H2O - All We Want (Cover Artwork)


H2O: All We WantAll We Want (2002)
Universal Music Group

Reviewer Rating: 1.5
User Rating:

Contributed by: maverickScott
(others by this writer | submit your own)

H2O used to rule. I remember when I got "Thicker Than Water" from Epitaph when it first came out, and I was blown away. I played that album nonstop, dubbed it for my car tape deck, saw the band live on the Warped Tour, bought their back catalog, and all was well. Then "F.T.T.W." came out, and I w.
iTunes StoreAmazon

H2O used to rule. I remember when I got "Thicker Than Water" from Epitaph when it first came out, and I was blown away. I played that album nonstop, dubbed it for my car tape deck, saw the band live on the Warped Tour, bought their back catalog, and all was well. Then "F.T.T.W." came out, and I wasn't as much of a fan. The hardcore seemed to be on a downturn, although the album still packed one hell of a punch.

Then "Go!" came out.

"Go!" was horrible. The music went completely bland and generic, the label tried to push the hidden cover song as the single, and Toby's voice went straight to shit on the recording. I saw the band live last summer on the Warped Tour again and they still had it - even the new material sounded decent. I just chalked it up to too many A&R Reps standing over the boards telling the engineers what to do.

Now, we have the brand new "All We Want" EP.

And it's terrible.

This band has absolutely no passion or energy anymore, at least on recording. "All We Want" is an absolutely horrible mid-tempo number that reminds me too much of Pennywise's "The World" for comfort. "Static" is the best song out of the new three, sounding the most like the band's older, faster material [the production still sucks on it, though, and sucks any life that might have been there right out of the track]. The third song, "Wrong," is just as slow and boring as "All We Want." There's nothing special about the songs at all.

The band does include two live tracks on here - "Role Model" and "Memory Lane." They were the two best songs off "Go!", and they sound infinitely better live, mainly because Toby actually sounds normal in these live recordings, opposed to the "nuts-in-the-vice" voice present on "Go!". But even these recordings sound incredibly low-budget - I have bootlegs of bands that sound cleaner than this.

To add insult to injury, MCA bleeped out the swear words on the live tracks! I'm not some huge advocate for swearing or something, but c'mon, H2O - stand up for yourselves against MCA before the label completely ruins you!

Oh yeah, the video for "Role Model" is also included on the disc, and it's actually a pretty good video [I wouldn't have known, since I don't think it ever got played ever]. So all in all, you have three brand new, absolutely horrid songs [I'd say they're the worst of the band's career], two decent live tracks, and one overlooked video. Is this worth it? Not unless you really, really are a fan.

A really, really big fan.

Don't forget your roots, H2O.


People who liked this also liked:
H2O - Nothing to ProveH2O - GO

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
Anonymous (December 26, 2002)

to the poster below me:

If getting poppier is growing up I wish they'd grow down and give us more NYHC. Just my personal opinion.

Anonymous (December 25, 2002)

What the fuck is wrong with all of you???? Just because H2O is on MCA doesn't mean they sold out. If they are sellouts for that, that means that the Sex Pistols were sellouts in '77, The Clash were sellouts and the Ramones were sellouts because they were on Sire recods which is Warner Bros. So fuck that shit.

So what their sound has changed, they are growing up as a band. I've been into H2O since Thicker Than Water came out and everything they've done has improved. The self titled record is still my favorite but F.T.T.W. Go and All We Want are all great. If you don't want to grow up that's fine but let them.

Don't Forget Your Roots.

Anonymous (November 22, 2002)

shit man... imagine if toby h2o sees these comments, along with other comments on other msg boards on the internet about how crappy they are now. i'm sure that guy's gonna cry a fucking river.

it'd be better if toby says sorry to the fans (even tho he don't owe shit, but it's out of respect anyways), get his major label album agreements done, go back underground, and start touring with acts like, say, hatebreed or between the buried and me, or at least shit that sounds like thrice for god fucking sake!

