Greg0rb: Best of 2009Best of 2009 (2009)
staff picks

Reviewer Rating: 5

Contributed by: InaGreendaseGreg0rb
(others by this writer | submit your own)

Greg Simpson is a staff reviewer at Punknews.org - ed.

This is Where I Shamelessly Plug My Own Band

Before I tell you about all the other bands I love to hype‚?¶

It seems every year I mention my band/projects in this here intro but never give you any way to actually hear them. I was scared maybe? Well, this year we have something decent for you all to hear. We're called Take Manhattan and we've got our 7-song EP available as a free download at takemanhattan.net. There's a way to get a physical copy too, and you may want that because the booklet is a coloring book of kittens and we shrink-wrap the CD with a four-pack of crayons. That's right.

Plug over = intro over.

My Top 20 Albums of 2009


Bowerbirds: Upper Air

Dead Oceans

While it's pretty much Hymns for a Dark Horse II, I shouldn't whine because their brand of tasty folk comprised of accordion, piano, booming percussion and smooth male/female harmonies is pretty perfect as is.


Woods: Songs of Shame

Shrimper / Woodsist

While Bowerbirds make pretty indie folk, Woods sure don't. It's lo-fi, reckless and sometimes meandering, with not-always-in-tune falsetto vocals and guitar solos that sound like they were cut and pasted into the wrong song. It's unsettling at first, but ultimately awesome.


Ben Kweller: Changing Horses


Even solo artists need some backup, and Kweller sounds so much more alive with a backing band behind him as opposed to the one-man-band that was 2006's Ben Kweller. Kweller's usual batch of pop gems are country-fried with big ups to pedal steel/dobro player Kit Kitterman.


Vivian Girls: Everything Goes Wrong

In the Red

Jangly, noisy, and poppy but not perfect, these ladies encapsulate the principles punk rock was founded upon. While not as chock full of hits as their debut, Everything has enough zazz along with enough growth to please all camps. Except those that go drinkin' at Applebees.


Yeah Yeah Yeahs: It's Blitz!

Interscope/DGC/Dress Up

While ‚??going electronic' is not at all out-there in today's indie world, it just sounds better with Karen O doing her thang over top.


Islands: Vapours


With Nick Thorburn and Jaime Thompson back together again and a whole new crew rounding out the band, we get a much different album than 2008's good-yet-slightly-bloated Arm's Way. A conscious decision by Thorburn to trim things down gives us the most Unicorn-esque album a Unicorn alum has released. Synthy, drum-machiney and catchy, Vapours is a bit one-note but a lot of fun.


Dirty Projectors: Bitte Orca


This record got way too much hype, but after a while I was able to give it a fair shake, and yeah, it's pretty wicked. The musicianship is incredible and tight yet bizarre, and it all works in some weird unique way.


Yo La Tengo: Popular Songs


The veteran trio keeps cranking out great stuff, and with Popular Songs they narrow their scope just a pinch while still hitting their strong points of fuzz-rock, Motown bounce, droning jams and sparkling ballads. Give them some props, people!


Neko Case: Middle Cyclone


Ms. Case and I started off on the wrong foot, for sure. First time I heard her was with New Pornographers, so when I was sent her live album The Tigers Have Spoken, comprised mostly of old country covers, I was completely thrown off and disappointed. Years later I have finally given her another chance and am rewarded with a gorgeous album full of thoughtful arrangements and her incredible voice.


Wilco: Wilco (The Album)


As far as I'm concerned, with this album Wilco has found the perfect balance between catchy country songs and that wonderful guitar racket.


Black Lips: 200 Million Thousand


The Lips return to a more retro production and feel with 200 Million while still stretching with a couple hip hop-inspired tracks. But watch out, they still might show you their junk.


Sonic Youth: The Eternal


While I loved the quote-unquote pop of Rather Ripped it's nice to see SY going berserk with their first indie label release in forever. Adding Mark Ibold (of Pavement fame) on bass lets them add yet another layer of noisy guitar. Booya!


The Mountain Goats: The Life of the World to Come


While I didn't connect with the Biblical references, I still found the album to be captivating (as usual) and incredible (duh). While I prefer when Darnielle rocks out a little more, I won't complain because he'll probably give me another album next year. The Lord provides!


