The Gaslight Anthem / Rival Schools

The Gaslight Anthem / Rival Schools: live in New Yorklive in New York (2010)
live show

Reviewer Rating: 4
User Rating:

Contributed by: lostandclownedlostandclowned
(others by this writer | submit your own)

"What the fuck does ‚??American Slang' mean?" is what I should have been asking myself on the train ride to Penn Station, but instead I fell asleep [Probably the cultural dialect and non-English idioms used by everyday Americans - Educated Guess Editor]. It took me by surprise when I found out that this show sold out in five minutes but it shouldn't have. I was disappointed to know I didn't have a ticket when I heard, but I figured Ticketmaster would put a few more up for sale as it got closer to the date. As it turned out, I was right and I was lucky enough to get one the day before the show. Something I did think about on the train ride was how they seemed to be trying to keep the night reasonably intimate; the last times they played in New York, they played a 3,000-person venue and then a 600-person bowling alley the next night, and the Fillmore holds 1,200. It was also the first genuinely sunny day I had seen in about a week of permanent gray so I thought it funny that it should be that day that I was seeing Gaslight.

I downloaded it when it leaked and got my physical copy of American Slang a few days before the show so I was familiar with and very much liked the new material but I was unsure of what to make of it as an album. I had similar thoughts about The '59 Sound until I heard those songs live, so I was anticipating the same effect that night. When I got there, I stood on line, looked at what the bands had at their merch tables, refused to buy an $8 beer and talked with my friend for a little over an hour; and then Tim Barry walked on stage at 8:00 sharp.

I had seen him play before but I never picked up Manchester or 28th and Stonewall so I wasn't expecting to know much of his set, but it didn't matter. Early on in the set, he dedicated "Moving on Blue" to anyone who was having relationship problems and then moved onto "Idle Idylist" and "Church of the Level Track," which I recognized immediately. He prefaced the former by saying that he hadn't worked since January and that he loves that he keeps traveling and that got some cheers. "Prosser's Gabriel," the centerpiece of his set, if only because of the fairly extensive story behind it, went over the best. Tim said that on the 210th anniversary of Prosser's lynching, he was going to play an illegal show on the Virginia Commonwealth College parking lot that now covers the slave graveyard he was buried in and that he fully expects to go to jail for it. The crowd cheered that too and he rounded out the set with "Dog Bumped," and at 8:30, I bought those two albums that I didn't have.

No sooner did my friend and I come back to the floor than did Rival Schools start playing. They were a band I knew next to nothing about, although I overheard someone next to me say that they just recently got back together. It sounded to me like were big fans of the Promise Ring, the Get Up Kids and Radiohead, so how they got tagged as a post-hardcore band is beyond me [Because their singer/guitarist, the illustrious Walter Schreifels, formed this band some time after he played in a hardcore band. Hence, "post-hardcore." - Obvious Answer Editor]. But in any case, I thought they were boring and it didn't look like the rest of the crowd was too enthused either. The highlight of their set was when the singer asked if anyone had World Cup fever, and then if anyone could name one person on the U.S. team. They played for about 40 minutes and left the stage when the room was full.

So we all waited and at 9:45, Gaslight opened up with their set with "American Slang" and "Old White Lincoln." Brian said they were excited to be playing because it was the first time most of the new songs were being played in a live setting. They then continued to play American Slang in its near-entirety with few stops and amidst the shouts from the crowd for them to play earlier songs, "Orphans" was introduced as a song about where the band was from and where they were going, and Side 2 of the album didn't let up, short one song.

"We Came to Dance" ushered in the end of the set and was followed by the always energetic "Great Expectations," though Alex Rosamilia botched the intro before telling the crowd he was sorry and re-starting it. "Blue Jeans and White T-Shirts" was played in typical fashion and ended the first set leaving the crowd waiting for the encore.

The only complaint I have about the band's live shows--besides (and I guess this is maybe a hometown crowd thing) the shouting at Brian during breaks between songs so you can barely hear him talk--is the fairly complacent set list. Granted, I've seen them a few times and they're a young band but I've yet to hear "Red in the Morning" or "Red at Night" played, and it feels like it's been ages since I heard "I Coulda Been a Contender," but Sink or Swim got its due in the encore. After "The Navesink Banks," they tore through definite fan-pleasers "Drive" and "Wooderson" and then some more '59 Sound material. After "Here's Looking at You, Kid," I was sure "The Backseat" would close the show, but instead we got what looked like a spontaneous version of "Se√Īor and the Queen," which was especially fun to hear. Then "The Backseat" was played.

The crowd loved the American Slang songs and they sounded great live as well. I could tell that they were songs the band was already confident with and that was cool to see too. Surprisingly, no covers were played and there was little banter from Brian, but I guess that was to see how the new material went over. I still haven't thought about what "American Slang" means, but sooner or later it'll come to me. The next time they come around here, they're playing Radio City Music Hall so it will be exciting to see if they sell out that place too. I hope they can. This show proved to me at least that they're a band that deserves to.