- n'deso

Anonymous (November 22, 2002)

what the feck?!?! h2o? more like h2crapass... i saw these guys about twenty times before fttw came out and was never disappointed once. and they were good guys. i got to meet them on st. marks one day as they were out handing out their own flyers. how d.i.y. is that?!?! sure they were always a better live band then in the studio but that's not to say thier first two albums weren't good either. but go??? i mean i could care less if it was on a major label, it just plain sucked. they should go back to playing "my love is real", now that was some sick shit.

Anonymous (November 20, 2002)

Can these guys actually say their making more money now that their on mca?
Do H20 ever headline their own tours anymore? My god, these guys had it made. Epitaph, MR.Brett perfecting the H20 sound with the production on fttw. I couldnt believe an article I read in a mag the things these idiots said. "we had some really great melodies going into the studio for fttw. Brett kept telling us to yell more. It was like we were his nyhc pet band." Oh my god, I couldnt believe what i had just read. Thank god for Brett for giving us the last taste of once a truley great band. Iam so glad that when I look at my cd tower all i see is the S/T record and fttw.

Anonymous (November 20, 2002)

Comparing any of these songs to "The World" is pathetic, "The World" is a good song, these suck.

Obscene_Jesture (November 20, 2002)


And H20 licks bag.


Obscene_Jesture (November 20, 2002)

Speaking of $6.99---

I just took a big shit today that had undigested corn nuts (ranch?) embedded within the feces.

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

I paid $6.99 for it, and regret it. The album doesn't fire me up like their older stuff.

And, as some of you have said, the censoring on the album is NUTS!

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

I have lost ALL of my faith in H2O. Don't get me wrong, Toby is one hell of a guy, as is Todd, Todd, Rusty and Adam. But last night I went and saw them live, for my fifth and last time. I payed 25 bucks just to see them and boy did it suck. I mean there live sound has changed ALOT. It went from fast and aggressive to happy and poppy. I guess you could liken it to an aggressive New Found Glory or something. Anyways it's too bad. Ohhh and in the song "Well behaved" instead of singin "I miss death and glory" they said "I missed new found glory" and all of the girls up front screamed there head off. I left in the middle of the set. Mark my word, The Boxcar racer/H2O tour is the WORST tour of the year. EASILY!!

Anonymous (November 19, 2002)

I actually like Go! It's definately more radio friendly than their earlier stuff but it's alright. F.T.T.W. is my fav cd by them though. It just sucks that h2o did exactly what they preached against. They sold out.

Anonymous (November 18, 2002)

h2o's first self-titled album on Blackout! Records was the best most ground breakin CD i had ever heard when i was 16. I listened to it everyday for over a year. Its still in my top 10 of all time list.
And when my band was just starting out, i met H20 a bunch of times and they sold my bands demo at their table and wore our Tshirts on stage for years. Ill never forget that and they will always be awsome to me for that.
As for all there other albums....no comment. But Great Guys. There demo 7" before the CD was out was fuckin awsome too. If the Mask Fits (the real version) is still my favorite H2O song.
If you like the first H2O CD, youll love the new 12cent CD. Its really in the spirit of that first album. fast, catchy, Hard and honest. With a sense of humor too. Check out the sounds at www.12cent.com.
The New CD "Bastard Music" comes out in a week,anyone who lieks the first H2O CD will definitly be into it.

Anonymous (November 18, 2002)

if i choose between this crap and a sum 41 piece of crap cd, i'd choose the sum 41 piece of crap.

TheBouncingSoul (November 18, 2002)

is there a worse song than "I want I want"?

because, if there is, then i haven't come across it

lolaq (November 18, 2002)

personally, "f.t.t.w" was my favorite h2o album. contrary to the review, i think it has a whole lot of energy. however, "go!" sucks ass, with the exception of, perhaps, one or two songs. i have not heard the new e.p., but now i really have no urge to get it.

h2o still rocks live, though. maybe they should just make a live album and let that be the end of it.

Anonymous (November 17, 2002)

god, you people are pathetic ... let them sell out in peace for fuck's sake. they made some great albums ... let it go ... it's over ... like hardcore

Anonymous (November 17, 2002)

scott, NaCl sucks. i think NaOH would be so much more kick ass.