Dinosaur Jr.: Farm


Less in-your-face fast than Beyond but still melt-your-face loud. How lucky am I that one of my favorite bands of all-time is one of the few to ever pull off a successful comeback?


The Raveonettes: In and Out of Control


The Raveonettes snared me once again with their infectious girl-group melodies about rape, suicide and drugs, but this time they don't smother things as much with ultra-fuzz guitars. I don't mind.


Phoenix: Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix

Glassnote / Loyaute

This album is so much more clean-cut and dancey than anything else I'm into right now. But with their infectious melodies and undeniable beats these Frenchmen somehow wormed their way onto my list. Kudos! Wait, that's not French.


The Thermals: Now We Can See

Kill Rock Stars

Catchier than ever and just slightly cleaned up, the Thermals keep climbing higher on my list of favorite current bands. And how did they not get Kathy on the mic sooner?!


The Pains of Being Pure at Heart: The Pains of Being Pure at Heart


They don't reinvent the wheel but I'm a sucker for Big Muff-guitars mixed with sweet vocals. These songs are way too addictive to deny.


Clues: Clues


Finally we hear from the other post-Unicorns camp. Alden Penner doesn't disappoint with this batch of dark, dirty gems, booming and clanging and out-and-out bringing the rock.


Cymbals Eat Guitars: Why There Are Mountains


From the moment I heard "Wind Phoenix (Proper Name)" online for the first time with its bouncy bass line, blast of brass and squiggly guitar lead, I was hooked. Within the span of one song this band can go from Built to Spill laid-back guitar noodling to My Bloody Valentine churning noise to Modest Mouse disco beats and back. Sure, they borrow a lot stylistically, but the songwriting rivals their legendary predecessors. It's rare that a record I love instantly can snare me so deeply and permanently. It feels comfy yet fresh and new. I can't say enough.

Honorable Mentions

The Decemberists: The Hazards of Love; Built to Spill: There Is No Enemy; Sw!ms: Itemlord; Cursive: Mama, I'm Swollen

Top EPs of 2009


The Rentals: The Story of a Thousand Seasons


The Rentals put out three EPs this year (or mini-albums, whatevah) as part of their Songs About Time project, but the first chapter is the only one really worth mentioning. While the other two focus too much on soft and slow stuff, the first chapter rocks the propulsive beats, hooky male/female vocals and melodic synth lines we expect from the resurrected Matt Sharp project. Glad to have a year full of the Rentals, but let's focus strictly on the music for a new full-length next, please.


Bon Iver: Blood Bank


I was late to Bon Iver and got this EP practically at the same time as the debut album. It's more laid-back folk for the first two tracks, but then Justin Vernon stretches his scope with some crunchy piano chords and a track full of vocoder action that somehow fits within his sonic world.


The Pains of Being Pure at Heart: Higher Than the Stars


Instead of sitting around while the accolades for their full-length rolled it, the Pains kept working and expand their sound here with dancier, more keyboard-centric tracks and a couple expected and welcome blasts of distortion.

How the Crap Did I Miss this Last Year?

Good Luck: Into Lake Griffy


I live in Bloomington for Christ's sake. Why isn't my band this good? Oh right, no Matt Tobey.

Vivian Girls: Vivian Girls

In the Red

Already talked about these girls. '09 was the year of the Vivian Girls for me apparently.

Now That's What Greg Calls Music VI

Side A
  1. Dinosaur Jr. - Over It
  2. Clues - Remember Severed Head
  3. Dirty Projectors - Stillness Is the Move
  4. Black Lips - Short Fuse
  5. Cymbals Eat Guitars - Wind Phoenix (Proper Name)
  6. Wilco - One Wing
  7. Woods - The Number
  8. Modest Mouse - King Rat
  9. Sonic Youth - Thunderclap (For Bobby Pyn)
  10. Yo La Tengo - Nothing To Hide
  11. Art Brut - DC Comics and Chocolate Milkshake
  12. Phoenix - Lasso
  13. Sw!ms - Pile of Features
  14. Islands - Vapours
  15. Bon Iver - Woods

