Tonight We're Going To Give It 35%

Punknews content is syndicated to a handful of your favorite social networks, including Twitter, Facebook and Tumblr. Join our Last.fm group and contribute your listening habits to our weekly charts. All of our high definition video footage can be found at Vimeo.

Here's your question and answer of the week from the Punknews Formspring:

Q: 1) In your opinion, what was the best series of sampler comps (e.g. Hopelessly Devoted to You, Fat Music, Give Em' the Boot, etc.)? Why?
2) Should Fat Wreck do another Short Music for Short People?

A: One of punk rock’s great assets is its legion of fantastic comp albums. Comp albums work particularly well for punk rock because the songs are usually short, so you get a whole bunch of different flavors rapidly, and also that punk bands can sound extremely different form each other, making each track especially unique.

As to the Fat Short Music comp, I like that comp a lot because it really magnifies what makes the bands on it either seem so great or so lousy. Some band’s 30 second songs are so good they feel like they are 5 seconds and you play the over and over for like 10 times in a row. But, other bands just seem so bland that their 30 seconds feels like five minutes. Plus that comp is cool because it has a lot of unique tracks/mixes of songs, which is always fun.

I’m not sure a sequel would be that great, at least for me. The comp seems set in the 90’s to me, so a sequel just wouldn’t seem as unique or fun. Plus, that comp had a lot of the legends on it- Black Flag, GWAR, The Damned, Dwarves- and even Green Day, Rancid, NoFX, and those guys in their prime, so it would be tough to compare. Though, I’d love to see another comp based around a theme.

As to comp series, there are a lot of really, really awesome ones. Fat Music for Fat People was good, but for me, it was a little too monosonic. I kind of like the harder nastier punk. Hopelessly Devoted to You didn’t quite have the hits, I think. I was a big fan of the first three Hell Cat Give em the Boot series. I liked how those comps had a really big range of sounds- from ska to Leftover Crack to F Minus to Rancid to actual Dancehall to pop-punk (AND AN EXCLUSIVE JOE STRUMMER TRACK!)- though I think after #3, it got a little weaker. I listened to #1-4 a few months ago, and while some of the songs might be a little cheesy, overall, that series holds up very strongly.

But, my very favorite comp series is the fantastic Rat Music for Rat People. Exclusive live recordings of Black Flag, Dead Kennedys, Bad Brains, DOA, Flipper, Circle Jerks, Avengers, TSOL, Fang, Minutemen, MDC, The Dils- just hit after hit after hit after hit. Plus, all those bands are in their prime and are completely on fire. Really amazing stuff. Not only is rat music #1 one of the best comps of all time, it’s one of the best albums of all time.

What comps do you like? There are A LOT of phenomenal single volume comps- Let Them Eat Jelly Beans, The Decline, etc etc etc etc etc. -John G

Of course your day wouldn't be complete without knowing every inane detail of your humble editors' lives. Follow @aubinpaul, @adamwhite, @johngentile, @ameliaaacline, @kiraface, @mcflynnthm, @andywritesstuff, @wackymondo, @Brittastrophee and @BrittStrummer's every move at Twitter.

The People Must Have Something Good To Read

In the past few weeks we've spoken with a number of bands and artists. Don't miss out on these interviews:

• Divided Heaven
• Have Mercy
• Brian Walsby as part of our Rad People who Make Rad Art series
• Stefan Babcock of Pup
• Gnarboots
• Dave Frenson of Banquets and Black Numbers