Anonymous (November 17, 2002)

this record fucking sucks

Tahoejeff (November 17, 2002)

I think we should just call ourselves salt

maverick (November 17, 2002)

I just got the idea to form an H2O cover band and call it NaCl.

Who's in with me?


Anonymous (November 17, 2002)

bono ....now i dont like bono, but i don't see why your sorry asses have to say a rockstar should go help out people in another country .....why is that a rock star's responsibility???
why don't you make it a goal to go to africa yourselves and help out!

Anonymous (November 16, 2002)

Im pretty sure they're dead.

Anonymous (November 16, 2002)

no, couldn't sorry.

TheBouncingSoul (November 16, 2002)

i think i'd be done.....i mean, if they move to another label, and they make better songs, they'd be fun to listen to sure, but this shit would be in the back of my head, it could never be the same

Anonymous (November 16, 2002)

question to you all. we all know h2o is going down the toilet and is already on its way to the sewage plant. but let's say, they get off the major label, and come back with another fttw. would you guys come back to h2o as well? or are you already done with h2o and wouldn't give a shit what they put out. it seems to me, reading these comments, a lot of you still have a glimmer of hope for h2o.

Anonymous (November 16, 2002)

Deplorable. Absolutely without redeeming value. *sighs* the live songs don't sound like what I seen (and heard) of them. The new songs are trash, and they've eiether forgotten their roots or an exec took the real songs and had Jive produce them.

Anonymous (November 16, 2002)

I just saw this for a buck and I passed it up.

- Scott
(Lawrence Arms woop!)

abileneINlove (November 16, 2002)

Perhaps an overlooked quippism from a few posts below, Bono wears clothes costing a lot more than $300.

Hardcore a la this has never been interesting. It is not even fun. All this gibber-jabber of roots, infant flesh, stabbed backs and selling out...

Not fun.

Anonymous (November 16, 2002)

i just got back from the boxcar racer/h2o/used show. my god it was pathetic. i mean, h2o is still a great live act, no doubt about it. but i'll sum up the night when toby asked the 13 year old blink-boxcar loving pre-pubescent crowd if anyone had their album fttw . . . i think i was one of the dozen or so people who raised their hands out of the crowd of 1000. toby kept having to rile up the crowd. sadly, it has come down to toby needing to constantly during their set clapping his hands vigorously to wake the crowd up. h2o needs to wake the fuck up, get off this fucking major label, and save some face as if they haven't lost a lot already. i really don't have a problem with the bands they tour with. i have more of a problem with their sound which sounds like nfg right now.

evilash (November 16, 2002)

everyone who is making U2 comments is gay because these posts are about H2O not old men

Anonymous (November 16, 2002)

Let's hope, that the new cd will be better!

Anonymous (November 16, 2002)

If Bono actually DID do something I'd like him, but he doesn't, he's a fake......like George Bush, they are both fakes.

WussEmoRock (November 16, 2002)

Haven't heard this release, but I doubt I will like it if it is anything similar to GO!. I will tell you how the songs sound live though, I am seeing them in about a week with TBS.


Anonymous (November 16, 2002)

I'm really suprised at how strongly most of you guys feel about H20 changing their style.. I guess ska kids feel that way every day!

Anonymous (November 16, 2002)

This EP should come with one of those labels you find on food products stating that if it's not guarantee to rock one of your socks off, to return it for a refund. Excuse me, but I'm going to listen to F.T.T.W. and remember the good times.


Anonymous (November 16, 2002)

Ugh, that's all I can say.

- Scott
(We deserve an apology)

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

Warzone in nyhc - not H2O.

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

hehe, little know it alls talking shit about bono, who goes global, bringing awareness to issues such as 3rd world debt. fuck you little assholes. what exactly have you done lately for 3rd world countires in debt? nothing right? thought so.

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

Bono is doing a lot more than you'd expect. He is more than talk. He acts on what he believes on. He's not superman, but he does what he can and he does it with heart. More than the average reader or person would do if they could, most likely.
If you want an example that may touch home, Bono payed for most (if not all) of Joey Ramone's hospital bills.

