Punknews.org
The Clash - Live at Shea Stadium (Cover Artwork)

The Clash

The Clash: Live at Shea StadiumLive at Shea Stadium (2008)
The Clash

Reviewer Rating: 3.5
User Rating:


Contributed by: BipedcasseroleBipedcasserole
(others by this writer | submit your own)

It's very rare and probably even more inappropriate, but the first thing that came to mind after I heard that Epic was putting out a new Clash record was: "Who do they think they are? Tupac?" Just like the late Mr. Shakur and his deceased, bullet-riddled rival, Biggie Smalls, the Clash seem to keep .
iTunes StoreAmazon


It's very rare and probably even more inappropriate, but the first thing that came to mind after I heard that Epic was putting out a new Clash record was: "Who do they think they are? Tupac?" Just like the late Mr. Shakur and his deceased, bullet-riddled rival, Biggie Smalls, the Clash seem to keep releasing a new album every few years, despite the fact they've been "dead" for more than a decade (literally, at least in the case of Joe Strummer, conspiracy theories aside). In 1994, we got Super Black Market Clash, a fantastic collection of rarities spanning the group's career. 1999 saw the emergence of From Here to Eternity: Live, which was a powerful reminder of just how untouchable the Clash were on stage. Nearly ten years later, we're served another reminder with Live at Shea Stadium.

Recorded on the second of their two-night stand opening for the Who in October of 1982, Live at Shea catches the Clash ostensibly at their best, but secretly in turmoil. Topper Headon, the stellar fellow behind the kit on albums like Give 'Em Enough Rope, London Calling and Combat Rock, had just been booted from the group for his addiction to smack. He was replaced with Terry Chimes, the band's original drummer, as heard on their self-titled debut. The entire band was busy struggling with their newly acquired stardom, and it wouldn't be long 'til Strummer forced Mick Jones to quit under the pretense that Jones was a sellout wannabe pop-star pansy. Add to this the pressure of playing to about 72,000 rabid, rain-drenched New Yorkers when they started out playing tiny clubs in England, and you'd think no group would be able to put on an even half-decent performance. But if you think for a minute that the Clash wouldn't bring it, you're a fucking idiot.

Like From Here to Eternity, the set list for Live at Shea covers every album the group had released. The Clash really were one fucking amazing live band, able to reproduce the same sounds they'd recorded on their albums, but so often deviating into extended jams, alternate progressions and, most importantly, some unbelievably charismatic ad-libbing by Strummer.

After a patently British introduction by band henchman Kosmo Vinyl, Strummer takes the mic, says "Welcome to the Casbah Club," and the first haunting quarter-notes of "London Calling" stab the night air. The first thing modern listeners will notice is the pristine quality of the production, especially Paul Simonon's thudding bass.

London Calling is revisited with performances of "The Guns of Brixton" (featuring Simonon's half-retarded vocals), "Train in Vain," "Spanish Bombs" and "Clampdown." Unfortunately, the relatively simple "Clampdown" comes off as a bit jumbled, and Strummer sounds nothing less than exhausted. "Spanish Bombs" also suffers slightly, with Strummer and Jones unable to reconcile their harmonies.

Heavy on hits, the group breaks out "Rock the Casbah" nine tracks in. For anyone wondering what their biggest hit would sound like without all the ludicrous `80s sound effects, synths and laser noises, you'll be pleased to know it manifests itself as a straight-ahead rocker, and is one of the night's best numbers.

Sandinista! saw the band experiment with a variety of strange and ill-advised sounds. Shea Stadium saw them experiment with the set list, breaking into the mellow "Armagideon Time" halfway through a groovy rendition of "The Magnificent Seven," and then going back into the original number after a prolonged jam and a Strummer advisement to "Extinguish all reefers."

The Clash shine on "Police on My Back," a great cut from Sandinista!, "The Guns of Brixton," "English Civil War" and "Career Opportunities." The crowd finally goes apeshit after the opening chords of "Should I Stay or Should I Go," a massively popular song for some reason, and the band responds kindly, rounding out the night with energy and some garbled Spanish before closing with the always-killer "I Fought the Law."

Again, one of the best parts of any Clash show is Strummer's goofy, impassioned ad libs. Shea saw no shortage of them. On "Clampdown," Strummer professes a desire to "practice chemistry" on "72,000 guinea pigs in Shea Stadium." He also recommends some exercise after "Police on My Back," saying "You'll find if you move you won't get rained upon...Yeah, ask your neighbor what that's about."

