Top 10 of 2004 - Aubin's Picks (Cover Artwork)

Top 10 of 2004

Aubin's Picks (2004)

staff picks


2004: A year in 365 words

I don't have any quotable observation about 2004, it came and it went, though not without a little fanfare. Politically, the US Presidential Election had us nervously flipping channels, and the Iraq war continues unabated despite the Administration's best claims otherwise. There were some great books, like Phillip Roth's The Plot Against America and some lousy TV like the abysmal season so far of the West Wing, and the similar plummet of South Park from inspired satire to weak straw man jokes.

The dead horse of pop-metalcore/emocore reached an ever greater strata of popularity, the true innovators of this genre, and every genre were still in full force. Aggressive music took many steps forward with inspired recordings from Pig Destroyer, Dillinger Escape Plan and Planes Mistaken for Stars and pop-punk saw great releases from the likes of Green Day.

But besides all the great new records this year, 2004 was an especially great year for classic records, with many of them finally recieving the kind of lush treatment they always deserved. While some labels went a little overboard by reissuing records less than a year old, others produced beautifully packaged and definitive versions of recordings like London Calling, Dear You and Weezer's Blue album. went into it's fifth year and while we saw the departure of long-time friend and co-conspirator, Scott Heisel, our newest editor, Brian Shultz has more than capably filled his ample shoes (figuratively of course, Scott is a big guy.) We also launched our new version of the site, which besides being an incredibly nerve-wracking experience for me, was a great way to respond to your suggestions and comments about the old site.

And while it's certainly been an eventful and exciting year, it has unfortunately been also punctuated by tragedy, for another year, we lost too many people. One particularly sad loss was that of John Peel who remains the most important DJ since the dawn of radio, and I doubt any broadcaster will ever come close to matching his legacy. Progressive music has lost its greatest advocate and biggest fan. We'll miss you John.

Anyway, without any further ado, here is my list, as always in no particular order.

Top Albums of 2004
Pig Destroyer: Terrifyer
Astounding complex, powerful and violent. The record that could very well bring grindcore into the mainstream. Well, maybe not the mainstream, but probably Hot Topic.
Dillinger Escape Plan: Miss Machine
While not as bleeding edge as Calculating Infinity, a record which saw the hardcore math-metal pioneers achieving new levels of melody and accessibility while doing their part to revitalize heavy music. Again.
Isis: Panopticon
The masters of athmospheric, narrative metal return with another alternately explosive and delicately beautiful release.
Green Day: American Idiot
A band so consistently creative, catchy and plain fun that it's sometimes hard to imagine how they manage to succeed at it year after year. Another successful reinvention of their sound, and a rock opera which is neither indulgent nor annoying.
Descendents: Cool to Be You
Fat Wreck Chords
Hardcore for the skinny, glasses wearing geek inside you. I'll say what I said in the original review: “the Descendents don't need to change the world of music with Cool to Be You. They already did in 1981.”
Snow Patrol: Final Straw
Strong melodic indie rock made ever more special by insightful lyrical musings that demonstrate one of the few nuanced views of relationships in emotional music.
Planes Mistaken for Stars: Up in Them Guts
No Idea
Another dirty, ugly and beautiful classic from a band that is finally starting to get the attention it deserves.
Muse: Absolution
Yes, vocalist Matthew Bellamy sounds a lot like Thom Yorke, but besides that, the Radiohead comparisons are undeserved. Baroque instrumentation and Sabbath-esque riffing combine beautifully to make a record that is energetic and prententiously lush, but in the best possible way.
Rise Against: Siren Song of the Counter Culture
While it didn't grab me as quickly as Revolutions Per Minute, over time, the impact and passion of the record grew on me. A truly impassioned and exciting record from a band which has gone from obscurity to one of the most loved hardcore/punk bands around in a handful of years.
Mono: Walking Cloud & Deep Red Sky Flag Fluttered And The Sun Shined
Temporary Residence
The heir apparent of noise rock like Sonic Youth and My Bloody Valentine, but infused with a classical sensibility allowing effortless segues between gentle melancholy and crushing feedback. Achingly beautiful and unforgettable.
Honorable Mentions
Brian Wilson: Smile
Mastodon: Leviathan
Bad Religion: The Empire Strikes First
Arcade Fire: Funeral
Menomena: I Am the Fun Blame Monster
Flat Earth Society: Isms
Champion: Promises Kept
Cult of Luna: Salvation
Nasum: Shift
The Secret: Luce