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

I agree, U2 are a bunch of fakes, hell, Bono is probably a fucking government agent. If you really wanna help people, help them grow food or build them some homes, which they really need, rather then "saying" you care. Actions speak louder than words Mr. Bono. Anyhoo, this was for the guy below. I'm Out!!!!

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

U2 sucks. If only Bono were serious about helping people, rather than a fake, who goes to Africa in his $300 clothes and poses with the locals pretending he cares, if he cared he'd live with them for a few months without his "crew" and I bet he'd change a lot, that would help a lot more than "posing". He'd probably die. Anyway, this was for the guy who said that U2 was so great. Also, H2O has gone downhill for a long time. The last thing they did that I liked was their cover of "Nazi Punks Fuck Off!", and that was way back in 1998, so they have basically become a much more talenmted version of New Found Glory, which still sucks.

evilash (November 15, 2002)

Toby can eat my ass. Lou for SOIA would fuck him up in a fight

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

toby said all that bullshit about not selling out back in the day and he preached straight edge i gave that up the day they signed to Mca

jake blues

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

have not heard the cd but how is your band doing?

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

I saw them and they covered "Sunday Bloody Sunday" by U2.....there are some things you just aren't supposed to do. Thats like a rookie wearing #99 in the NHL or someone on the Chicago Bulls trying to wear #23. I left the show.

waste_elite (November 15, 2002)

what a shame, H2O used to be such a good band.

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

I bought the EP at a show. It's censored. h2o is seriously one of the biggest examples of selling out.

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

this cd fucking sucks donkey dick

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

fuck all u calling h2o sellouts

Dubar (November 15, 2002)

H2O.... argh, I cant hate them. They were good.. amazing even. H2O was always one of those bands you'd expect to hear in a "best show ever" conversation, the type of band whose logo people would get tattoos of. NYHC means something, and they embodied it.

But... they abandoned all of that. They went and turned into fucking pussies getting assraped by the system and the only thing I can feel is sad. The only chance you get to see them live is with shitty drive thru bands, and maybe they still have some of the power that they used to, but their crowd is filled with 14 year old girls, and even if I start dancing, or if there are a few people there to have some fun, its NEVER going to be the same. H2O is dead. Its worse than breaking up because they cant just get back together and make it all better. If they're gonna regain the admiration and respect they once had, they're gonna need to start from square one and rebuild the trust of their fans.

zeiter (November 15, 2002)

Yeah, its sad how H2O has gone downhill. I never really heard much of them before warped 01, but I liked what I heard. I saw them live and thought they kicked ass, so I went and bought Go... I was never so disapointed in an album ever, and this EP doesn't sound alot better.

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

Dms suckaaaaaazzzzzz

TheOneTrueBill (November 15, 2002)

mine was edited too by the way... forgot to put that in the last one

TheOneTrueBill (November 15, 2002)

i've lost 95% of the faith i once had in this band... it really pains me to see a band that you hae such a sentimental attachment to get so shitty

TheBouncingSoul (November 15, 2002)

i'd still like to know if they edited all the copies, or just the press ones.....because wow, if they did....

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

to the person below:::
was that the tour when your mom drove the bus?

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

h2o toured with blink-182 in '97 too.

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

I'm a huge PW fan and "All We Want," aside from the first 5 seconds possibly being the same chord, sounds nothing like "The World."

This is why some people get paid to have reviews published and thankfully... YOU DON'T.

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

***sings it like the first couple of lines of "5 Year Plan"***
-My band sucks now worse than New Found GLory!
We've lost all of our sincerity!
My band sucks now worse than New Found Glory!
Can't wait to be all over MTV-

Sing it Toby!

FeedMyNightmare (November 15, 2002)

I miss my h20. Still a great live show, some people complain about the "new" fans bit I enjoy a little floorpunching in front of these kids, and having them run out of the pit in fear. Mabey someday Toby will remove his head from his ass and bring true nyhc back ..eh Liberate?

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

i was a fan since '97 and every album went a little downhill. after GO came out, i vowed to never buy anything from h2o again(i didnt buy go, i just borrowed it and thought it sucked)
oh yeah, i think they started getting poppy/mainstream about the time when FTTW came out and breakers started showing up at the shows.

