Punknews.org
Various - Confuse Yr Idols: A Tribute To Sonic Youth (Cover Artwork)

Various

Various: Confuse Yr Idols: A Tribute To Sonic YouthConfuse Yr Idols: A Tribute To Sonic Youth (2004)
Narnack

Reviewer Rating: 3.5
User Rating:


Contributed by: InaGreendaseBrian
(others by this writer | submit your own)

There really can't be that high of a success rate for tribute albums. Either a band will try to cover an artist in their style thus making it sound redundant, or an artist will cover the song in their own style and fall flat on their face. But then, this is Sonic Youth. The difficulty in coverin.


There really can't be that high of a success rate for tribute albums. Either a band will try to cover an artist in their style thus making it sound redundant, or an artist will cover the song in their own style and fall flat on their face. But then, this is Sonic Youth. The difficulty in covering Sonic Youth and making it your own style would leave you with a departure in sound too far to continue calling it tributing. Thankfully, this handful of obscure bands (excuse me if my "Hip Noise-Art Outfits" list doesn't match yours) does it right.

There's a cohesiveness in Confuse Yr Idols most compilations or tributes couldn't touch with a ten-foot pole. Although none of these songs are direct manifestos to the songs covered here, each is so detailed in its own way that it seems more an ambitious reflection than individual cover, while still holding key ground parts to each track manipulated. Sonic Youth seemingly reinvented themselves well, which is why all the little changeups here make the disc so damn interesting.

Although the 12-track compilation acts evenmoreso of an arty reflecting aesthetic of an otherwise already noisy and experimental outfit, that's what makes it work. The practical hip-hop drum 'n bass and quirky chirp of "a funny, sunny street" in KY Prophet's "Making The Nature Scene" definitely differentiates in delivery yet retains the atmospheric consciousness the original once pulled for.

There may or may not be a bit of history surrounding the random yelping of Soundgarden's "Spoonman" chorus right smack in the middle of the bridge of Tub Ring's "Kool Thing;" I don't really know. But the fact of the matter is that it would work wonderfully live, while here it just comes off like a quick timeout for overly silly nostalgia. Even this one glaring fault gives the middle section a bit of character, however.

Also, while dual versions of the same song is never the smartest idea, Saicobab do more than cheap rehashment closing out the comp. The wind chimes and obtusely random blood-curdling scream are just a pair of utterly frantic noises that fill the second version of "Death Valley '69," a proverbial wall of experimental antics that acts as the Hyde to its contemporary Jekyll opener.

For any Sonic Youth fan, this is a must. There's no better compliment to free-form noise experimentalism than an additional layer of free-form noise experimentalism, and that's exactly what Confuse Yr Idols pulls off.

MP3 CLIPS
Parts & Labor - Sugar Kane
Saciobab - Death Valley '69

 

 
People who liked this also liked:
The Ataris - So Long, AstoriaBigwig - Unmerry MelodiesFairweather - LusitaniaBandits of the Acoustic Revolution - A Call to Arms5¢ Deposit - We Have Your Daughter!Scraps and Heart Attacks - Still SickNo Trigger - The World Is Not A StageCapdown - Pound for the SoundVarious - This is Solid State Volume 4No Motiv - Daylight Breaking

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
Anonymous (September 21, 2004)

One of the best tributes I've heard in a loooooong time! It's up there with the Marc Bolan tribute on Tzadik.

Icapped2pac (September 20, 2004)

When I saw "Jekyll", for a second I thought Jackyl was on this. This score is for making your video in front of K-Mart because they won't sell your CD. Imagine how many videos would be made in front of Wal-Mart if everybody did that today.

CallingLondon (September 19, 2004)

wow what a helpful clip of sugarkane. oh wait...

Anonymous (September 19, 2004)

Sonic Youth's twenty minute version of Diamond Sea is my idea of Heaven.

Rob.
http://ys.lossforwords.org

Anonymous (September 19, 2004)

i'm really curious to hear what racebannon did with "death valley 69"

yet no comment from you

Anonymous (September 18, 2004)

I prefered brian's reviews with his Inagreendase name, as to just plain old "Brian".

I trusted "Inagreendase", dunno if I can trust "Brian".

score is for scary sounding staff login names.

Anonymous (September 18, 2004)

For some reason I don't like this band. It must be the fact that they're on a major and I'm afraid to lose my cred.

-Jason Tate

Anonymous (September 18, 2004)

Sonic Youth is mhhmm good.

- I Hate The Kids

Exclusive Streams

Sponsored


Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Other Places to Go