Best EPs/Splits
Alkaline Trio/One Man Army: BYO Split Series Volume
The best material from both the Trio, and One Man Army in years. It's a shame that it turned out to be One Man Army's swan song.
Meshuggah: I
Fractured Transmitter
A veritable “greatest hits” of the band compressed into a single twenty-one minute track. Effectively combining all of their incarnations, from their first great record Destroy Erase Improve, through the polyrhythmic grandeur of Chaosphere with the esoteric range of Nothing.
The Casket Lottery: Smoke and Mirrors
Second Nature
After a series of unconventional and interesting post-rock releases, the Casket Lottery released arguably their strongest and most refined offering to date with Smoke and Mirrors. Unfortunately, all signs point to the fact that it is likely their last as well.
Gatsbys American Dream - In The Land Of Lost Monsters
Talented, creative and thoroughly unique. I've heard the band spent one and a half months recording their full length compared to the five days spent on the EP and I can't wait to hear what they'll do with all that time.
Taken: Between Two Unseens
Another band that broke up too soon, melodic, heavy hardcore and strained vocals. It's hard to explain what makes them different from the glut of bands playing this kind of music, but dig them up, give them a listen and you'll see.
Best Reissue
The Clash: London Calling
In a year which had a surprisingly high number of quality reissues from major acts like Weezer, to obscure but brilliant ones like Coalesce, one stood far above the rest, the painstakingly thorough reissue of the London Calling which includes both the remastered original, a bonus disc of demo tracks and odds and ends, and a interesting and compelling DVD presentation of the recording of the classic record. No fan of punk rock should miss this one.
Mix Tape
  1. Psyopus - “Death, i”
  2. Pig Destroyer - “Gravedancer”
  3. The Secret - “Memento Mori”
  4. Nasum - “The Deepest Hole”
  5. Lamb of God - “Blood of the Scribe”
  6. Old Man Gloom - “The Volcano”
  7. He Is Legend - “The Seduction”
  8. Dillinger Escape Plan - “Panasonic Youth”
  9. The Haunted - “99”
  10. Meshuggah - “I”
  11. Rise Against - “Give It All”
  1. Snow Patrol - “Wow”
  2. Menomena - “Cough Couging”
  3. The Killers - “Mr.Brightside”
  4. The Thermals - “How We Know”
  5. Death from Above 1979 - “Romantic Rights”
  6. Arcade Fire - “Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)”
  7. Jimmy Eat World - “Drugs or Me”
  8. Owen - “Note to Self”
  9. One Man Army - “All the Way”
  10. Green Day - “Give Me Novacaine”
  11. The Casket Lottery - “On the Air”
To paraphrase that dark wordsmith, Jerry Seinfeld:
Well, the new year is merely symbolic of how another year's gone by and how little we've grown. No matter how desperate we are that someday a better self will emerge, with each flicker of the candles on the cake we know it's not to be. That for the rest of our sad, wretched, pathetic lives, this is who we are to the bitter end. Inevitably, irrevocably. Happy New Year? No such thing.

That cautionary statement aside, at least 2005 will have some great new music with new releases expected from many bands like Alkaline Trio, Meshuggah, Gatsbys American Dream, Paint it Black, Chixdiggit, Thrice, Propagandhi (!), The Esoteric, Comeback Kid, No Use for a Name, Millencolin, ...And You Will Know Us by the Trail of Dead, Weezer and many others. So despite the ominious quote, the new year just may be a good one.

As for me, I'll still be here, hope you'll be here too.