Set list:

  1. American Slang
  2. Old White Lincoln
  3. Stay Lucky
  4. Bring It On
  5. The Diamond Church Street Choir
  6. The Queen of Lower Chelsea
  7. The '59 Sound
  8. Orphans
  9. Boxer
  10. Old Haunts
  11. The Spirit of Jazz
  12. We Came to Dance
  13. Great Expectations
  14. Blue Jeans and White T-Shirts
  15. The Navesink Banks
  16. Drive
  17. Wooderson
  18. Even Cowgirls Get the Blues
  19. Miles Davis and the Cool
  20. Here's Looking at You, Kid
  21. Se√Īor and the Queen
  22. The Backseat


People who liked this also liked:
Up for Nothing - Twelve Stories DownBorn to Lose - The Dreams of KidsThe Gaslight Anthem - American SlangRazorblade Handgrenade - And I Try to Stay Positive...The Scandals - To the YouthBanner Pilot - CollapserAlkaline Trio - GoddamnitThe National - High VioletThe Menzingers - Chamberlain WaitsDillinger Escape Plan - Option Paralysis

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
inagreendase (June 24, 2010)

Why don‚??t I just say Foo Fighters are a post-grunge band

Exactly? You wouldn't be the first...

Blackjaw_ (June 24, 2010)

When a review's too long, you don't leave out important details, you go back and get rid of useless parts. Like the entire first and (most of the) second paragraphs.

mikexdude (June 24, 2010)

People were definitely too harsh on you, but he also did Guest vocals on No Division and so did Tim Barry : ) I don't think Rival Schools is generic.

lostandclowned (June 24, 2010)

I didn‚??t think they were that great. I didn‚??t go to see Rival Schools, I went for Tim Barry and Gaslight. The review was already long and I didn‚??t remember a lot about them; I thought they were really generic but that his banter was funny. The guy‚??s other work shouldn‚??t matter in my opinion of RS. What does it matter that I didn‚??t know he produced No Division. It was stupid to gloss over them but it‚??s stupid to be harsh about it.

I think ‚??American Slang‚?Ě has a deeper meaning than a dialect and that post-hardcore is a stupid concept. Why don‚??t I just say Foo Fighters are a post-grunge band.

‚??Manchester‚?Ě and ‚??28th‚?Ě are pretty good. I‚??m glad I finally heard them.

Blackjaw_ (June 24, 2010)

faithisforfools (1 day ago)

Dude doesn't know Rival Schools... so fucking what.
They put out one album (so far) which was decent. I'm sorry, Walter's awesome and has a lovely resume, but you can't take Rival Schools and put them on a fucking pedestal for one fucking album. Wait until that 2nd one comes out... then we'll see.

you know about their two unreleased (but easily obtainable digitally) albums, right? and then "Rival Schools United By Onelinedrawing"?

givemeamuseumandillfillit (June 23, 2010)

What a fucking clown.
That Rival Schools paragraph is one of the worst things I've ever read.

Seriously, sit down in the corner and think about your life for a while. Even then, Rival Schools last record was released in 2001.

faithisforfools (June 23, 2010)

Dude doesn't know Rival Schools... so fucking what.
They put out one album (so far) which was decent. I'm sorry, Walter's awesome and has a lovely resume, but you can't take Rival Schools and put them on a fucking pedestal for one fucking album. Wait until that 2nd one comes out... then we'll see.
And as for the reviewer, the guy's got enough good stuff in his profile (Avail, D4, Fugazi, DK, Descendents) to allow a "pass". Not like he's sayin' "oh, they were decent, but nowhere near as sexy as New Found Glory or Say Anything!".

Let. Him. Pass!

Misanthropee (June 22, 2010)

Shameless fanboys both above and below me.

Rival Schools >>>>>>>> Gaslight

maverick (June 22, 2010)

"I Coulda Been A Contender" is my favorite Gaslight song, but I haven't seen them play it since SXSW 2008, unfortunately. I asked Brian why once and he said he didn't like re-living what the lyrics were about when they performed it. Bummer.


conduit (June 22, 2010)

No sooner did my friend and I come back to the floor than did Rival Schools start playing. They were a band I knew next to nothing about, although I overheard someone next to me say that they just recently got back together."

I wish I had stopped reading there but I noticed you also said they were boring. fuck this review.

the_other_scott (June 22, 2010)

I left this show with such mixed emotions. They sounded awesome. The crowd was really into it, but it was so strange seeing them in that capacity. I've been going through this for 15 years with bands that start out small and get huge, and it's strange every time - but this was just different.

It was like I was happy for them but I felt like they had moved on without me.

TeaEssAre (June 22, 2010)

I feel bad now... Never review until you learn who Rival Schools and Walter Schreifels are...

TeaEssAre (June 22, 2010)

This is painful to read. Horribly written, and amazingly uninformed. How does this dude not know about Walter Schreifels? I think it's safe to say a lot of music the reviewer listens to would not be the same had it not been for his influence. Do yourself a favor and never review again...

mikexdude (June 22, 2010)

Yeah, pretty bummed that you didn't like Rival Schools live enough to talk more about them...

mattramone (June 22, 2010)

Needz moar ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------

thehandswillabide (June 22, 2010)

Why even post Rival Schools if this reviewer is just a Gaslight fanboy and spent more time talking about their stage banter rather than a single bit of their songs.


Cos (June 22, 2010)

Rival Schools reunited (by fate) sometime in 2008. They were promising a new album around that time but in typical Walter fashion, he keeps procrastinating and hasn't put it out yet. Their a fun band but probably won't win over any new fans with their live show.

carlo_cabinetti (June 22, 2010)

------- --------- -------

lostandclowned (June 22, 2010)

In b4 the other one was better.

Exclusive Streams


Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Managing Editor

Adam White

Contributing Editors

Kira Wisniewski Brittany Strummer Armando Olivas John Flynn Chris Moran John Gentile Mark Little

Copy Editor

Adam Eisenberg Britt Reiser

Podcast Producer

Greg Simpson


Aubin Paul

ISSN 1710-5366

© Copyright 1999-2013 Punknews.org

Terms of Use Privacy Policy Contact Us About Punknews.org

Other Places to Go