Punknews.org LogoPunknews.org

Sign In | create an account

 
Staff IconSeventeen Evergreen - Life Embarrasses Me On Planet Earth (Cover Artwork)

Seventeen Evergreen

Life Embarrasses Me On Planet Earth (2005)
Pacific Radio Fire

Reviewer Rating:


Contributed by: Anchors
(
others by this writer | submit your own
)


Published on August 23rd 2005


Call me crazy, but I’ve never really thought that camping, or the whole notion of sleeping out in the woods and “roughing it” is any sort of a good time. I enjoy tons of outside activities, any sport you can think of, swimming, jet skiing, you name it and I’ve probably done it, but going into the middle of nowhere, getting bitten to all hell by bugs, and sleeping on the ground has just never struck me as enjoyable. The woods are the exact vision that I get upon listening to Seventeen Evergreen’s music. I see two stoners giddily playing the guitar and drums, respectively, in some clearing deep in the woods. Nine out of 10 hippies would absolutely love this album, and the other hippie is too strung out on PCP to actually vote, but he’d have probably enjoyed it too.

A good amount of this disc is free-form and instrumental with no real direction to speak of, and while I can generally get into that type of thing, this just doesn’t grab me. There’s no elements of this that stick out; it seems to drone on in one long, continuous stoner session. Some songs try their best to defy this convention, as “Grays” plods through most of the length with some melodic chord plucking and repetitious use of the snare drum, but it ultimately can’t get over the hump as the guitar slowly intensifies, as the song is all crackle and no pop. The majority of these songs just don’t settle into an identifiable groove, and I’m not letting them off the hook on the premise that it’s only a two-man outfit, as there’s lots of things that can be explored with only a guitar and drums, none of which are really expanded upon with this record. But if reverb, low vocals, and open-ended song structures are your thing, you may have just found a new favorite band.

For the rest of us, that open-ended song structure needs some sort of push to it, something to make what seems like improvisational wankery into actual music. Seventeen Evergreen, however, seem to dabble far too much in the wankery end of things. “Luzerac” is the one song on this record that most closely resembles some sort of song structure, as there’s a good deal of vocals and some low droning guitar, but that doesn’t mean it’s able to hold your attention. The ambient sounds of “Grays” are really the album's best moments, as the snoozefest “Haven’t Been Yourself” takes away any remnants of continuity that the album was still holding on to. Singer Nephi Evans just can’t seem to find the right ratio of vocals to music to actually keep things interesting. Every so often you’ll stumble onto a hot pocket of energy of creativeness, until the droning just wipes it out.

My issue with this album is much like my overall view on camping, in that what seems like enough to keep you occupied will in turn leave you bored very, very quickly, but probably with less bug bites than an overnight stay in the woods.

I’m all for music being inventive, and fighting against being derivative and formulaic, but somewhere along the line it also has to be interesting, and that’s the boat that Seventeen Evergreen let leave the harbor. One quick listen through this album and you’ve heard all that you’re going to; there’s no melodies, chords, or lyrics that won’t go in one ear and right out the other, and that’s what’s frustrating about this. Life Embarrasses Me On Planet Earth can toil in greatness, but will ultimately stay a subpar effort.




Please login or register to post comments.
What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
    Anonymous (February 6, 2006)

    i actually like this album... its something i can definitly mellow out to

    Anonymous (August 24, 2005)

    i used to not mind so much, but now it's just too much. i hate anchors reviews. every review starts out like some crappy high school essay. i'm not reading the review to hear about your outdoor hobbies, i want to know what the fuck the band sounds like and i don't want to trudge through a bunch of shit to get there.

    Anonymous (August 24, 2005)

    So everyone hates this review...Can someone tell me what this band actually sounds like?

    Anonymous (August 24, 2005)

    "one quick listen..." is right, as the reviewer stated. i suggest you try listening again. Anchors has absolutely no context to place this music. that was a poorly written dismissal of a good record by a group that is 5 people and not a duo. 2 song writers, yes. i see Anchors didn't bother to read the liner notes either. and what's this "no melodies, free form, and instrumental album?" listen again and please don't waste our time with these type of reviews. maybe the other anonymous has a point with his Good Charlotte slag.

    Anonymous (August 24, 2005)

    "You know what I hate? Fucking Phish. I hate, hate, hate Phish."

    -Don't you mean Phucking Phish? Tee hee, hee hee hee heeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.

    stevejonestherealbones (August 23, 2005)

    "Anchors, you really have no concept of music outside of Good Charlotte, do you? This isn't a hippy band."

    now that we get 30 reviews a week, we see 15 reviews from anchors...and only 6 of his reviews a week are good charlotte records, so i'm pretty sure he knows of other bands

    - jones the bones

    - stevejones8770@yahoo.com

    Anchors (August 23, 2005)

    Bands besides Good Charlotte exist?

    Anonymous (August 23, 2005)

    Anchors, you really have no concept of music outside of Good Charlotte, do you? This isn't a hippy band.

    Anonymous (August 23, 2005)

    fuck. stupid opening. i don't care what you like and what you don't. dick.

    yayforapathy (August 23, 2005)

    Anchors, i believe that you are not man, but in fact a machine.

    Anonymous (August 23, 2005)

    i agree...way to NOT sound so smart..respectively

    Anonymous (August 23, 2005)

    that "respectively" in the first paragraph was unneccessary

    Anonymous (August 23, 2005)

    You know what I hate? Fucking Phish. I hate, hate, hate Phish.

    Features

    Exclusive Streams

    Newest Reviews

    Punknews.org Team

    Managing Editor

    Adam White

    News Editors

    Kira Wisniewski
    Brittany Strummer
    Andrew Waterfield
    Katy Hardy
    Matthew Baldwin
    Armando Olivas
    John Flynn

    Video Editor

    Chris Moran

    Social Media Editor

    Justin August

    Copy Editor

    Amelia Cline

    Reviews Editor

    Joe Pelone

    Interviews Editor

    Richard Verducci

    Publisher

    Aubin Paul

    ISSN 1710-5366



    © Copyright 1999-2012 Punknews.org



    Other Places to Go

    Punknews.org Flickr Pool