Side B
  1. The Mountain Goats - Genesis 3:23
  2. Bowerbirds - Ghost Life
  3. Neko Case - People Got a Lotta Nerve
  4. Ben Kweller - Sawdust Man
  5. Built to Spill - Planting Seeds
  6. Vivian Girls - Can't Get Over Your
  7. The Thermals - When I Died
  8. Wavves - No Hope Kids
  9. The Pains of Being Pure at Heart - This Love Is Fucking Right!
  10. The Rentals - Song of Remembering
  11. Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Dull Life
  12. The Decemberists - The Wanting Comes in Waves/Repaid
  13. The Raveonettes - Boys Who Rape (Should All Be Destroyed)

What Will Make 2010 Wicked Awesome

January looks to be killer with Spoon, Vampire Weekend, Los Campesinos! and Magnetic Fields all putting out albums. Later on we hopefully will get stuff from Arcade Fire, the Hold Steady, the National, Surfer Blood, Frightened Rabbit and maybe a new Strokes? As an annual tradition/joke I will also hope for new My Bloody Valentine and Jesus and Mary Chain albums. Pfff.


People who liked this also liked:
The Ataris - So Long, AstoriaBigwig - Unmerry MelodiesFairweather - LusitaniaBandits of the Acoustic Revolution - A Call to Arms5¬Ę Deposit - We Have Your Daughter!Scraps and Heart Attacks - Still SickNo Trigger - The World Is Not A StageCapdown - Pound for the SoundVarious - This is Solid State Volume 4No Motiv - Daylight Breaking

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
damo (December 28, 2009)

i like none of your list but i'm still going to check them out again just to see if i'm being daft (like i was with polar bear club)

WaitingRoom (December 27, 2009)

Only other list where I've seen Pains of Being Pure at Heart! Awesome.

crashtester (December 26, 2009)

I used to be a big Sonic Youth and Dino Jr fan like 15 years ago and all but that being said this list has really no business being on a punk website, this guy has clearly "moved on" from the genre.

greg0rb (December 26, 2009)

Yeah well it's gonna be probably two years at least before there's even a chance of that happening... you had a busy year- did you even get twenty albums?

jesse (December 26, 2009)

Man, I think I agree with a lot of what you put on that list, but I just missed like, all of these albums this year. It's all stuff that I probably would have really liked. You need to move back to Chicago to keep me up on my game.

greg0rb (December 26, 2009)

MM=Modest Mouse? I put a song on my 'mix,' but it didn't make a list because I didn't want to create a 'best b-sides' list solely for it. I tried to talk Brian into letting me put it on the EP list but he wasn't havin' it.

thegreatestmanalive (December 25, 2009)

I like your list. Thanks for writing about cymbals eat guitars, that islands album cover means i wont listen to it, clues is impossible to find and im shocked i didnt see MM on your list

Infrarecon (December 25, 2009)

That Pains of Being... record is sooo good, EP's great too. Definitely up there with my favorite stuff released this year.

schwenny (December 25, 2009)

That neko case record is pretentious an the lyrics make no sense. I laughed out loud when I read an interview and she talked about how she had written half the record when she realized it was all about tornadoes? Are you kidding me. She must be on some pills.

As for Bon Iver it's the kind of shit that middle class frat boys jam too while they pack bowl after bowl in there five foot bong. Try something edgier like that band Guster. Bon Iver reminds me of Shawn Mullins the fucking one hit wonder who wrote rockabye, so if you like Bon Iver you also like Shawn Mullins rockabye.


ffwoodycooks (December 25, 2009)

your description of the Dirty Projectors album nailed it.

sloanedaley (December 25, 2009)

I enjoyed the Wilco album, I just kind of forgot about it over time I think. I was actually kinda disappointed with the Pains' EP, I didn't enjoy it as much as the full-length and first EP.

Jelone (December 25, 2009)

Totally agree with your BK comments. Kitterman makes Horses taste soooo good.

Exclusive Streams


Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Managing Editor

Adam White

Contributing Editors

Kira Wisniewski Brittany Strummer Armando Olivas John Flynn Chris Moran John Gentile Mark Little

Copy Editor

Adam Eisenberg Britt Reiser

Podcast Producer

Greg Simpson


Aubin Paul

ISSN 1710-5366

© Copyright 1999-2013 Punknews.org

Terms of Use Privacy Policy Contact Us About Punknews.org

Other Places to Go