Anyone ever hear the saying "we become with me hate" I present to you Fat Mike Bush. 1+ Reply
Someone (March 16, 2004)
hmm now that just doesnt make sense... Soros contributed millions to MoveOn.org which is entirely anti-bush...but yet Propaghandi is writing songs criticizing him on an anti-Bush comp...??? 2+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
i don't know much about soros - but i am sick of reading just mindless and baseless crap thrown around. What does propagandhi have against this guy - just calling everyone a nazi is fuckin stupid. So its now punkrock to not read up on issues and call people asswipes? Wow and i thought this band was way more credible than that. I'm not saying i know all the answers - but state what ya got against someone vs. just name calling. I just read soros article on line about America's misuse of power. What if this guy and propagandhi agree on this - or maybe we are all nazis to propagandhi? Funny coming from a band that i thought had a credible background fighting real nazi movements. 2+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
What a fucking surprise? Punkvoter is acting in concert with the group Americans Coming Together, a Democrat-friendly interest group. Americans Coming Together is heavily financed by you know whom? Asswipe George Soros. So exactly whose ass is Punkvoter wiping now? 2+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
clearly some of you have not even listened to Propagandhi that closely...they often criticize Canada, Canadian government policies, etc. Most likely I would put it down to the simple fact that some of you do not KNOW they are talking about Canada because you do not KNOW anything about Canada in the first place yourself.
Someone (March 16, 2004)
Its not like fat mike has major distro industry hacks to answer to when he puts out a record like this. From the surface it looks like fat mikes the bad guy in all of this but who knows.
Someone (March 16, 2004)
funny i just read Soros website - he sounds more pogressive than Propagandhi- oooh wait - he is actually doing shit. Must make him an asswipe! 1+ Reply
GREG6711 (March 16, 2004)
I am not going to see NOFX at Warped tour. I never liked them anyway, but I thought they were okay when I saw them in Chicago while waiting for Bad REligion. you just lost some money from me mister Fat Mike. I can't support the fat wreck comp series either.
Someone (March 16, 2004)
Yep, Fat Mike loves Anti-Flag and bitches CENSORSHIP over the fact that some retailers won't carry their album because of what's on the cover artwork. Yet, Fat Mike won't release even Propagandhi's song on a comp, for fear of offending a war-profiteerring billionaire, whose ass he wants to kiss! Isn't that CENSORSHIP too?! No, in fact, neither case are. Some retailers made a decision not to carry the Anti-Flag album. And Fat Mike made a decision not to carry a song. Both were personal choices made--not from gov't compulsion, which true censorship is. So the next time Fat Mike raises charges of censorship, or does anything else, well, you just think about it first. That's a refreshing idea. 2+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
About Soros- He is an ass, sure. But if I was to be stuck on an Island with either him or Rupert Murdoch, I would choose Soros. He is a advocate of the Tobin tax (which is a very small tax placed on all International transactions. The money would be given to developement NGO's [Non-governmental organizations] to help developing nations. So he is an ok guy. I can guarentee you what Propaghandi's problem would be with Soros is his support for the Democrats. I mean lets face it, sure Kerry is wayyyyyyyyyy better than Bush, but he is still representing half of a two party system and is probobly big-buisness friendly. thats my 2 cents 1+ Reply
Someone (March 16, 2004)
Propagandhi just hasn't been the same since "Less talk, more rock." These days they seem to be taking more of a "less rock, more talk" approach. 1+ Reply
Someone (March 16, 2004)
Is anyone else waiting to find out who'se decision it was and what the motives were before shooting their mouth off?
Frankly, someone way, way above me made a good point: It's rock against BUSH, not an invitation to make scattershot political one liners against other people.
Propaghandi has been known to make wise ass comments against politicans everywhere on their cds, and no one minds. But for this comp, they should have honed their focus, like the rest of the artists, who presumably are singing about the same topic.
It sounds to me like Fat Wreck said, give us an unreleased song that fits in with the theme. That said, Propaghandi probably ignored the last part.
In conclusion, Propaghandi is welcome to do their political commentary of people other than Bush on their own cds. However, when they agree to lay down a song for a comp against President Bush specifically, it be show rest of comment 1+ Reply
Someone (March 16, 2004)
free john hinkley?? great idea- lets send all the murderers and maniacs free - good idea - i believe in correction not death penalty. How many people did hinkley fuck up? 5+ Replies
mikeinflames (March 16, 2004)
all you people flaming on propagandhi for speaking out against bush need to shut your ignorant american faces your wonderful president is destroying the world and killing millions of innocent people worldwide so anyone has the right (no matter what country they are from) to speak out against him it's not just an issue for the u.s. it's an issue for the whole world so stop being stupid typical ignorant americans and open up your mind for once 5+ Replies
FAKESMILE (March 16, 2004)
I agree Bush is an asshole, and screwing up big time. His attitude towards other countries is arrogant and stupid.
