- Home
- Submit News
- Bands
- Streams
- Best New Music
- Interviews
- Tours
- Reviews
- New Releases
- Contact Us
- Login
Bouncing SoulsBouncing Souls: CometComet (2012)Rise Records Reviewer Rating: 2.5 User Rating: Contributed by: JeloneJelone (others by this writer | submit your own) As a Bouncing Souls superfan, I will go to bat for just about anything the band has released up this point. Those first seven records are essential, life-affirming listening for punk fans. Heck, "Kid" was my high school yearbook quote. But even I can admit that the band has had somewhat of a creativ.
As a Bouncing Souls superfan, I will go to bat for just about anything the band has released up this point. Those first seven records are essential, life-affirming listening for punk fans. Heck, "Kid" was my high school yearbook quote. But even I can admit that the band has had somewhat of a creative backslide as of late. The single series that became Ghost on the Boardwalk yielded some great tunes, and even flashes of the band's old humor, but as an overall record, it came off a little homogenous. Follow-up Comet is a lot of firsts for the band: First for Rise Records, first time recording with Bill Stevenson and, unfortunately, the first disappointing Souls album. Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
Its a really good Souls album, the review is bogus. Baptized, Fast Times, Coin Toss Girl, Comet, and Ship in a Bottle are great Souls songs. well, that was terrible. a few mediocre songs and a bunch of really crappy ones. can i get my money back for something i didnt pay for? maybe it's time for a brief hiatus, followed by some reunion shows for their 25th in a few years. I really liked this record. Its a deconstruction and a throwback to older days, while keeping their new found sensibilities. It's a good solid record, and I think I might be the only person who actually REALLY, REALLY likes "WE LOVE FUN." It's not perfect, it's not new, but I don't want perfect or new. I want the Bouncing Souls and we got them. I'd give it a solid 4! I really really wanted to like it... but Its just ok.. a dissapointment for me. Probably the blandest thing the Bouncing Souls have done. It's about even with Hopeless Romantic for me. It's just... there. Solid album, I think their best since the self-titled record. Nice to hear them expanding into new territory pretty smoothly. This one really grew on me. Even their good albums have a handful of tracks I have to skip over, this only has one. "We Love Fun" is an embarrassment. Don't listen to anyone who thinks "The Pizza Song" is good. Best since anchors. Really like the production on here Best songs the least punk? This review is lame. Comet is the Souls' best since How I Spent My Summer Vacation hands down. This album has some songs I'd like to marry (coin toss girl, fast times), some songs I'd like to bury (we love fun). Some great ones, but I doubt I'd ever let my iTunes play through the album as a whole again. honestly.. I've read your recent reviews and you are an idiot!! Sorry you garage band didn't work out a**h***!! Your "Pennywise" review was terrible and this review is terrible!!! FIRE THIS GUY!!! Good but not great. It wont see as much playing time in my car as The Gold Record did. The first spin I didn't know if I was into it but by the third time the hooks had set in and I really started loving this. Best since anchors I think it would be cool to say I prefer this band's older work and generally I do hate it when bands slow down their songs. But although I've been listening to their releases since their early years, it's only in the last couple years with their last 3 releases that I really started to consider this as one of my favorite bands ever. I really like this album a lot again and maybe there is some poor lyrical content in songs like "We Love Fun" and "DFA", but hey, an old song like "Olé" by them hadn't either. Almost all of the songs on this new album just sound great to my ears once more. I haven't heard this yet, nor do I think I will. Score is for the artwork. This is a solid Bouncing Souls album. If you've ever liked them, I don't see how you couldn't at least like this a little. My only complaint is that it needs to be a little longer! Not HISMSV or Anchors, however very good. Saw their Troc show and they were brilliant. Cheap Girls sucked however -oldpunker- The Bouncing Souls always make me Smile. Someone just learned how to use Illustrator... We