-----your mama

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

ya, my review this read pretty much that same. I didnt mention it but Im totally with you on the first song sounding like Pennywise. Im so glad I didnt buy this cause I will NEVER take it out of its case again. And mine came edited too, so either its just the press copies or they are all like it.

When reviewing this album its hard to like convey how much it sucks, because its beyond words. Its just the worst, dont even try it, cause you won't like it.

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

"To add insult to injury, MCA bleeped out the swear words on the live tracks! I'm not some huge advocate for swearing or something, but c'mon, H2O - stand up for yourselves against MCA before the label completely ruins you!"

are you sure it wasn't just an edited copy you got?

evilash (November 15, 2002)

Alright, I dont know too much about H20 but I happened to hear this CD and it was really bad. I don't undrstand why they where ever considered a NYC Hardcore band in the first place. I'm a huge Sick of it All fan and I will admit that their latest stuff is not up to par, but at least it has a little more sincerity going for it.

I have heard F.T.T.W and thicker than water also and I must say I wasn't totally impressed, but this album is shit. The song role model is bad and so is that fact that appears on the disc twice (i dont care if its a video). I'm not sure what is being accomplished here. Maybe H20 os trying to end their MCA contract by putting out shitty records.

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

i do agree with just about everyone says, i mean i dont think go is terrible or all we waant is terrible its just that when you compare to the kick ass older stuff, it really doestn hold. i mean i saw them at the box car show and and the newer stuff if better live, and hearing guilty by association with freddie madball coming out and singing his part was just awesome. but in the end i will not give up on h2o, ill stick with them to the end, i look at this like a marriage, its for better or worst, and right now were going through a rough patch, so just gotta stick out for a while, and hopefully everything will work out. so yeah anyway i still think h2o is the shit

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

When will H2O wise up. The new cds are to poppy for old fans, while the live show is still to heavy to win over the NFG, Boxcar Racer fans that are seeing them live. What I'm hoping is that MCA will drop them & H2O, realizing the error of their ways, would go back & put out a cd with some balls ala s/t, Thicker Than Water.

TheBouncingSoul (November 15, 2002)

i haven't heard it, but after hearing go, i'll just assume it sucks.....what the hell h2o?

adam (November 15, 2002)

H2O... sigh... for some stupid reason I still have faith that they'll turn around and remember who they were.

Remember when they toured with bands like Sick Of It All, Madball, Agnostic Front and Rancid? Remember how Toby was such a Sick Of It All fan that he actually roadied for them for years?

Now who do they tour with? Boxcar Racer, Sum 41, New Found Glory? I hope thats working out for them.

H2O is undeniably good live and have shown they can do so much better than GO and this new EP... I know Toby took some vocal lessions but that dosent excuse the over-produced sound you get here.

Oh well... one day...


Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

I saw these guys at warped 01.....and they seemed like a great band painfully trying to brcome a terrible "new found glory"ish band, what a shame.

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

vice-in-the-nuts or nuts-in-the-vice?

Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

FTTW was so good, even the poppy stuff was great, but Go was horrible. They had such a huge fanbase after FTTW that just ignored go, myself included.


Anonymous (November 15, 2002)

sadly, the last time these guys came here (pitssburgh) there was like no one there.does anyone respectthese guys anymore? i mean they rule live, but if i was ever lame enough to call a band sellouts, it think h20 would be that band.ehhh.

punky (November 15, 2002)

"Bleeped out the swear words on the live tracks??? Damn!! That sounds so lame...
Great live band, but if there is a band that truly needs to be labeled as 'sellouts' its H2O...

Exclusive Streams


Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Managing Editor

Adam White

Contributing Editors

Kira Wisniewski Brittany Strummer Armando Olivas John Flynn Chris Moran John Gentile Mark Little

Copy Editor

Adam Eisenberg Britt Reiser

Podcast Producer

Greg Simpson


Aubin Paul

ISSN 1710-5366

© Copyright 1999-2013 Punknews.org

Terms of Use Privacy Policy Contact Us About Punknews.org

Other Places to Go