Still I think the way some bands are talking shit about Bush is stupid. Yes the man is a fuck-up, but explain why.
Propagandhi are displaying him as hitler on t-shirts and their site. Also I saw NOFX last year and Fat Mike was wearing one of those "not my president" t-shirts and had drawn a swastika on bush' forehead and a little mustash like hitler.
I don't see what they want to achieve.
They should use decent arguments instead of calling him a nazi. Which he isn't. Hitler murdered millions of people. How can anyone say Bush is just a bad as him? I think it's very disrespectful towards those who were killed in WOII and those who still have to live with the traumas that they have from that war.
Bush is not a fucking nazi.
Just an idot who can't lead show rest of comment 4+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
Dear message board,
To put an end to this pointless banter, I provide a rebuttle:
Propagandhi are 3 pretentious individuals from Manitoba, don't worry about their worthless opinion, it carries no more credibility than yours or mine.
They would enjoy to know that this isuue has raised so much attention and controversy.
I want to sell this record to create money for punk voter foundation. I don't want to deal with a legal case as a result of slanderous linear notes. I wants to combat voter apathy and involve the youth of this nation in voting so that we may improve it.
This has nothing to do with George W. Bush(directly), or big business.
I have stood behind propgagandhi, Fat Wreck Chords released 'today's empires' in the year of 9/11. I have legitimate, personal reasons for not including this track with these linear notes on the album.
Propagandhi are arrogant, pompous and condese show rest of comment 5+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
If Fat's beef is just with the liner notes, then remove them and simply include the song as is. 2+ Replies
GregSka (March 16, 2004)
They already lost my respect with their Ska Sucks song. First they said it was a joke, then they said the song was targeted at nazi punks. Nazi punks.. who like ska.. a genre of music created by Jamaicans. I'll believe it when I see it. 3+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
This has nothing to do with Propagandhi, but Fat censorship. Stung Out did record Firecracker for the LIAD album. However, Jason screamed a line directed at presidential assasignation and it was pulled from the album. 2+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
there is more to this story that we should know before making all these baseless assumptions. regardless of the validity of "fat mike's" comment above, they at least state a possible reason for this song not being included. they could face a libel suit for those statements about soros.
but, couldn't fat ask them to just change the liner notes? it's not even the song that's at issue.
and, propagandhi should explain their position on why soros is a bad guy. this is 2004, not 1984. i would hope that punks are smart enough not to accept just empty sloganeering as a rallying cry.
and one other thing. why are people so offended by negative comments about the u.s., but u.s. citizens or not? don't take it so personal. what have you really done to warrant such loyalty and anger? you were mostly likely born here. don't act like you're entitled to some much respect show rest of comment 1+ Reply
Someone (March 16, 2004)
jeez, my spelling errors are atrocious. let's try again:
there is more to this story that we should know before making all these baseless assumptions. regardless of the validity of "fat mike's" comment above, they at least state a possible reason for this song not being included. they could face a libel suit for those statements about soros.
but, couldn't fat ask them to just change the liner notes? it's not even the song that's at issue.
and, propagandhi should explain their position on why soros is a bad guy. this is 2004, not 1984. i would hope that punks are smart enough not to accept just empty sloganeering as a rallying cry.
and one other thing. why are people so offended by negative comments about the u.s., by u.s. citizens or non? don't take it so personal. what have you really done to warrant such loyalty and anger? you were most likely born here. don't a show rest of comment 4+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
this is hilarious, fat mike would be the first person to say that everyone has the right to criticize the President, but the minute somenone criticizes someone he support he removes that band's song and liner notes from his cd. Talk about hypocrisy. I'll be downloading this cd b/c I want some of the songs on this cd, but fat mike won't be getting a penny from me. Hey fat mike, if you are gonna project this image that you should be able to criticize others, why don't you practice what you preach. Disagreeing w/Bush's policies, criticizing him, and supporting voter registration is one thing, but making it personal by putting out a "rock against so and so" cd just makes you look ignorant and pathetic.
Someone (March 16, 2004)
"the other countries of the former Soviet Union and Eastern Europe were responsible for creating, almost overnight, a civil society"
are you fucking joking, if thats not a huge exaggeration for a press release i dont know what is. Its strange you actually take this for truth when they say he's responsible for creating civil society in a whole region of the globe, how can you read language like that and not take it as blatantly tabloid. I hear he also invented water.
And its a liner note, if you want more than a disembodied critique, maybe they should have set out with that purpose. fuck. everytime you say you don't like broccoli I dont ask for a chart I take you at your word and eat my sweet potato, we finish dinner, and i fuck your wife. clean and simple.