Love Fun is probably in their top 5 worst songs of all time. Maybe even the worst. plus i ran into pete on the street and he gave me a low fiive they played 8 new songs at the troc show - but they also played 28 songs in total so that was alright by me TOUR UPDATE: TOUR UPDATE::: it's OK. problem with 10 track albums is even if there's only a couple duds, the album just isn't that great. and this does have a couple duds. It's a bouncing souls album. Its not as great as "how I spent my summer vacation" but I certainly wouldn't call it their worst. Ah what do I know I'm a souls fanboy! I prefer Comet to Ghosts On The Bordwalk. It's much faster and louder. I agree that some of the songs have similar structure, even though they still sound like good Bouncing Souls. The bigest weakness of this album is, that it's too short. Drop "Coin Toss", "We Love Fun", and "DFA", and this is pretty solid. i like it. soooooooooooooooo bad...who knew all the metalcore kids talking shit when rise signed them were right?? Reasons why this is a fucking solid album: horrendous album cover, lame music. All Hail the Souls! This is a standard album for them and it still sounds pretty good. Stoked. Even an okay Souls album is better than most of the other stuff I hear. I like these songs about as much as the ones from "Ghosts on the Boardwalk," and they feel more cohesive as an album than "Ghosts." Get the shit out of your ears/brain. "Ole" wasn't written by a group of men in their forties. Well, i do love fun. Terrible album. We Love Fun? DFA? Give me a fucking break. so angry i bought this album. It's crap rehash of everything they have done before but shit. How many times can we have the same fucking riff/song structure? muted guitar before poppy song? yeah lets do that again! try and recapture former glories by doing the usual slow, anthemic final song? yeah why the fuck not? I know labels don't mean much in this day and age but shit, even these guys are on Rise? I feel older than shit right now. "Ole" wasn't written by a group of men in their forties. we love fun is no dumber than ole and everybody loves that tune. I agree with Bryne. And, like the Souls, I love Fun. Joe makes some good points, but I think this record is a lot of fun. I think I have aged. this thing is a pile of HOT SHIT!!!! maybe its not their best, but its a solid record and is easily better than any of the bands up on 'exclusive streams' right now... Oh DFA is a classic song already Looks like I am the only one who loves this album. "We Love Fun" is nowhere near as bad as anyone is making it out to be. This seems harsh. This is a lot better than Ghosts on the Boardwalk. It's not as good as the Gold Record. As far as new Souls goes I'll take it. this is a good album Maybe the b-sides in the vault for the Comet sessions will hit the web sooner then later and make up for the 10 tracks that even the most honest hardcore BS fans will have the balls to say are going to go down as the worst. Even if Comet may disappoint many of us long time Souls fans,these guys still fucking kick ass live and I will continue to see them live until they no longer got the gasoline in them to do it anymore. I still got faith in these guys and look forward to future albums that will make up for this part of there catalog. Pretty "eh" record. The Bouncing Souls really fell off after Anchors Aweigh. The Gold Record and Ghosts On The Boardwalk have their moments, so does this one, but that doesn't mean they're good albums. Oof dah.... I whole heartrendingly disagree with everything in this review. " It doesn’t contain any embarrassing lows" Shut the fuck up, renaldo. Go give Punk Goes Pop Volume 15 a seven. Anchors Aweigh - brilliant. this record...not as... Yeah "DFA", "We Love Fun" and "Infidel" are some of the bands weakest songs but other than that it's fine and dandy by my standards. |
Previous
Exclusive StreamsSponsored EventsNewest Reviews
Punknews.org TeamManaging EditorAdam WhiteContributing EditorsBryne Yancey Kira Wisniewski Brittany Strummer Andrew Waterfield Armando Olivas John Flynn Chris Moran John GentileCopy EditorAmelia ClinePodcast ProducerNariman ShariatPublisherAubin PaulISSN 1710-5366© Copyright 1999-2013 Punknews.orgTerms of Use Privacy Policy Frequently Asked Questions Contact Us About Punknews.org Other Places to Go |









Better than The Gold Record or Ghosts on the Boardwalk. I think they recaptured some of the energy they lost after Anchors Aweigh.