All in all, you can't fuck with the Clash. Even though the set list might be a bit heavy on hits for diehard fans, this was a night that witnessed the band catch up with their endless ambition, though the folks in attendance might have been somewhat undeserving of seeing such a performance. From Here to Eternity had the luxury of picking and choosing from a plethora of shows, making it superior as an album. But as a timepiece, as an aural snapshot of the apex of one of history's greatest bands, Live at Shea gets the job done. It's just a shame the band fell under the gun just months later, just like 'Pac and Biggie after they found their niches. Unfortunately, it was the Clash who turned the pistol on themselves.

 

 
People who liked this also liked:
The Clash - London CallingNOFX - CoasterDescendents - Milo Goes To CollegeDillinger Four - C I V I L W A RThe Loved Ones - Keep Your HeartAgainst Me! - New WaveOperation Ivy - Operation Ivy [reissue]Dead to Me - Cuban BallerinaBouncing Souls - The Gold RecordJawbreaker - 24 Hour Revenge Therapy

Please login or register to post comments.What are the benefits of having a Punknews.org account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on the stories that interest you
  • Rate music and bands and help shape the weekly top ten
  • Let Punknews.org use your ratings to help you find bands and albums you might like
  • Customize features on the site to get the news the way you want.
Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not respon sible for them in any way. Seriously.
lushj (November 14, 2008)

I broke down & got this yesterday- the neat-o book version!

It's really good, and hearing "Rock The Casbah" that way was sweet!

bryne (November 12, 2008)

I think "Guns of Brixton" might be my favorite Clash song.

lushj (November 12, 2008)

I love the Clash, but is this really worth getting? "From Here To Eternity" was sweet- is there a version of "Know Your Rights" here? The one on that live record may be my favorite.

P.S.- The vinyl version of "From Here To Eternity" was really really sweet- it was gatefold, with full color inner sleeves. What's the vinyl look like for this one?

maverick (November 12, 2008)

I've listened to this album so much over the past month (and even more in the past week since I picked up a copy on vinyl on Election Day), it's absurd. Such a great set from the band, considering the circumstances (70,000 people not really giving a fuck about you; pouring rain; inter-band tension; a new/old drummer).

I do disagree with your assessment of "Rock The Casbah," though -- it sounds like a bar-rock cover band's attempt at the song, mainly because Terry didn't write it and thus didn't get the nuances of the rhythm. The song definitely suffers from Topper not playing on it.

Other than that quibble, this live set is awesome and is one of my favorite records of the year, no question. Killer packaging on the CD, too (the vinyl, not so much).

-Scott

bongsmcj (November 12, 2008)

i really want to listen to this sometime very soon...

paulrulzdood (November 12, 2008)

pretty cool review. the clash kick ass. i'd buy this but i tend to listen to live albums once or twice then file them away. even Social D live at the Roxy and F2F Live. i just tend to prefer studio recordings or actually being at a live show. i don't know why anyone would care to read this, sorry. scores for the clash.

WYOR (November 12, 2008)

I would bone this record.

Autosuggestion (November 11, 2008)

Let's not equate a band deciding to break up with people getting murdered.

And let's not equate the official release of the recording of a 26 year old well-known live concert with releasing countless unknown posthumous new material.

FUCKINGFUCKINGFUCKING (November 11, 2008)

I think it's gay.

sumwon (November 11, 2008)

Topper is so much better than Terry. Not to bash Terry, he is a fine drummer. But Topper was brilliant. Easily the most talented member of the band. The Clash weren't the same without him. Download some 1981 bootlegs to hear the Clash at their best.

Still, this is a good product. Its just not great like the Clash were with Topper.

desc (November 11, 2008)

it is not the first "big clash live record." The Clash: Live from Here to Eternity was a huge, lavish live package that came out in 1999. It was curated from multiple concerts.

Problematiclogic (November 11, 2008)

I say this in my local record store today. Then I bought some Lemuria and Elvis Costello. Good times.

DrGunn (November 11, 2008)

i think it's a shame that the first big clash live album that draws from one show (from here to eternity is from a ton) is from a stadium setting, which is kind of an awkward one for the band. i'll still probably get this though.

in biggie's defense, i think he's only had two posthumous albums versus like a million for tupac.

jBakunin (November 11, 2008)

The sound on this is awesome for a 25 year old bootleg.
I thought Casbah was the weakest track on this. It sounds flat without Topper on drums.

chrisafi (November 11, 2008)

Rock the Casbah is not their biggest hit in the UK, that'd be London Calling, but yes, it actually sounds good without all that digital crap

Score is for the review, good context but little bit blow by blow

Exclusive Streams

Sponsored


The Fest 13

Newest Reviews

Punknews.org Team

Other Places to Go