I don't care if they made an attack against me, its a liner note for a punk rock comp on fat records, the fac
show rest of comment
Someone (March 16, 2004)
FUCK FAT WERAK, FAT MIKE IS A DUMBASS, PUNKVOTER IS A JOKE. sorry, i'm pissed, it's soo fucking stupid, it's a punk comp, it shouldn't have any songs banned or kicked off, or what ever. FUCK FAT MIKE, FUCK NOFX, FUCK FAT WREAK. I'M VOTING FOR BUSH!!! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH 2+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
It was a mistake to put Propagandhi on such a compilation anyway. This project is trying to get youth to vote out bush and get involved when Propagandhi activley say that people who vote are stupid. Nothing like living under Dictator Bush, complaining about it and then preaching that people shouldn't vote. Yes, I realize that the band is Canadian (the guitar player went to the same elementary school as my girlfriend). When John K. Samson left the band so did the talent. 2+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
Punk Voter was started to...if i recall, try to oust Bush from office, and in doing so prove that the punk community can unite on an issue and stop their bitching to cause an effect on the rest of the world. And what happened? Everyone started fighting over someone's OPINION, and we're all a joke again. Way to go! Of course what Fat Mike did was censorship, he removed an opinion from the public. It doesn't matter if you agree with him, or if you agree with Propaghandi, or if you disagree with everyone. It doesn't fucking change anything to go over and over the same pattern of who's a pussy or who's a dickhead. Propaghandi has a right to their statement, Fat Mike has a right to censor it. But instead of the two uniting and reaching a compromise (something you must do when you unite) they were obstinate and lost a lot of respect, and in Fat Mike's case, fun show rest of comment 1+ Reply
Someone (March 16, 2004)
spoiled, ignorant, suburban dwelling pussies. graduate, move out, pay rent for a decade and then you can pretend to know what you're talking about. till then tune in the oc and rock out to simple plan and keep your misinformed man-pleasers closed. 2+ Replies
Someone (March 16, 2004)
Scott and Kirby's invasion of their board yesterday was hiiiilarious. Took waaay too much of time. I wonder the site is currently "down."
Someone (March 16, 2004)
I cannot believe that I read the words "This has nothing to do with Goerge Bush (directly)" in Fat Mike's statement. The tour is called "Rock Against Bush". He openly and publically criticizes Bush and his administration. He slandered against G dub ya in the new AP. He isn't worried about slander. He has the right to free speech in slandering the president ruthlessly for the past 2 1/2 years but others aren't granted the same freedoms. He also is rich and shows just how pompous he is. He used a public forum to insult Propaghandi. If he were really the person he claims he is, he would have not have responded publicly and he definitely would not have insulted them. It was a private matter and all we, as the public, need to know, is that he didn't approve of the song. He owes us no response.
I would support punk voter if it was an unbiased attempt for show rest of comment 3+ Replies
Someone (June 25, 2004)
what people are failing to recognize here is that propagandhi aren't saying that soros and bush are the same evil, butt that big money and voting is always a bad mix, and that what's the difference between bush and an administration totally controlled by corporate influences and mission statements, and someone offering an alternative and spending a lot of money on it to make a view they support so obvious... politics are co-opted by money far too much, and really it's a fear propagandhi has, that people will shift blindly to one side or the other and before you know it... same shit, different dictators... I don't know a shitload about Soros, and I think as a short term goal, a new prez in 04 is a great idea, however, putting a lot of faith in the next guy could lead us into the same shite...
Someone (August 17, 2004)
I agree with Someone on Friday, June 25, 2004 @ 00:21:10 EDT
Propagandhi anticipated Kerry's election and criticized soros already
soros is on the good side right now, good as opposed to bush-evil side
but he's criticizable
it was probably not the perfect moment to do it, but what about freedom of expression and no censorship ?
of course they will be right to criticize kerry when he's elected (I hope he is, of course) cause he's a democrat like clinton and he's gonna do fucked up stuff like a good old corporate-ass wiper democrat
maybe fat mike thought the RAB comp was about putting everyone together, like in a mickael moore stuff, to obtain some direct progress, which is bush kicked out, rather than discussing the system, like noam chomsky would do, and point out the shit in the democrat side
in other words the RAB comp is adressing the people who might change their vote show rest of comment 1+ Reply
Someone (September 3, 2004)
http://www.canadiandimension.mb.ca/extra/d1207hc.htm There. This is why Propagandhi don't like Soros. Now stop reading the official soros website because obviously its going to be biased in his favour, i mean, just read the Bush website. It makes HIM out to be a good guy. Now read the link. | Features
Previous
Contests
Exclusive StreamsNewest Reviews
Punknews.org TeamManaging EditorAdam WhiteNews EditorsKira WisniewskiBrittany Strummer Andrew Waterfield Katy Hardy Matthew Baldwin Armando Olivas John Flynn Video EditorChris MoranSocial Media EditorJustin AugustCopy EditorAmelia ClineReviews EditorJoe PeloneInterviews EditorRichard VerducciPublisherAubin PaulISSN 1710-5366© Copyright 1999-2012 Punknews.org Other Places to GoPunknews.org Flickr Pool |






wow.